It is seen that these activits keep changing their names to confuse the police.Accordingly it becomes essential that "Biometric" identity of all those detained and even of complete ex-SIMI activists be made and computerised. These details can be shared by various state govts. investigating agencies though special dedicated networking. It will reduce harrassment of innocent youths.
Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) was formed in Aligarh (Uttar Pradesh) in April 1977. In the last 10 years SIMI has been slapped with several bans and scores of its members put behind bars. In the last 17 cases against SIMI, all accused people have been acquitted. Former SIMI president Shahid Badr Falahi was arrested in three cases and has been acquitted in all. The last time he was acquitted was in July 2006.
They say, government don't provide enough "proof" to justify ban on SIMI.... why don't government presented all articles on rediff about SIMI? It "reveals" their working, ideology, modus oprandi and "guess and opinons" of " Investigation agencies"...Infact recent " Indian Mujahideen" was suppose to be SIMI VERSION 2.0 what else they want???
RE:news
by BALA R on Aug 07, 2008 01:23 AM Permalink
if those who gave cerdicts in courts had the taste of their mother/father/wife/sister/bro/son/daughter killed in the recent blasts...will they give such verdicts???-Bala, Toronto
RE:SIMI is not antinational
by prasanta chatterjee on Aug 20, 2008 05:04 PM Permalink
hahahaaa..well said!!i believe if kashmir is given to pakistan take baluchitan and sindh from them. if not attach sindh and create unneccessary disturbance there.
The High Court has clearly stated that the evidence submitted by the prosecution (read Government) is just not sufficient. The Prosecution had 7 years and all the Government's powers and yet it could not provide the required proof. All arrested and detained by the police have lost 7 years of their lives and they have to start all over again. The hardship, torture and harassment they have faced! WHAT will recompense them??
RE:SIMI - GUILTY TILL PROVEN INNOCENT
by Sagar Das on Aug 06, 2008 05:19 PM Permalink
We should recompense them, by hanging them publicly? Is that good or, need to stone on them and brutally kill them?
Which option is better..? And also few supporting politicians of this country.
Am not specifying the names which are genuinely good guys.
RE:SIMI - GUILTY TILL PROVEN INNOCENT
by Spread TheWord on Aug 06, 2008 05:40 PM Permalink
Seems like the majority think the HIGH COURT is wrong in its judgement. Thats how much respect we have for the law of the land. All the commentators want the SIMI to be hanged when the HIGH COURT has exonerated them. Good - We dont hang people by public opinion!!
RE:SIMI - GUILTY TILL PROVEN INNOCENT
by koteswara k on Aug 06, 2008 03:40 PM Permalink
by reading your concern,I would like to advise Osama Bin Laden also to ask compensation for his lost public life from US.
RE:RE:SIMI - GUILTY TILL PROVEN INNOCENT
by irhad on Aug 06, 2008 04:00 PM Permalink
innocent till proved guilty Govt, police army had poor record of conviction
RE:more death
by KTK Branch on Aug 06, 2008 12:53 PM Permalink
absolutely correct. Anyone can't do anything because of some selfist hindus supporting them. They are simply puting word communal.
RE:more death
by joseph on Aug 06, 2008 03:16 PM Permalink
utkarsh mehta, your words are nonsense and useless, you really an idiot. Why u worry when big butcher in seat, nothing to worry , this is politics we are spreading some hatred to gain votes for next election that all.
Some comments on this board exhibit total ignorance and stupidity of the writers. One is appalled. All this TODAY. When you can just GOOGLE and WIKI up anything under the sun. One writer believes that CIRCUMCISION reduces the size of the penis ! What the ???? Another - Muslims eat Pork !. Just where do these guys come from??
I WOULD HIGHLY ADVISE SIMI TO MAINTAIN STATUS QUO AND REMAIN UNDERGROUND. THIS IS A PLOT BY THE GOVERNMENT TO TRACE SIMI MEMBERS ONCE THEY SURFACE ON LIFTING THE BAN. WE KNOW THAT SIMI WAS JUST A NORMAL STUDENTS ORGANIZATION AND WAS NEVER INVOLVED IN DESTRUCTIVE ACTIVITIES, BUT THERE ARE SOME ELEMENTS IN OUR SYSTEM WHICH CANNOT BEAR THE FACT THAT AN ISLAMIC ORGANIZATION IS DOING SOCIAL WORKS. THEREFORE, PLEASE TAKE CARE AND DO NOT RE-GROUP FOR SOME MORE TIME.
RE:RE:I advise SIMI members to remain underground
by anjana varma on Aug 06, 2008 04:36 PM Permalink
you are absolutely rite. i totally agree with u ...
RE:I advise SIMI members to remain underground
by Reformer on Aug 06, 2008 06:30 PM Permalink
Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) was formed in Aligarh (Uttar Pradesh) in April 1977. In the last 10 years SIMI has been slapped with several bans and scores of its members put behind bars. In the last 17 cases against SIMI, all accused people have been acquitted. Former SIMI president Shahid Badr Falahi was arrested in three cases and has been acquitted in all. The last time he was acquitted was in July 2006.
They say, government don't provide enough "proof" to justify ban on SIMI.... why don't government presented all articles on rediff about SIMI? It "reveals" their working, ideology, modus oprandi and "guess and opinons" of " Investigation agencies"...Infact recent " Indian Mujahideen" was suppose to be SIMI VERSION 2.0 what else they want???
RE:Media's role
by Spread TheWord on Aug 06, 2008 12:38 PM Permalink
The High Court has clearly stated that the evidence submitted by the prosecution (read Government) is just not sufficient. The Prosecution had 7 years and all the Government's powers and yet it could not provide the required proof. All arrested and detained by the police have lost 7 years of their lives and they have to start all over again. The hardship, torture and harassment they have faced! WHAT will recompense them??
RE:Media's role
by kayan on Aug 06, 2008 01:07 PM Permalink
What will you compensate to families whos bread winner s were killed by stupid jihad bomb attacks?
RE:Media's role
by shirdil on Aug 06, 2008 01:13 PM Permalink
Mr spread u r right these simi young boys were beaten black and blue by policeTheir testc were squised like tamotoes. they were made namard.Now what their wivies will do This is true fact.I reas this in some urdu weekly. Now I requst the govt of India and states to compensate them with atleast 10 lakhs.They do need sympathy of our Muslim brothers. they should be given free ticket by Air Indias to Haj
RE:Media's role
by Reformer on Aug 06, 2008 06:32 PM Permalink
Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) was formed in Aligarh (Uttar Pradesh) in April 1977. In the last 10 years SIMI has been slapped with several bans and scores of its members put behind bars. In the last 17 cases against SIMI, all accused people have been acquitted. Former SIMI president Shahid Badr Falahi was arrested in three cases and has been acquitted in all. The last time he was acquitted was in July 2006.
They say, government don't provide enough "proof" to justify ban on SIMI.... why don't government presented all articles on rediff about SIMI? It "reveals" their working, ideology, modus oprandi and "guess and opinons" of " Investigation agencies"...Infact recent " Indian Mujahideen" was suppose to be SIMI VERSION 2.0 what else they want???
RE:Media's role
by pokala sreekanth on Aug 06, 2008 07:42 AM Permalink
Muslims in India never eat Pork , infact they like Cow meat . Letus not talk about thier personal likes / traditions. The issue is about a faction of muslims & other communities still feeling India is a place to Enjoy than , to serve.( Here some logical dude likes to compare lazy Hindus !! .They are everywhere and during the most hatred Hitler times . ) Its patriotism we are talking about. Its high time , we unite under the ferver national interest and eradicate this fanatic movement which is threatening the world over
