Yeah in first place looking at karthik's record, he was not fit to be in the playing 11. his last 5 inning scores are: 1, 0, 4, 2 and 0. He has played 26 ODI's and has scored a mere 330 runs with an average of 22. If he plays at any position , he cannot play well. what had he done at 5/6? He cannot play strokes at his will, he has to wait for the bowler to bowl a lose ball and which aussies seldomly bowl. what did team mgmt gain after replacing dravid with karthik, nothing karthik scored a big ZERO