The evaluation system is definatly wrong. The very purpose of appointing judges is defeated.With Judges with high calibre were just show pieces. Mr Javed Akhtar has rightly said that people are listning by their eyes. if at all the performance of public is to be considered a formula should by designed in which public response will be calculated by percent votes (only one SMS per mobile ) this should not be disclosed to judges. Judges should give points may be on 0 - 10 scale. This percentage should be clubed with public vote percentage & a winner / loser should be declared. Some refining will have to be done in this process but atleast professional will select deserving candidates.
