Dear Praful, Who are you to complain about McCarthyism? It is always the left which has practiced this terror tactic, never allowing other views to be aired. Now that the shoe is on other foot, you are crying? Anyway, except in some so called left leaning circles what is your credibility? And as for charges of Indian left being stooges of China, it is so transparent that their ranting is helping China and it does not need any further proof.