Sudhir, it is very clear he is a communist by the way he talks. To comment about his father being a BJP corporater, what would you say for Somnath Chatterjee's father who was in the RSS? There are many examples like these but one do not need to assumpt "if we dont know them, why comment on them". Guha is certainly a communist, or rather i should say, an opportunist - as all commies are. If India is surviving even today, if India has survived the past, and if India will successfully survive the future, it is solely because of Hinduism - not the 'ism' that our corrupt politicians (right from Gandhi, Nehru to the present ones) have defined. Hinduism is the culture every individual in this whole subcontinent has in his blood. It may have been distorted now, but it does exist in most of them. We perform pooja when we bring home a new computer, we believe in god rather than brakes, and that certainly makes India tick. Opportunists like the Corrupt Congress, Caramchand Gandhi, Communists, Christians -- all are C's have indeed made and are still making our great nation feel "down". As rightly put in one of rediff's earlier articles - When communists departed as Chinese Agents and Russians agents, who are Indian agents? - we need leaders like Savarkar, Sardar Vallabhai Patel, Chatrapati Shivaji etc. An iota of those characters can be seen in Modi who is being unsuccesfully trampled by indian media. Communism will surely see its death soon which is very clearly visible. Look at the