V.P.Singh had blotted his copy book with his Mandal slant ages ago and with that gone into the realm of irrelevance.Regardless of his efforts to resurface and the efforts of a discredited section of the political spectrum to resurrect him,say what he might,he continued to be kept in the dustbin of history For once,he has a point.He is making it well.There is logic.There is substance.There is real concern for the welfare and the integrity of the nation The dubious nuclear deal with the USA needs to be scrapped forthwith.Lot more seems to be involved than the mere prestige of the ruling party We did not lose lives and get Independance to become the vassal of the USA.Our scientists did not struggle to take us this far in the nuclear field to surrender our achievement to the hegemonical dictates of the USA.If our Scientists can take us this far without the \'assistance\' of the USA why doubt their capability to take us further without the string attached assistance? Why suffer the arrogance of the likes of the US ambassador? Why are the Scientists not being consulted in the first place? Let us go by their advise.Scrap the deal in the meanwhile S.Ramaswamy