Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
RE:RE:Give Bharat Ratna to Manu
by Rajiv Sundar on Jun 01, 2007 12:33 AM

Here is a bit of background on this matter

Law wise -- the Gujjars are OBC. But they find it difficult to compete with Yadavs, so they are fighting to be classified as SC/STs. The Meena (the community to which the police officers accused of violence belong to) are SC/STs and do not want the Gujjars to compete against them.

But here is the interesting part -- traditionally, NONE of the castes involved have suffered due to Casteism. They have all been tremendously powerful within society at various times. The Gujjars and the Meena both belong to the Kshatriya Varna have actually been Rulers.

Unfortunately, because of reservations, even the thought of fair competition and selection by merit has died (since it is easier to change the law use reservations to get ahead instead of working hard or by being better qualified).

A society without meritocracy naturally tends towards the use of unfair means. Any surprise that such a society is more violent?

Arjun Sign, Periyar and co knew that the path they were laying was going to produce chasms in the country and would result in an uglier society. And yet the knee jerk reaction to blame Brahmins, who are of the few people who do not rely on reservations and have no interest on whether who remain as OBCs or who becomes SC/STs.

Blaming Manu or Brahmins in this case is outright ridiculous in this case.
Gopal Krishna %u2013 next time, it would help if you try to understand a subject before you comment on it (Wikipedia and Google n

    Forward  |  Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Deadlock with Gujjars is over