Agree with you. Old versus young doesn't count. Just see how Warne, Macgrawth and Gilchrist has shown the way. Buth they all are AUSTRALIANS and none of the great INDIAN players have shown the willpower and attitude to make a mark in IPL.
So the debate is not of young and old. The debate is that our fabulous four (or five, whatever you call them), are not good enough to play for T20. I think next edition of IPL will benfit at least 5 newer talent from India, as Fab 4 (5) have shon their inability to adapt and are total failure in IPL.