First: Will somebody kill 2 people just because he was humiliated. Will he be ready to risk his life, future, everything to settle a score. Not a strong motive in my view.
Second: Will Hemraj allow Raj Kumar to force himself on Aarushi when he knew Dr Talwar and his wife are sleeping on adjucent room. I mean will he not consider the consequences after that. Won't he consider what if Aarushi screams or what they will do after the act has been done.... Will they simply leave or will they kill Aarushi so that no one comes to know about it???? Before deciding to be a party to all this won't Hemraj would have known that this may lead to killing of Aarushi??? So was he ready to take the risk. Sounds unlikely.
Third: This story of CBI is too simple... Why did it take so long for a reputed institution like CBI to finally crack it.
Fourth: Why CBI also inititally pointed its suspecion towards Dr Talwar then and his custody was increased? Why did CBI keep on saying that Dr. Talwar is not co-operating and is hiding things. If this was the case there is nothing for Dr. Talwar to hide.
Guys, Small people like Krishna and others are being made scapegoad in this whole mess. CBI has to save his face or worse is acting on high command's instructions which is to protect someone influential.
RE:What is this SHIT
by Indian Dictator on Jun 26, 2008 03:30 PM Permalink
Good, you've got 4 points! Please read some Agatha Cristie Parot's, Sherlock Holmes, Karamchand(TV serial, an old one), Vyomkesh Bakshi stories and you'll be able to draw some more points!! CBI is a byproduct of corrupt Politics. Scotland Yard would've been solved this case in a week or so..
RE:What is this SHIT
by Nana on Jun 26, 2008 03:12 PM Permalink
Sherlock Holmes;.....Join the CBI sorry SBI...I mean State Bank of India..your analysis is fit for that..and not CBI..
RE:What is this SHIT
by Rajanikant Chaturvedi on Jun 26, 2008 03:42 PM Permalink
It is rediculous and CBI is not doing this kind of mess first time. They intially make case complicated and drag it for few days then suddenly will give judgement like this. Fodder Scam, and many other scams are proof of it. Pepole still NIHARING the result of Nihari Case yet. which also end abruptly.
RE:ddd
by Pranab M on Jun 26, 2008 02:57 PM Permalink
Please bear the cost of narco test then , request to Govt please stop wasting tax payers money by conducting farce narco test again and again .
If CBI & Police are unable to find the truth after conducting so many tests,Please leave Krishna and Dr. Talwar to pubic. They can find the truth within 10 minutes.
RE:Leave them to Public
by jhumpalahiri on Jun 26, 2008 03:27 PM Permalink
Send them all to bihar. public pitayee will unfold the whole story within minutes.....
Hi Guys,Here is the Simple logic to think,Can u find out who will be the real Murderer? 0) Murder timing & date,whole India knows as well 1)Ek Room me Parents so rahe hain aur dusre room me Aarushi aur teesre room (Servant room me ) Hemaraj aur uske saathi party mana rahe hain. 2)Party ke Baad,Jab Aarusi ke Room Me Rajkumar Jata hai aur Molest karne ki Kosish Karta hai aur peeche peeche bache huwe 3 log bhi ander ghushte hain.
3) Jab Aarushi ka Rajkumar ne molest Kiya tab woh kyun nahi chillai??????? 4) Jab Ghar me 4 log party mana rahe hain,tab Talwar family ko kyun kuch bhi pata nahi chala???? 5) Jab Hemraj Darr jata hai,aur complain karne ki dhamki deta hai,to USKO tarrace par le jaya jaata hai?? Here is the big question Mark,woh bhi chilla sakta tha,jab usko chchat le jaya ja raha tha....kyun......????? 6) Aur abhi tak Talwar family media ke saamne kyun nahi gidgidaye,dono kyun chuppi saadhe huye hain? 7) Aur jo sara Indian ne jaana ki Murderer is her father only, what was all about that story? 8) Why CBI is not taking actions agaisnt false story? why has been that headlines across India without any base? there must should be something, which still mysterious so far. I know sarasar ek bholabhala Nepali Ko fasaya jaa raha hai, kyun ki,there is no any evident for the right culprit. I COULD HAVE SOLVE THIS MURDER MYSTERIOUS PROBLEM IF GIVEN ME A CHANCE.
REST ALL ARE AWARE.........../EVERYDAY NEW TWIST,HEADLINES,STORIES, Desh me ek sabse bada majak banake ra
RE:Ek Nepali,Ek Revenge Aur Dursa Lamba Murder Mysterious daily headlines.
by Hirak Som on Jun 26, 2008 03:01 PM Permalink
U r right Dilip. Yeh story kuch hazam nahin hua. Totally baseless. Krishna ko fasaya ja raha hay. Coz Talwar has raputation in ministry level. CBI go to hell.
RE:Ek Nepali,Ek Revenge Aur Dursa Lamba Murder Mysterious daily headlines.
by Chota Chetan on Jun 26, 2008 02:52 PM Permalink
you are absolutely right...
6ft kee doori par 4(Hemraj, Shabhu, Rajkumar , Krishna) log khade hain....aur murder kar rahe hain... Maa Baap so kaise sakte hain...
RE:Ek Nepali,Ek Revenge Aur Dursa Lamba Murder Mysterious daily headlines.
by Chota Chetan on Jun 26, 2008 03:03 PM Permalink
not only they murdered the two people but they changes the computer password... deleted the photographs from camera... cleaned the room... locked the door upstairs... flushed the khukri...(the most hilarious theory) locked the front gate .. and fled away.. ... ..
RE:Ek Nepali,Ek Revenge Aur Dursa Lamba Murder Mysterious daily headlines.
by Arun George on Jun 26, 2008 03:30 PM Permalink
You tell me how a domestic help learnt to change the password of the computer. Nice joke of a story. They are only 'leaking' the story to the media to see if it is believable. If none of you guys would have spoken out. This would have been a final version. Now that you guys have poked so many holes in the story, we can expect the investigation to go on.. and on.. and on... Incidentally that is the time-tested , fail-proof tactics of our system. Or maybe there will emerge a sudden 'killer' from somewhere..hehehe.. keep watching this hillarious investigation.
RE:Ek Nepali,Ek Revenge Aur Dursa Lamba Murder Mysterious daily headlines.
by dilip patnaik on Jun 26, 2008 03:02 PM Permalink
guru..ekta kapoor ko niya script writer ke juro rat hai....
BC aj kal kam bam heni hai
talwar ke beti ke mout hoe hai..jab teri sath is tara gathana hoga ..analysis karna
It is plain common sense to thank that no servant will dare to host a wanton drinking session with other servants, when the master of the house (Dr. Talwar) is around. One more stupidity is that the killed girl's room was kept open and 3 people were molesting her and torturing and killing her with deadly weapons, and no screams were let out and the master and mistress never heard any voice?.
Even a mild earhquake can shake the sleepy and make them run. Third nonsense is after killing Arushi they killed Hemraj; and all these went on without any disturbance to the dentist couples? What was the average time taken for all thse; may be 2 hrs?
Even agreeing that they were in deep sleep after getting tired from a deep copulation, these shocking violence and bloodshed in the small apartment never alerted them; hard to digest as doctors are supposed to be extra alert and sensitive to the slightest changes in their environment.
It is nothing but a contract killing. And the mobile phones, killer cloths, phones went missing eternally? Even gifting a camera days before her death, can't it be signalled as a parting shot by the parents?
I doubt Dr. Talwar is not her biological father as the birth is from artificial donors. Check the blood groups. May be his property, they don't want to pass on to her. So before this rebellious girl becomes a major, she had to go from the scene. Who must be the end beneficiary, his brother, colleagues cum extended family members?
RE:Non-Sense Theory
by Rajendra Mudale on Jun 26, 2008 03:01 PM Permalink
I agree, i too suspects Arushi may not be Dr. Talwars biological daughter & after knowing, he got provoked & killed her.
RE:Non-Sense Theory
by Ramakrishnapillai Nair on Jun 26, 2008 02:46 PM Permalink
The compunder and the male servants had a few drinks and when one is booze one can turn into a beast and that is what happened here. The reason for the confusion is that Krishna is inconsistant in his confessions and the Weapon could not be located.This is not CBI's fault.Some murders are so complex to solve,they are like the synopsys of Hitchcock movie.
