One fails to understand why people are blaming mamta banerjee & her party for exit of tatas from singur.When she was on indefinate strike Buddhadeb gave her assurance of talking & than she broke the jinx of her fast,when initailly being asked by buddhadeb babu why before making any commitment to tata he did not consulted oppostion or gained their confidence his reply was'WE ARE 235 THEY ARE 30'.This man's (buddhadeb) over confidence,self ego had brought bengal in black listed state for industrial development not mamta alone.