1. Films produced in Mumbai are watched by whole India and producers earn from across the country 2. The Actors do not earn because they live in Mumbai but because they are liked people across the country and they pay hefty price to watch their films. 3. Salaries for Private sector companies employees are not paid from what Maharashtrians consumer but what the whole nation consumes. Therefore the corporate tax paid by Mumbai belongs to whole nation and not just Mumbai or Maharashtra Solution Every Private Sector company shall be asked to spell out what is each States contribution to their Sales and give each state its share in the company. As nobody else is asking for quota Maharashtra with the logic will get on an average 8%-10% quota and shall be happy with that.