No, not at all, its a foolish thing to send pathan back who is having all rounder skills, the winning rate of india was increased when pathan joined the team few years back.
If that is the case, players who are not form need practice, then what about Sehwag and Kaif, both have got countless chances in one days when they are not scoring enough runs.
But player like pathan needs to get more chances, by giving him chances only he can improve, its a big foolish thing to send pahtan back, he is a up coming all rounder, i expected this back chappell is doing a foolish thing, may be pathan is not having any big hands behind him thats y he is sent back,
I want to share one thing with bcci if possible, on which criteria basis they are giving chances to players, if pathan is not in form then what about veeru, kaif, jaffer and vrv. Is vrv more effective than pathan, no way he is having only speed but no length.