If the BJP rode the anti - incumbency wave to win in HP, why is it that the Congress could not ride the same anti - incumbency wave in Gujarat? How is that the BJP is able to ride a 5 - year anti - incumbency of the Congress as against the Congress' inability to ride a 12 - year anti - incumbency wave in Gujarat? Where are the Abhishek Singhvis, Jayanthi Natarajans and our own Sahadevan to defend this flawed argument?