I dont know whether it is right or wrong to send Irfan back, the time will tell. For me he should have been in the second test insted of VRV Singh, which would have strengthened the batting lineup a bit. And might be in the seaming conditions of SA Irfan wd have proved good. Also Gautam Gambhir should have been in the team insted of non performing Shewagh. This could have given us advantage in the opening slot by playing a lefthander. If atall sending Irfan is a good desicion then it should have been 'send back Shewag,Sachin & Irfan'. Sachin's one fifty in a yr doesn't do any justis to his caliber either.