RE:Any dipute between State election machinery and legislature should be settled by Judiciary
by sriram s on Mar 28, 2008 12:42 PM Permalink
CONGRESS SHOULD BE DISMISSED
RE:RE:Any dipute between State election machinery and legislature should be settled by Judiciary
by Mahmood Hasan on Mar 28, 2008 12:46 PM Permalink
VILAS IS VERY HUMBLE & HONEST CM, THERE MUST BE SOME EC FAULTS WHICH LEAD HIM TO JAIL
RE:Any dipute between State election machinery and legislature should be settled by Judiciary
by tejaswi pai on Mar 28, 2008 01:22 PM Permalink
If vilas is honest CM then why does the state have so much corruption. Its like the way the leader is the state will be the same. Sweet words and velvet glove does not mean he is a honest CM
RE:Any dipute between State election machinery and legislature should be settled by Judiciary
by sunder on Mar 28, 2008 12:47 PM Permalink
These politicians made the British Raj dwarf.
This is a shamefull incident, where an officer is made to suffer just b'coz he is not a toe-licker of CM n politicians n does his duties honestly. The CM n whole assembly shld now be sent into the jail for this behaviour.
RE:SHAMEFULL....!!!
by jagar singh on Mar 28, 2008 12:59 PM Permalink
state election commissioner is a constitutional authority.i think they may even imprison governor not withstanding constitutional provisions.
for state it is Chief Electoral Officer, for central it is Chief Election Commissioner, do emply better jurno's whos has some knowledge about our constitutioanl bodies.
RE:Re: Nanad Lal
by jagar singh on Mar 28, 2008 01:03 PM Permalink
you are wrong ,kumar.state election commissioner is meant for local body elections under state panchayat laws.,whereas chief elction officer works for assembly and loksabha elections.they are different people.
Since, the state Assembly Acted unanimously, therefore, it seems to be good a decision, became imperative in order to curb the high handedness of beaurocrates. Since Public Servants always strive to travel beyond their powers and jurisdiction, therfore, it will work as a lesson to such minded peoples. In India, there is devision of powers and functions and therfore, none should transgress into the affairs of others and to ensure smooth functioning of the system, the appropriate laws were framed by law makers. This time a particular law, framed for meeting with such menaces, has been acted upon. Thats all, then why such hue and cry are being made?
RE:Breach of previlege
by ram mohan on Mar 28, 2008 12:28 PM Permalink
I am a hater of Narendra Modi.BUT if this action was done by Narendra Modi and Gujarat Assembly,all including you,the media,the secularists must have already made this int a VERY BIGGER ISSUE.
RE:Breach of previlege
by Secular India on Mar 28, 2008 12:43 PM Permalink
you are right.... Modi sneezes and everyone thinks he has murdered. I am sure more farmers in Vidarbha due to lousy government policies die in a month than in all the riots which have happened allegedly with Modi's support !
RE:Breach of previlege
by S Bandyopadhyay on Mar 28, 2008 12:31 PM Permalink
It is not clear from the article,what is the offence and why he was punished.Why he did not seek legal remedies? We want learned legal opinion about the same.
RE:Breach of previlege
by sameer bhosale on Mar 28, 2008 12:32 PM Permalink
Are you a judge,Mr.Ali? How can you decide that Mr. Nandlal has acted beyond his powers.It may be possible that to teach a lesson to an upright beauricrat,all the politicians have come together.It doesn't mean that the politicians have taken right action.You and me cann't decide this.This case should be decided by the Supreme Court.If the upright noncorrupt officials get such treatment,then it will discourage the young talented persons to enter into Govt.services.
RE:Please help
by Vishy on Mar 28, 2008 12:34 PM Permalink
please leave immediatly, its b'coz of cowards like u we are in this state. Please leave so that we are able to rebuild the country
This is what will happen if you give keys to the chors,The democracy is being exploited by the politicians in such a rampant manner and with such authority,where they have a protection on what ever they do in the assembly,If an EC who is in the position of a Governor status can be insulted ,then what more can we say of these idiotic politicians who can stoop to any levels.
