This was a very balanced article taking into view both the pros & cons ublike a few other columnists who are downright biased one way or the other. I totally respect the credentials of the author. However, I would disagree with his conclusion that the Indian voter must decide. First because elections will not be held solely on this issue..for that you need to have a refrendum..a practice not prevalant in India. Also, for a technical deal like this, a voter however educated he may be...is not equipped to judge the technicalities of the deal. It should be left to the nuclear scientists & political leadership...as has been done now.