RE:China has no moral authority.
by ghanchakker on Mar 19, 2008 08:46 PM Permalink
communist in india are not a political force as such to say that they are doing nothing against alleged chinese aggression has no relevence !what about other leading political parties such as BJP and others why are they silent? why can not they march along with refugee protestors in india! why is US silent too!and what does the holy dalai lama thinks?does he think that it is chinese who have started the reign of terror on tibens then why he says that all violence by tibetans be stopped immediately otrher wise he will resign as the leader of the exile government of tibet and will no more be the tibetan leader against chinese rule!
If India wants to solve Kashmir issue. Then India must allies with USA. US is real democracy and their national interest not harm India. India allies with western world will make India as superpower.
Same time India have to use tit for tat policy for China as
China has boundary issue to nearly all their neighbour. No one can trust on China.
Fact is violence is the only Solution Tibet problem. For that Tibetean have to take weapons in hand. India must provide weapons to Tibetan. As China supplied to Pak and NE-militant.
India have to supply nuke to Taiwan.
India and US need to support east-Turkistan freedom movement.
India and US need to support democracy movement in China which will leads to civil war.
Once Tibet liberated from China, India and Tibet have to take initiative to merge Tibet in India. Because of same culture and ideology.
RE:MY TIBET
by Fried Yakov on Mar 19, 2008 08:50 PM Permalink
I do not know whether I am correct, but I feel that only Tibetians can help themselves. It is not worthy to practise non violence with a monster like China. The Tibetians should adopt the policies followed by the Vietcong (I am sure that communists all over the world, including in India and China, will approve of those tactics as they did when those tactics were used by the Vietcong), and work to throw away the Chinese oppression. I know this may be against the Tibetian ethos, but even the Vietnamese are largely Buddhists and 50 years of non-violence have not produced any sense of shame in the Chinese dragon. It is time perhaps for the younger generation of Tibetians to chalk out a more pragmatic and decisive course of action.
RE:RE:MY TIBET
by Shesh Lak on Mar 19, 2008 08:54 PM Permalink
Fries, You are right. Chinese didn't pardon anyone involved in tiananmen square incident then Tibet is a far dream. Non violence will not have any solution. Only tit for tat can do.
RE:MY TIBET
by Shesh Lak on Mar 19, 2008 08:51 PM Permalink
Bingo, You are getting too ambitious. Let Tibet be a separate country. We can always have a open border policy with them but no merging .. heheheh We are posting messages as if Tibet is liberated :-P
Is the issue sympathy for Tibetans or apthy towards Indian communists? If Indian communists oppose the Chinese aggression is Tibet going to get liberatsd? The super powers and the whole world for that matter in just making meek calls for the justice for Tibetans but no one cares to strongly oppose the Chinese action for the sake of their own selfish interests or lack of true interest in Human Rights. All the so called powers that be have a black spot about their own backs what will they say of China. The Rediff readership in largely rallying behind Tibetan cause out of hatred of their own Commies and Govt than China. Hipocracy of the stragest order.
RE:Why concern about Indian Commies
by Srinivas on Mar 19, 2008 08:37 PM Permalink
Let them firts do that. They were ready to bark on US is quite on China. Indian comunists didn't oppose China when there is war between India China. Indian comunists are anti national
RE:Why concern about Indian Commies
by TruthOne on Mar 19, 2008 08:43 PM Permalink
I think China doesn't care a damn what the Indian Commies say or don't say. They are just nobodies for China when it comes to its own interests and trust them least. Indian commies also know it too well.
RE:Why concern about Indian Commies
by Srinivas on Mar 19, 2008 08:38 PM Permalink
Truth is very hard to digest that CPIM is and CPI are anti nationals to support China even they can sell India
RE:Rediff is mouth piece of CPIM and congress
by ghanchakker on Mar 19, 2008 08:39 PM Permalink
on what basis are you saying this? please inform us what your leaders are doing for tibetan refugees? why can not they march along the tibetan refugees in india in support to their cause!
RE:Rediff is mouth piece of CPIM and congress
by ghanchakker on Mar 19, 2008 08:41 PM Permalink
on what basis are you saying this? please inform us what your leaders are doing for tibetan refugees? why can not they march along the tibetan refugees in india in support to their cause!
I find that many contributors on this site hate China more than they love Tibetans. Old Lama regime was a feudal regime with massive inequalities and oppression. Whether Chinese provided a better alternative or not is a debatable issue. But romanticizing Lama theocracy defies any logic
RE:Romanticizing Lama Theocracy Defies any Logic
by Astute Analyst on Mar 19, 2008 08:40 PM Permalink
I am not a CPIM supporter and am a PhD student in a decent university. I have a deep respect for Buddhism and a great fascination for Tibet's history and culture. My friend, the life of an ordinary Tibetan was horrible before Chinese occupation. It might not have improved under the Chinese rule. But if I were a Tibetan, I would want democracy, neither chinese rule nor Lama rule.
RE:Romanticizing Lama Theocracy Defies any Logic
by ghanchakker on Mar 19, 2008 08:56 PM Permalink
is the issue in this forum is hatered to communists or Tibetan issue? and who are you to decide that who is nationalist and who is antinational?do u think that bagat singh was a antinational or that chanderShekhar was not nationalist ? and the india bouregise middle class that wants to leave india and settle in usa and western countries nationalists? this so called middle class and its leaders who while showing their hatered towards towards communists and purchasing of course thru bribes and illegal money by depriving poor indians of their rights only buying Chinese TVs , Moboiles , washing machines and festival lamps during festivals only choinese ! i ask all bourgese middle class indians and i mean you mr. srinivas will you stop buying chinese products and lead a movement thru your leaders against Chinese products in india and ask indian Govt. to ban chinese products!
RE:Romanticizing Lama Theocracy Defies any Logic
by ghanchakker on Mar 19, 2008 08:41 PM Permalink
communist in india are not a political force as such to say that they are doing nothing against alleged chinese aggression has no relevence !what about other leading political parties such as BJP and others why are they silent? why can not they march along with refugee protestors in india! why is US silent too!and what does the holy dalai lama thinks?does he think that it is chinese who have started the reign of terror on tibens then why he says that all violence by tibetans be stopped immediately otrher wise he will resign as the leader of the exile government of tibet and will no more be the tibetan leader against chinese rule!
RE:Rediff is mouth piece of CPIM and congress
by ghanchakker on Mar 19, 2008 08:40 PM Permalink
communist in india are not a political force as such to say that they are doing nothing against alleged chinese aggression has no relevence !what about other leading political parties such as BJP and others why are they silent? why can not they march along with refugee protestors in india! why is US silent too!and what does the holy dalai lama thinks?does he think that it is chinese who have started the reign of terror on tibens then why he says that all violence by tibetans be stopped immediately otrher wise he will resign as the leader of the exile government of tibet and will no more be the tibetan leader against chinese rule!
I find that many contributors on this site hate China more than they love Tibetans. Old Lama regime was a feudal regime with massive inequalities and oppression. Whether Chinese provided a better alternative or not is a debatable issue. But romanticizing Lama theocracy defies any logic
