RE:indians and slave labour
by JGN on Jun 27, 2008 03:04 PM Permalink
Mr.Rhazes Ashrawi, such things happen in other countries also. This month's Reader's Digest has an article about a 12 years old girl from Egypt (a country following the divine laws and most merciful creator!!!!!!!) sold to a couple from that country whoo migrated to USA, for 30 USD a month and the hard-ships she had to undergo in US at the hands of her employers. The girl has been rescued and the couple is awaiting punishment (smilar to the case under discussion). She even refused to talk to her father due to his inhuman treatment.
RE:RE:indians and slave labour
by salim on Jun 27, 2008 04:39 PM Permalink
Mr.Atheist,if a person commits a crime ,would you accuse the legal system for that?
One doesnt become a muslim by birth,he becomes one by following islam.I remeber some time back you quoting muslim honor killings to some how suggest honour killing is part of islamic belief system.I argued that it is the influence of bad culture,now you would have seen so many honour killing within especially asian communities regardless of being a Muslim,sikh or Hindu
RE:RE:RE:indians and slave labour
by JGN on Jun 27, 2008 06:29 PM Permalink
I had never written anything about "muslim honor killings" I had mentioned the case of Mukhtar Mai (that too was reported in Reader's Digest about 6 months back)when one Mr. Balaord was waxing eloquent about his religion.
If the nature of human-beings cannot be changed even in countries following the "divine laws" for more than 1400 years, forget about reforming the "kafirs"! Pl read the article "Is god a plain dope" at Postive Atheism. Also visit the web of "Actual Freedom - the third alternative" to know more about the basic reasons for the human-behavious and how to over come that. This is an alternative to organized religions.
RE:RE:RE:indians and slave labour
by JGN on Jun 27, 2008 06:13 PM Permalink
>>>>>>>>One doesnt become a muslim by birth......do you mean that a person become muslim only when a small portion of a particular organ is cut-off or if he blows himslef up "in the cause of Allah"? The reply was to the post of one Mr.Rhazes Ashrawi. don't jump to conclusions.
RE:RE:RE:indians and slave labour
by JGN on Jun 27, 2008 06:15 PM Permalink
honour killing by the followers of any religion (whether Muslim,sikh or Hindu) is an obnxious practice. The law of the land should be respected by all. I do not hold any brief to defend any religion.
Bias is definitely there, or re diff is stupid because this is what happening everyday to indian maids in the Gulf. I definitely feel that the punishment was just, but why do you make a big issue of that, why not look around and then see other communities practicing worse than slavery in the Gulf that too openly. Why not report it everyday, and mind you most of them at the other end are Indians.
RE:What about the same happening in the Middile East
by Sathish N on Jun 27, 2008 03:20 PM Permalink
Basheer, Don't think he is justifing the wrong. His argument is that it is not an just an Indian issue. It is an issue with all humans.
RE:What about the same happening in the Middile East
by JGN on Jun 27, 2008 03:06 PM Permalink
Forget about maids, even small boys are sent to theWest Asian countries as Camel jokeys, that too for the entertainment of the followers of the "most merciful creator" !
RE:What about the same happening in the Middile East
by amitabh badchalan on Jun 27, 2008 04:46 PM Permalink
And who sells them most of them are hindus who sell their child....the creations of"most lustful creator"
RE:What about the same happening in the Middile East
by JGN on Jun 27, 2008 06:17 PM Permalink
Pray, let us enlighten us about who are selling their minor daughters at Hyderabad and Calicut to toothless Arabs!
RE:What about the same happening in the Middile East
by JGN on Jun 27, 2008 06:56 PM Permalink
amitabh badchalan, so you are admitting that there are other "creators" also. Good.
the punihshment for Ms. vARSHA would be to treat her in the same way as she treated the two maids.She must do all the brutal things herself so that she can understand the maid's plight and the sufferings.
It is a matter of shame that an India born couple should resort to torture, slavery of Indonesian domestic help in USA. They fully deserve the conviction meted out to them. It is indeed an eye-opener that such despicable practices are prevalent in a free and enlightened democratic country like USA. Thru their uncivilized acts Mr and Mrs Sabhnani have also tarnished the image of Indian origin persons settled in the USA. I am unable to understand what makes the people indulge in such barbarous acts. Perhaps some readers may offer some light on this.
RE:slavery of domestic help
by Bharath raj on Jun 27, 2008 12:23 PM Permalink
Never trust the chinese or indonesians,they are most horrible people in this country and jealous of Indians.They can go to any extent.
RE:slavery of domestic help
by beerappa Gowda on Jun 27, 2008 12:35 PM Permalink
u r blaming the poor maids why r u glorfying the shamelss indian lady who came from Mahatma gandhi's land
RE:slavery of domestic help
by swamy on Jun 27, 2008 12:53 PM Permalink
right, no tears for the b**tch, let us reserve it for our heroes like ManeckShaw
RE:slavery of domestic help
by vishal potdar on Jun 27, 2008 04:48 PM Permalink
Please Sabhnani are sindhis and sindhis are not indians but pakistanis. so no doubt they created this act. No indian would dare to do this outside india, cause there no one would be able to protect you as in india you can get out of every crime you create.
if we follow the same judgment in india, i think we might need a whole town to jail the offenders. in india we still have 2 culturally develop to avoid slavery, bonded n child labor.
you go to any bihar, up , mp, rajasthan and all over north india , this is happening in india , poor indians work in richin dian houses, with all kinds of tortures , when we go are going to put these rich people behind bars, unless government gives 100 % education to all poor and help themit wont happen in the near future.
RE:slave
by Naveen Bhatt on Jun 27, 2008 12:06 PM Permalink
And there is no difference with South India. Let us not be biased. I see tons of slavery and inhuman cruelty or complete disregard for the poor in all southern states.h
