I believe its a fair decision considering some of the decisions the other convits have recieved. The judge was fair in pointing out that it was just not the act of possessing a fire arm but also in convincing others to help him destroy it which is also a crime. The judge also was right in pointing out that Dutt was in constant touch with Mr Ibrahim and had attended Dawoods Party knowing very well who they were. And guys possesing a fire arm is different and possessing a AK-56 is different. Its a weapon of mass distruction a purely offensive weapon. Also Mr Dutt was somewhat aware of what was being conspired with regards to the bomb blast and yet did nothing about it. Imagine how many lives could have been saved if the police would have been informed about this possible scenario. I feel sorry for Mr Dutt as what he did was in his reckless young days of drinking and drug addiction but a crimes a crime and the law is the same for everyone. But we will agree that the Mr Dutt who commited the crimes and the one going to prison for em are 2 completely different individuals , cause the earlier sentence had done its part in reforming the guy into the Dutt we know today. I just hope Mr. Dutt has the will power to sail through these rough times and emerge a more accomplished man. May he have the wisdom to emerge throught it all victorious.