I know tastes differ, but this is a good example of how much it can differ! I lived in Bangalore very near to Sethji's cafe for a few months, and the food was absolutely tasteless, bland and over-priced, to put it mildly! While the art display outside is just about ok, the ambience is nothing but that of a mediocre cafe, and I've had better aaloo-parathas even in my college mess(and you all know how most college mess food is!).
Maybe the critic went to Sethji's on a date with someone special who made the moment feel so beautiful that even the tasteless fare that was served there seemed delicious to her. :-)
Anyways, if you want to blow up 30 bucks on below-average fare, visit the place.