I think we should look at a good captain as the moment L. Rajput was sacked from Indian coach Kumble's decisions have been wrong. Gary Kirsten has been the reason for defeat with Kumble after batting on a green top. BCCI gets a Aussie as coach b4 Australia's India tour and SA as a coach b4 SA tour. This is sheer stupidity as these whites will always support their country by leaking / misleading. I have no hesitation in questioning the committment of Chappal earlier and Kirsten now? Why are we criticising poor Sourav? He was playing a gem of an innings in Sydney till he was cheated by the umpire while India tried stared at defeat. Have we forgotten his fighting innings in fast South African pitches like J'berg against same 2 bowlers 150km plus with Nel as the 3rd? He was again playing another lone chanceless gem till cheated by the umpire at Motera unlike fashion parade of Dhoni with 2 missed catches and one missed stumping by Boucher. In tests we require a good lower down w-k bat who can play with responsibility when chips are down instead of throwing his bat and Dhoni definitely did not try that. That he got a 50 was pure luck while that Dada missed his century due to the Umpire was pure bad luck.