Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
RE:RE:RE:Rebuttal to Shenidh's arguments
by Shenidh on Feb 26, 2007 10:16 AM

Mr.Secular,

Sorry for the late response. Becuase I do have full time job and I write my comments only in spare time unlike you as your full time job is writing comments here :)

Now coming back to your reply, do you really read what I reply to you? If you read, do you really understand my simple english? In my earlier reply I had clearly replied you that he was already called by the arabs as "Al-Amin" i.e trustworthy even before his prophethood. He had won their trust completely. He didn't need any more time after his marriage with Khadija(RA) to win Arabs trust. And this is the fact. Nobody has denied that. Just because you are not ready to accept it, it does not mean that fact will change. That's why I told you are like a revolving object which does not change it axis. I hope this time you will not try to pretend as stupid and keep on repeating your baseless claims about the prophet(pbuh). Also, where did u get this claim that he had mental disorder at 40? Are you insane?? Do you have any proof for this claim? Try to be realistic. Don't you think these are your own imaginary views just to defame Islam and prophet(pbuh)?

Anyways, below are answers for you other questions that you posted in your later comments

Once again please provide the proof that
1. There is a GOD
The proof of God is achieved through using your own logic. I will give an example. If you were walking in the middle of the desert, and come across a beautiful watch, and the watch has the exact time displayed, just because you don't see anybody around in the desert, you cannot say that something as accurate and flawless as this watch doesn't have a creator. You know
that somebody made it. Similarly, if you look around you, the solar system, and how it works flawlessly and perfectly to the second, the ecological system, and how perfectly it works in sync with each other, so much so that if you abuse one part of it, you are damaging the rest of the system, when you see these things, but don't see a creator, you still know that something so perfectly made HAS to have a creator, just like that watch!

2. it is a HE
In Islam, we don't believe God has a gender. The word He is used because there are only two forms in Arabic, male or female, we have to use either one.

3. There are angels
If we believe from the above example that there is a creator, then we must believe what the creator tells us, and he tells us there are angels, so we believe it.

4. Koran was "Gods" word dictated to Muhammad.
The Quran itself challenges people to prove otherwise! It is a flawless book, with no contradictions. Even if you believe that there are contradictions, those seeming contradictions have a very logical explanation. Nothing in the Quran goes against modern scientific theory. Amazing considering it is 1400 years old, and presented to us by someone who couldn't read or write!

5. That Islam doesn't divide the world into Dar-ul-Islam and Dar-ul-Harb and that it is the duty of every Muslim to bring Dar-ul-Harb into the fold of Dar-ul-Islam, with explicit instructions of using any means possible and killing mentioned explicitly.

Actually there are three distributions. DarulIslam, Darul-Harb, and Darul-Aman. DarulIslam=Islamic rule. DarulHarb means that
society or government that is striving to eliminate Islam, Muslims are obliged to raise arms against them. DarulAman means that place where Muslims are allowed to live peacefully under non-Muslim rule, they must live according to the rules and regulations and laws of that country. This simple distribution of DarulKufr and DarulIslam is incorrect, otherwise Muslims
would be fighting in every single country that they lived!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
The truth about Aurangzeb