Rediff deleted one of my questions as abuse. Rediff allows any unjustified criticism against hindus while even paointing out verses in Quran is treated as "abuse".
Your clarifications are not the least bit satisfactory. Putting to death surrendered people is against all norms of humanity. Prophet Muhammad should have overruled Ibn Salam's decision. Would u like America do the same to surrendered muslim soldiers?
Ibn Salam knew what Prophet wanted and decided accordingly. Being with your leader for a bit of time, one can make out his likes and dislikes. That was the acse with Ibn Salam also.
More than justifying all this to me, whats important is u justify to your conscience.
