RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 06:37 PM  Permalink After reading this,Could you please eloborate on the differences between a real son and the adopted son? Now this is my answer Zainab was prophet cousin,whom he knew her all along.If Prophet Muhammed desired her,he wouldnt have married her too Zaid in the first place. You guys assume as if Prophet Muhamed came to know Zainab through his adopted son,the truth is it is He (Prophet) who arranged the marrage itself and it is because of this Zainab (PBUH) asked Prophet Muhammed to marry her after she divorced Zaid. May peace and blessing be upon Zaid and the mother of belivers Zainab and Prophet.    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Vivek Harry on Jun 02, 2008 06:43 PM  Permalink mr. balaord, think for a moment, can you stoop so low as to adopt a son if you cannot treat him like a son, it is double insult to the poor fellow, then you will understand what Zaid would have felt    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 06:51 PM  Permalink Mr.Vivek.There is a difference between fact and speculation.To assume that Zaid was too upset with Prophet Muhammed doesnt have even a semblance of Truth.Zaid was martyred in the cause Islam and Prophet in the battle of Muttah. The love and affection between Prophet and his adopted son only grew ever stronger every second.It is legenadary in the history of Islam. So please dont throw calumnies based on pure ignorance.    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Vivek Harry on Jun 02, 2008 07:04 PM  Permalink mr. balaord, if the relations between them were so cordial, then your prophet would not have threatened to divorce Aisha and Hafsa, it there in the Quran, what proof are you aksing us for, that means you are not aware of what there is in the Quran, there are hadith regarding this affair between Umar and Hafsa, why should we spoonfeed you, since being a imitator of your founder, you should know about these things    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by JGN on Jun 02, 2008 06:53 PM  Permalink How she could have expressed her displeasure knowing fully well that her life itself was in the hands of Mohammed?    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 06:57 PM  Permalink When ignorance is combined with bigorty,then the only way you can do is to resort to speculation. Prove me that Ayesha was disappointed wife,then I will answer your question. One,only has to look at the married life of Prophet and his wife Ayesha to realize how soulful and how compassionate they were towards each other Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by JGN on Jun 02, 2008 07:02 PM  Permalink Mr. Balaord, Frist prove to me that The Quran was revealed by some most merciful creator. Then we can discuss the rest of the matter. Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Vivek Harry on Jun 02, 2008 07:01 PM  Permalink mr. balaord, why do not you marry your son's wife then    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by abhinav on Jun 02, 2008 06:40 PM  Permalink why did he ban adoption then......??? see khalid one of u r true islamic scholar knows about it..u did not..... anyway baloard...........why did he ban adoption then......??    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 06:46 PM  Permalink There was no ban on adoption per se,but Islam is very categorical in its laws that is a adopted son can never become a true son.This doesnt prevent a adopted father to love the adopted son as much or more than his real son.But by law,the laws of inheritance doesnt apply to him. When Zaid's actual parents came and wanted their son backmProphet Muhammed asked Zaid to go with them if he wishes so,but Zaid refused and asked her real parents to allow them to saty with Prophet Muhammed itself.Thats how the love and affection between the Prophet Muhammed and his adopted son.    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 07:00 PM  Permalink You have missed the point.Though the laws of son doesnt apply to the adopted son,this doesnt prevent one from adopting (without have any legal bearing ofcourse).The proof is there in the life of Zaid itself,he didint go awasy from Prophet Muhammed.Till his death he was with his beloved adopted father.Please know Zaid was martyred in the cause of Islam and for the defence of his prophet. Dont try to portray a disappointed or rebel Zaid.He is a noble man loved by Muhammed and loved muhammed much more. Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Sadique on Jun 02, 2008 06:50 PM  Permalink He did not ban adoption instead after that he banned such marriage which cud be mislead by others.......so that issue itself is lessons to all humankind to avoid any such relations....but u r still taking in negative ways......same for Bibi Ayesha as well the girl get married in 9 years it is true...but the same lady became 1st Muslim scholar woman in the time of darkness when woman was the only for house work and baby sitter....Role of Bibi Aayesha in Islam change the view towards women but still people believe that in Islam women's are only being raped or killed....    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by JGN on Jun 02, 2008 06:52 PM  Permalink Mr. Sadique, you are giving misleading information. The first wife of Mohammed was a business woman (also 15 years older to him). Now a woman cannot get even a driving licence in Saudi Arabia nor can they go out without a male relationship for company. What a great progress!!!!!!!!    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Sadique on Jun 02, 2008 07:23 PM  Permalink I am not giving misleading information dude....Ofcourse first wife of Prophet Mohammed was Bibi Khadijaa she was buisness woman and first woman who accept islam(Bibi Aayesha was first scholar of Islam, please don't get confuse) ...Prophet marry with her when Prophet was 25 years and Khadija was a widow of 40 years which itslef lessons for widow marriage and not leave them to die in society or make sati...however Prophet leave with her till next 25 years as a single woman man...then Bibi khadijaa died...Prophet was 50 years old then and all later 5 marriages where either to expand Islam or to make gud relations with allies or to give shelter to widows...However I don't know why Saudi Arabiya has restrictions but the fact is woman can work (where man are not present), get educated with the Hijaab can rome outside as well......    Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:47 PM  Permalink ABHINAV ITS NOT BANNED BUT THERE ARE SOME GUIDE LINES IN IT....LIKE HE'S NOT HAVING THE BLOOD RELATION WITH THE OTHER CHILD OF THE ADOPTER...SO IF THE ADOPTED ONE IS GIRL ....IT BECOMES NA MAHRAM(WITH ONE WHO CAN MARRY)..... ONLY THE PERSON HAVING BLOOD REALTION CANNOT MARRY AMONG THEM SELVES THEY ARE CALEED (MAHRAMS) BUT I KNOW YOUR FILTHY MIND WONT GET THIS.....    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Ravindra Dinanath Vartak on Jun 02, 2008 06:50 PM  Permalink mR. khalid raza, are you aware that marriage among the sons of brothers and daughters of sisters (first cousins) are common among Indian Muslims? Are they not blood relations?    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:56 PM  Permalink Ravindra...by blood relation it means those who are from your lineage and those fromwhose lineage you are!!!!!others one can marry.... and have you got information about the south indian dravidioan hindus who marry their sisters daughters....???? dont try to abuse the religion Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by abhinav on Jun 02, 2008 06:50 PM  Permalink ha ha haaa........khalid u r reply is the answer...... so he banned adoption to be able to make his marriage with Zayed HARAM.......right......    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 07:00 PM  Permalink You have missed the point.Though the laws of son doesnt apply to the adopted son,this doesnt prevent one from adopting (without have any legal bearing ofcourse).The proof is there in the life of Zaid itself,he didint go awasy from Prophet Muhammed.Till his death he was with his beloved adopted father.Please know Zaid was martyred in the cause of Islam and for the defence of his prophet. Dont try to portray a disappointed or rebel Zaid.He is a noble man loved by Muhammed and loved muhammed much more. Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 06:55 PM  Permalink Any things whihc bears a Arabic name becomes a source of quotation for you guys,thats why you people are oblivious to the science of Hadith lierature. Most of the stories quoted by the orientalists are taken from books written 500 0r 600 years after the death of Muhammed ,known as Sira. The authors of these books simply collected what ever they eard and they have confessed that in their books. Muslims treat only Quran and Hadith (validated by Quran) as the authenttic source. Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Star on Jun 02, 2008 06:57 PM  Permalink Polygamy was the norm at the times of Ibrahim, Dawoud, Solayman, all known in the Bible to have been polygamists,,,,,,, These fickle minded, brainwashed element just look at the seamingly weak points of our beloved Prophet.....    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by Vivek Harry on Jun 02, 2008 06:59 PM  Permalink you also can marry your son's wife    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Mr Khalid.... u have not responded.........why did mohammed marry his own son's wife.......?? by JGN on Jun 02, 2008 07:02 PM  Permalink Yes, of course. Recently a Mullah in UP had issued a fatwa that woman has become the wife of her husband after her father-in-law raped her!!!!!!!!!    Forward   |   Report abuse

Message deleted by moderator

RE:Ask any Muslims: Deobandis, or Teesta Javed Khan Seetalvad- who is resposnible for this? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:32 PM  Permalink Boka chele y dont you run....the last bus to dhaka is ready to take off....if you are left behind the indians will kick you out.....run run run    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator

RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by Star on Jun 02, 2008 06:26 PM  Permalink I dont think we Muslims are in liberty to entertain you with an answer. Chances are the answer is far beyond your comprehension - which incidentally probably also explains why you readily take to worshipping idols.    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:29 PM  Permalink aabhinav you cant even qoute the source of this information!!!!!    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by JGN on Jun 02, 2008 06:27 PM  Permalink >>>>>>>>>>Chances are the answer is far beyond your comprehension!!!!!!!!!!!!    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by Vivek Harry on Jun 02, 2008 06:33 PM  Permalink mr. star, have you forgotten your claim that your black stone can erase sins, how can a black stone erase sins, can you explain please or you want a refresher dose, is this black stone more powerful than your founder because he also could not erase sins, what are you boasting about, cannot you not see the huge fraud at the source of Islam    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by Star on Jun 02, 2008 06:36 PM  Permalink Vivek Harry I STILL PERSIST WITH MY SAME CLAIM THAT WE DONT WORSHIP IDOLS.... I thnk you forgot the precise concept which i had farwarded to you in our last discussion...    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by Vivek Harry on Jun 02, 2008 06:40 PM  Permalink you can make any claim, but your statements are contradicting your claims, you answer the question, how can you claim that a black stone can erase sins, while you scoff at our contention that shivling also can erase sins. according to common sense, only god can erase sins and nobody else, that means based on your claim itself, the black stone is your god, higher than even your founder, now if you cannot understand simple logic than it is not my fault, because you have stopped thinking long ago    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by Star on Jun 02, 2008 06:45 PM  Permalink You are a confused man......... I think you haven't got clear concept or it was beyond your comprehension i suppose!!!!! So forget it and keep on following your blind mythology be an ignorant, Idoltrorous as you guys have been from the eras........ Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by Vivek Harry on Jun 02, 2008 06:49 PM  Permalink mr. star, it is you who are confused, otherwise you would not have made the claim that the black stone can erase sins? If you are so brilliant as you imagine, can you explain how this is possible Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:25 PM  Permalink Abinav where you get this from either from anti muslim sites or from the sanghis proaganda books    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by abhinav on Jun 02, 2008 06:27 PM  Permalink khalid........lot of muslms have agreed to me on this board itself about marriage of prophet mohammed ..... just ask u r muslim scholar why adoption is banned in islam.........u will get the answer.......    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:35 PM  Permalink In islam ONE WHO ADOPTS ORPHANS DOES A MUCH HIGER PRAYER THAN PERFORMING HAJJ. THIS IS WHAT ISLAM SAYS ABOUT ADOPTION..... YOU ARE ASKING ME TO ASK MUSLIM SCHOLAR WHOM YOU ASKED BEFORE POSTING FALSE THINGS....MODI OR RSS???    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by JGN on Jun 02, 2008 06:38 PM  Permalink Yes, Islam has given importance to orphans because Mohammed himself was an orphan. He could think of his own circumstances only. The Quran was meant for the inhabitants of 7th century Arabia.    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:43 PM  Permalink ITS MEANS FOR THE ENTIRE TIME...TILL THE WORLD FINISHES..... WE ARE NOT LIKE JEWS AND XIANS WHO CHANGE THEIR BOOK ACCORDING TO THEIR NEED AND SAY....THAT SOME ONE HAS TAKEN THEIR SIN SO THEY ARE FREE FROM SIN...AND SOME SAYS WE ARE CHOOSEN ONE AND COMMIT CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by abhinav on Jun 02, 2008 06:46 PM  Permalink khalid u r brother Baloard has agreed to the fact of moahmmed's marriage to Zainab.......did u read his reply.......?? Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by abhinav on Jun 02, 2008 06:37 PM  Permalink mr khalid i have posted relevant quranic verses baing adoption in islamm....... here it is again: '"God did not make your adopted son as your own sons. To declare them so is your empty claim. God's word is righteous and constitutes true guidance. (Q.33: 4)."    Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:42 PM  Permalink IT MEANS THE RIGHT OF THOSE ARE NOT AS THOSE OF YOUR OWN SON...AS THEY ARE NOT YOURZ BY BLOOD..... ABHINAV YOU READ THE AYAH BEFORE THIS AND AFTER THIS AND YOU'LL GET THE ANSWER FROM THERE ONLY.... BUT I HAVE ALWAYS SEEN NON-MUSLIMS QUOTING QURAN OUT OF THE CONTEXT..... Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by balaord on Jun 02, 2008 06:35 PM  Permalink what is the difference between a real son and the adopted son? Zainab was prophet cousinm,whom she knew her all along.If Prophet Muhammed desired her,he wouldnt have married her too Zaid in the first place. You guys assume as if Muahmed came to know Zainab through his adopted son,the truth is it is He (Prophet) who arranged the marrage itself and it is because of this Zainab (PBUH) asked Prophet Muhammed to marry her after she divorced Zaid. May peace and blessing be upon Zaid and the mother of belivers Zainab and Prophet.    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:36 PM  Permalink ABHINAV.... YOU HAVENT STILL PROVIDED THE SOURCE OF THAT HADITH????? RSS BOOK OR WESTERN ANTI ISLAMIC MEDIA BOOK?    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:28 PM  Permalink you cant even quote the ssource of information..... you say you dont belive in religion your rligion whar=tever be ithindu or else you are anti islam....for people like you its written in quran that they are wandering in their dream to tarnish and finish the religion......but they wont succeed.... millions of non muslims before you tried this .....you seee the results islam incrreased four folds    Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:Khalid / star / Baloard........why did prophet mohammed marry his adopted son's wife......?? by khalid raza on Jun 02, 2008 06:50 PM  Permalink FROM WHICH BOOK ????? WHICH PASAAGE COMMON DONT HIDE NOW!!!!    Forward   |   Report abuse

Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator

Message(s) deleted by moderator not displayed on this page

Message(s) deleted by moderator not displayed on this page

Click here to view messages reported for abuse