There are lots of misconceptions in your posting. First of all, The deal is nothing but US and India Specific. Please do not have any other view to this, even if it is not very Specific about it. Please go through Mr. Kakodkars assertion yesterday telling that "India should be Allowed to Import Reactors from other Countries". What do you mean by this?
Secondly, the Hyde Act was passed just to contain India and the same will definitely be applied against India. Not just this act, but there are some more coming that would be acted against India, if India wishes to go its own way.
Do you think the US will honour in letter and spirit all those what is written there in the 123 Deal. Yes she will do so, as long as it suits her. The moment she thinks any thing against her benefit, those are simply dumped. And no one can tell a word against this Super Cop.
Logic do not apply to the US. It has its own logic to go by.