I agree with most of your points Samira. I agree Muslims in India and abroad have made huge contributions towards society. But your saying that Muslims have had a bad deal since 1947 is not right. India is a third world country. Indians from all religions have had a tough time. And many have succeeded irrespective of their religion. There are successful people in India from all religions. If Indians were so biased towards religion, would we have Muslims as some of the biggest stars in bollywood. I don't know of any private company that does not employ the qualified personnel whatever religion he may belong to. Instead of complaining , maybe we should concentrate on getting education to the poor of this country irrespective of their religion. Peace.