Well tht ws long time ago and rediff posted the results and almost evry1 one said mohanlal shud have gottn the award. Haven't seen the movie.
But, havin watched black i fail to see why bachan got the award for over the top acting, and it wsn't alzheimer's disease bachan ws essayin but it ws parkinson's disease. Evn aamir khan himself statd tht bachan did go ovr the top for his role, whn tht role required subtle portrayin.