I am not very sure about terms but i think there is a differnce between reviewer & critic. reviewer job is supposed to produce comments on the what movie is all about and what do it offers. It is critic's job to find the flaw in movies. So if this is all what u says review it's ironical & u must open a new link of critic in ur movie section to put these reviews. I think ur reviewer have set very high standards that he expects from an indian movie. Then i m giving u a suggestion please go to hollywood & write reviews only for hollywood's movies & leave we nonintellectual people on our fate. It was very clear from the promos of movie that it is going to be emotional drama & the same it served. Perfomance are good. Every person has different taste but this critic thinks he is the best person to judge which movie one should go & which they don't. And ya one more thing that i rmbr is 4 years ago u have published very outstanding reviews for YEH KYA HO RAHA HO because director(or writer,not sure) of that movie had been associated with you before doing this movie. And that movie was just average in perfomance & storyline & flop at box office. Contd. see part 3..