Sending back Pathan was a knee jerk re-action. Considering his age, he should have been retained back. One learns by watching too. Its not as if he is not trying. Besides he hit the first century of the tour. On present batting form, there are others who should have been sent back ahead of Pathan. The move is reminiscent of what the Pak cricket board used to do with its captains till the recent past. Now that he is back, what he needs is a stint with Mr.Lillee. Not another Ranji game.