Reservations should be based purely on economics. why dont we just get rid of all reservations based on caste and religion and focus on the economically backward. Only people who are below a certain income braket should be allowed to avail of the reservation. Black have reservation in the US and they continue to be poor by and large. So reservation isnt actually the answer. The government has no spine and it keeps whipping up the reservation issue to take our attention away fro its performance, which is pathetic. Muslims need to help themselves. No community has ever progressed using a crutch. Muslims need to stop having a negative feeling about being victimized and start foxusing on their strengths. Muslims have a great deal of resilience and are incredible artisans in india.