There are reasons why Kirsten might get the nod for the India coach.
Besides his vast experience and outstanding record as a player, Kirsten is relatively very young still. In fact, Sachin Tendulkar and Anil Kumble had made their international debut much before he came on the scene.
That could work as a two-edged sword, with Kirsten having retired only three years ago well aware of the demands of international cricket but might well find it difficult to command respect from the Indian players, many of whom he has shared dressing rooms with.
But the BCCI may choose to see the glass half-full at this point in time.