from the time of Nehru. ministry of external affairs is a big joke. what a bunch of crackpots. India need not have recognized tibet as a part of china. india doesn't need to support one china policy . all those people in MEA are people who wet thier pants every night. why do they need to make all this stupid mistakes. India at minimum has nothing to say about Taiwan and then Tibet. If they are a bit smart or they have bit sympathy for Tibetians they should side with US and support for betterment of Tibetians.
India under Nehru made big mistake of allowing China take over Tibet. All along Tibet was a free country and never under the rule of China but unfortunately Nehru did not understand that. The time has come for us to correct this wrong. We should give all the support to TYC and declare India is for a free Tibet. If Indian government can not overtly do it it should support TYC covertly. It is in the interest of India that we keep China away from our border and hence we should support TYC. Also I am happy after so many years Tibetans have given up the useless non-violence struggle. In 50 years nothing has moved in its favour and in the future too nothing is going to happen. China will do every thing to sabotage the non-violent struggle of the Dalai lama.
RE:India should support TYC
by arungopal agarwal on Mar 26, 2008 02:29 PM Permalink
We are not dare enough to talk about Arunachal and China occupied Kashmir-what you say is theory.
It is realistic to wait for a suitable time to get independence. Tibetans should understand India's commitment to them. They should not drag the situation to a level where that can ruin India's relation with China. In fact, this problem was the root cause India's first war with China in 1962, especially when Dalai Lama came to India. India is always committed against colonialism. It is true that China conquered Tibet by force, and indeed it was and is not a part of China.
But the Tibetans should restrain from taking the agitation to streets. They have to learn from the experience of countries like Georgia, Latvia, Estonia who were able to liberate themselves from the Soviet Union. They should be little more patient and should be smart. Military communism followed by the China or the ex-Soviet Union is dangerous than colonialism which was followed by countries like Britain, France. Tibetans should realise this and act accordingly. They should understand that an Indian citizen who believes in democracy always supports their cause.
Communist militia always behaves cold-blooded. History has witnessed in past many a times. The brutality displayed by the Khamer Rouge in Cambodia killing millions, the acts of Soviets in Hungary, Afghanistan is beyond condemnation. Fidel castro was some what better compared to those people. Even in India we are witnessing the barbarian acts of the communists, in Bengal & Kerala. Therefore Tibetans should not take the path o
RE:Learn from the struggle of countries like Georgia, Latvia, Estonia
by JGN on Mar 26, 2008 02:57 PM Permalink
Mr. Ram Chandra, what about somebody bombing Iraq in the name of non-existent WMDs, using chemical weapons in Vietnam or dropping atom-bombs in Nagasaki and Hiroshima? Were they also "commies" ???
RE:Learn from the struggle of countries like Georgia, Latvia, Estonia
by avtar priyadarshan on Mar 26, 2008 07:43 PM Permalink
aint sure about that but u surely one....
RE:Tibet
by pr adiseshu on Mar 26, 2008 02:09 PM Permalink
your second point is incorrect,now tibet position main culprit was india nehru was responsible for this situation. now his party also don`t help tibetens you see dalailama position also same as tasleema comingdays.indian politisians are .5 persons.they afraid chainese they can do nothing.
RE:Vaj pee
by Narasimha Swamy on Mar 26, 2008 02:24 PM Permalink
It was Nehru who said so and all successive governments in India are following the same policy unfortunately.
RE:Vaj pee
by Manjula A on Mar 26, 2008 03:18 PM Permalink
That is because the country is still governed by Aryans and Aryans have no feelings towards this ancient land or towards Lord Shiva. All they are bothered is about their Ram. They sold out the Indus Valley sites to Pakistan and Kailash to Commmie Hans. All they protected were the stupid gangetic planes that breed nothing but poverty and ignorance. Until the power comes from the hands of these foreign Aryans to the hands of the original Indians, such things are natural.
RE:Vaj pee
by Vas on Mar 26, 2008 07:52 PM Permalink
Are you one of them 'original' Indians? Good Lord - and to think I mistook you for just another chimp swinging from tree to tree.
By the way, leave Lord Shiva out of this, you LTTE dravida piss-pot. And, any selling out of hindus and hinduism has been done long ago by your anti-hindu scum-bag Karunanidhi and his band of dacoits, and his numerous off-springs from various women - he thinks all hindu gods are complete nonsense (while pretending to be an atheist and carefully hiding the cross he wears under his shirt). His attitudes towards Hindu gods would make him the biggest anti-Shiva & and anti-Muruga. Care to liberate TN from the clutches of the dacoits first? Or are you too busy selling cocaine in the streets of Amsterdam?
RE:RE:Vaj pee
by AG B on Mar 26, 2008 04:24 PM Permalink
Ah! here comes another divisionist. Leave alone caste, region and religion - now Aryans, Dravidians etc etc just to prove that the other person is bad and self is superior. the notion of indian comes only when another country attacks - because when war comes prices go up and there could be emergency. Out of selfish fear join the bandwagon of chest-thumping Bharat Mahan groups. The moment peace is there hark back on divisonist themes and ask for reservation. Do we need these kind of citizens??
No country in this world has got independence through non-violent methods from an oppressor including India. So if Tibetan people want independence then their best chance is fight for it at the opportune time i.e. when China is weak and not when it is powerful.
RE:Wait for opportunity
by gac on Mar 26, 2008 01:43 PM Permalink
true, there is no freedom of independence without bloodshed. its high time tibetans have to shed their religious ideology of non-violence to get they want, otherwise they will ever have to wait for freedom under dalai lama as their leader with his non-violence ideology.
RE:Wait for opportunity
by XianYe on Mar 26, 2008 02:13 PM Permalink
Good. This way the Chinese security forces have ample reason to mow down the thugs with an iron fist. The Chinese security forces, and Chinese abroad, should certainly do something to shut up the two US citizens of Tibetan origin. I am in full agreement with you. Let's start the bloodshed and let the blood spill into Indian territory. Any territory that harbours forces of hostility towards China is considered a legitimate target.
RE:Wait for opportunity
by Rama Ganesh on Mar 26, 2008 10:58 PM Permalink
Dear Xian or whatever you are! If you are imagining that you can win over tibet by using force you are living in fool's paradise. You can only win temporary victories through such methods. Your deeds will catch up with you sooner or later. And don't ever imagine that you can get away using force and letting the blood spill-over into India. You are being watched by the big brother, the US, who is waiting for a chance to get at you. You have already given them one on a plater, Taiwan. If this is your mentality, be sure of seeing more Taiwans around you. And I promise you my friend the day is not far when you will see China breaking up like the Soviet Union. You can save your breast beating till then.
