traitor somnaths reserved his place in CPM by doing chamchagiri of jyoti basu.once he got the speaker post he got carried away with the powers/ riches /luxuries of high office . no wonder just like all UPA polictians he is one of the richest Polictians of bengal.
If traitor somnath quits his MP post which he won due the party and recontests , he will not get more than 6 votes(that of his family). If he is so sure ask him to quit the parliament and fight election as an independent. as a independent he is not answerable to anyone and he can take his own decisions. But if he wins on a party ticket,, his victory is due to the lakhs of ordinary party workers (their labour and money) , so traitor somnath dont get carried away with the Governor post being offred by UPA. If traitor somnath has the guts in his balls get your self relected on a non CPM ticket
RE:traitor somnath
by Arijit on Jul 24, 2008 03:43 PM Permalink
You appears to be a Cummie residing in the slums! Why do you people preach a Pseudo-Communism to destruct the political harmony of India? Do you know the reasons why communism is not accepted, even in China, Russia? Because of you stupid men, West Bengal is suffering a lot! You must be one of the OPPORTUNISTS of West Bengal. Unless some NEPOTISM is allowed by CPI/CPIM, nobody in West Bengal preach Pseudo-Marxism! Marxism is an out dated tool to analyse economy and social behaviour! It's not a thing to preach for running a Government! I suggest you SANJAY to read more research works, latest authentic journal papers and know more! I suggest Karat, Sita Ram, Buddha, Jyoti, Raja, Chandra Chodan too to open their EVIL EYES. HISTORY will never spare such Pseudo-Communists!!! JAI HIND.
RE:traitor somnath
by Sourabh Sen on Jul 24, 2008 03:45 PM Permalink
How many votes do you think Karat woll get even if he contests election as a CPM candidate?
RE:traitor somnath
by kuttan on Jul 24, 2008 05:20 PM Permalink
Prakash,Brinda, Dr.MMS are the people who are holding high profile office posts, without contesting elections and have no intention to contest as well. karat was a stdent leader in Jawaharlal Nehru University, so was Brinda in some other university.Dr.Singh had his followers everywhere, but have not faced electorate.
RE:RE:traitor somnath
by Manya Neel on Jul 24, 2008 03:40 PM Permalink
Do you know that Somnath was considered for the post of President of India and Congress had no problem with it? Do you also know that your precious communists were uninterested and Congress had to drop the idea? So, understand that, Speaker's post is not a great thing for Somnath Chaterjee. I am sure you are a communist. Have you read Karl Marx fully?
RE:traitor somnath
by armando on Jul 24, 2008 03:40 PM Permalink
Somnath leaving the CPM is start of the slide of the commie outfit. Mamta Banerjee, Congress and a party floated by Somnath is going to rule Bengal from now.
It is time that these China lovers are thrown out of this country
RE:traitor somnath
by c k on Jul 24, 2008 03:49 PM Permalink
Dear Manya, Karl marx says that people are the property of the nation and they should live,eat,sleep in floak and the children produced thus is again national property.Karl Marx himself was such a product.
I don't think so comrade. Party can suspend Mr. Somnath Chatterjee. But you & your other Polet Buro members miss-utilize the power of Polet Buro. After all you have no option to defend your defeat in the Parliament. You all just switched off the nation’s eye to the other side. Very Very bad decision. My Red salute to Mr. Somnath Chatterjee for his courageous decision for not step down from the Honorable post of Speaker.
For your kind information I am a party member of CPI (M). So your thinking is absolutely wrong.
Second, as per parliament law, when a member is going to sit in the Honorable Speaker's chair, he will not belongs to any party & no one can force to take him any decision till he is sitting on this chair. Mr Karat & the others have already done this mistake & again at the time of giving the member's list to our President, the same mistake once again done & our party leader have accepted that. If Mr Chatterjee done the mistake not to follow the guideline of our Party, then why till today party not able to take the same action on Mr. Subhash Chakraborty?? I think party has that fear as mobs always with Mr. Chakraborty. Do you not think Mr. Chakraborty continuously breaking party law??
My dear friend, do you not think that CPI (M) & other left parties done the mistake to go with a Party like BJP??
RE:I DON'T THINK SO
by Souren Banerjee on Jul 24, 2008 06:17 PM Permalink
Dear Friend- I am not like Mr. Soumen Mitra. It's my stand on this issue, It may be differ. But this is not fair that you will fource someone to change the party if he will not accept your views. You are telling like our General Secretary. Sorry friend- Please change your attitude.
RE:I DON'T THINK SO
by armando on Jul 24, 2008 03:42 PM Permalink
Somnath is a hero..........the commies are eating humble pie. And Karat is at the end of his tenure. Revolt will hit him hard
The selective amnesia faced by somnath chatterji a capitalist in communist clothes is not at all surprising ,He has declared assests of 8 crores and likes westren lifestyle,No doubt communist movement has suffered due to traitors like him .However this is a small deterent and Party will surly reach its goal of ruling India,We must pity people the speaker of loksabha as he has embraced evil capitalism while running away from noble path of communism,This defection was known from long back as when interviewed by noted chinese daily GAOLINg Times Mr chatterji had talked abt his likeness abt English clothes and continental Italian dishes this were not words of true communist but voice of a traitor among the heroes
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by Vinayak on Jul 24, 2008 03:44 PM Permalink
Message to the family of the crank Sahadeven :Kindly admit this nut in a mental asylum at the earliest.
Coming to your comments:You nut , what about Jyothi Basu whose son is an industrialist and Karat and his wife who goes around in Luxury Cars and leading a luxurios life style . Do you mean to say that they are poor? They have also amassed undisclosed wealth.
Commie cadres like you are so much brainwashed that their brains eventually become like that of a monkey.
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by Deepak MA on Jul 24, 2008 03:35 PM Permalink
Oh! you are a MC and a BC for sure!! You are ideal to clean Karat's toilet with your tooth brush! Let's say the Chinese' toilets with your tooth brush....
For decades you had Somnath Chaterji as your star member... and suddenly he became a capitalist!! God save this country....
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by jeffy george on Jul 24, 2008 04:04 PM Permalink
mr. sahadevan, ur comments are very good. but somanath is not as rich as your kerala leaders. they are not open. we should appreciate somanath for declaring his assets. your kerala leaders are very rich, and telling they are good communists. you better go and learn how to live like a human, u know only communist theory. you were against computer in 80s and 90s. now u better use computers than any other people...better stop your foolish principles and live in forest
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by A. Swaminathan on Jul 24, 2008 03:40 PM Permalink
Please tell me..what is the leftist ideology..and which will continue to march?. There are so many persons like me, very much ignorant of your left ideology.Please enlighten us, with your marvelous principles and ideologies.
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by shuvrajit sen gupta on Jul 24, 2008 03:39 PM Permalink
Traitors Somnath Chatterjee!!!!Traitors are those who are currently there..They had spoilt west bengal and now they are tring to spoil India..Somnath Chaterjee is a honest man who did what was good for the country
RE:RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by Arijit on Jul 24, 2008 03:57 PM Permalink
Another Bong Cummie! You people are REALLY DISGUSTING. You must either a REFUGEE, or a slum dweller, or a local-DADA having some NEPOTIST people around you! We know that you people preach for the Pseudo-Communism, Pseudo-Marxism to have some FAVOURs from those stupid HEADLESS CHICKENS. Do you really know Communism and MArxism? Could u pls let me know whether these two terms are synonymous, or having some diferent meaning? I am just trying to see conception in regard to communism/Marxism of you poor CUMMIES of Bengal. I know you people can never answer those as Pseudo-Communism, Pseudo-Marxism are being preached by your Karat Inc., Bardhan Inc. HISTORY WILL NEVER LET YOU GO EASILY; YOU MUST HAVE TO PAY FOR THE PSEUDO-COMMUNISM IN THE ERA OF MASS GLOBALIZATION.
RE:RE:RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by palash ghosh on Jul 24, 2008 03:41 PM Permalink
I completely agree . Comrade Karat pls throw out Subhas Chakraborty as well. We leftist are with you Red salute to you
RE:RE:RE:RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by Arijit on Jul 24, 2008 03:49 PM Permalink
Palash Ghosh---a leftist!! How Funny!!!! Most of the stupid, pseudo-cummunies of Bengal who has become "left" from 1977 are OPPORTUNIST! I guess there will not be any exception for Palash Ghosh too. Perhaps he needs favour/recommendation to have his job/land/something else!!
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by Arijit on Jul 24, 2008 03:47 PM Permalink
Sahadevan KK, WHEN DID YOU TRANSFER YOUR IDEOLOGY? I believe you preached something against those stupid Pseudo-Cummies sometime back! Now you have started uttering something for the favour of Karat Inc. and Bardhan Inc.! How funny you people are!!! You too must be one of the OPPORTUNISTS!!!!
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by Muthukumar on Jul 24, 2008 03:41 PM Permalink
Your goal is rulling India...ha ha ha...Joke of the milenium...
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by balaji ramani on Jul 24, 2008 04:08 PM Permalink
Ha ha ha ha ha!!!!
You fool! Do you know that Karl Marx is a German. He wore clothes that you might call 'English clothes'. He probably ate Bread and pasta which are Italian dishes.
The chinese leaders always wear western clothes. They have no qualms in having Pizza Hut, McDonalds and Subway in Shangai, Beijing and Tianjin.
A communist does not necessarily lead a life of a dighambara saint!!! It is an ideology that has no relation with your clothes and what you like to eat.
Sahadevan, you certainly are the most ignorant communist in the whole world!!!
RE:Leftist ideology will march on ,,,,,,,,,
by kuttan on Jul 24, 2008 05:27 PM Permalink
Near Sahadevan's home town there is a mental asylum called " Oolampara". Find out from the keepers whether a man has jumped their mental care centre. Oolampara in Calicut of Kerala is famous for these types of cracks.
now CPIM again proved that no one is in trhe party. every member even he is party member or Polit Beareau should definetely follow the party rule and line. 4 months ago party suspended senior PB members Vs achuthanandan & pinarayi. this is lesson for all parties.So CPIm again proved that no one above the p[arty rule. I thik all parties should defenitely follow these decision when they are standing above parties decision.and also CPIm is only one party, they take action without nlooking their face whether he is senior or junior
We the Indians are not surprised by the act of Politbureau of expelling Mr. Chattarje.. Those who raised their voice against the wish of PB were expelled from the party in earlier occassion too. CPM lost good leaders because of their this type of act. We are waiting to see when they expell Mr. Jyothibhasu.
The left should have taken a rather mature approach instead of humiliating a highly respected person. They also acted in hurry in pulling out support and in the same fashion expeling Somnath. We must always keep a chance of discussion and take expression of the otherside before jumping to the guns. We should bring understanding not only with other parties to some extend but within party to a large extend.
RE:Give democracy a chance
by MSK on Jul 24, 2008 03:41 PM Permalink
the decision of expelling him itself is wrong and haste. and they say it is the dictum of poarty and eberybody obey it. Good principlpe. and rule. But once the origin decision of eviction itself is haste why cant they see the things in absolute manner and revert back the decision?
RE:Give democracy a chance
by Radha Krishnan on Jul 24, 2008 03:36 PM Permalink
CPM action of expelling Mr. Chattarjee is only to divert the attention of Media and Public. They utterly failed in Indian politics. Poor chattarjee he is the ultimate victim. But most of the Indians are behind Mr. Chattarjee. His decision was very right. We support him He is the good speaker. Politicians should learn from him
RE:Give democracy a chance
by armando on Jul 24, 2008 03:46 PM Permalink
Somnath is a hero, no doubt. He did a great job as the Speaker on that fateful day.
You can well imagine some other person trying his hand at it. The Dy Speaker was all at sea when he was in the Chair
RE:There is a difference between entrapment and sting operation.
by A. Swaminathan on Jul 24, 2008 03:48 PM Permalink
These parties..think that people are stupid..and dance to their tune. That age has gone..Mr.Advani Go and suck your fingers like baby. We have seen what , you have done in babri majjid and gurajat. You are master of creating communal dis-hormoney and creating votes out of it.
RE:There is a difference between entrapment and sting operation.
by Radha Krishnan on Jul 24, 2008 03:40 PM Permalink
Absolutely correct. BJP's image is tarnished like anything. Shameless Advani. I dont know with what face they will approcah the people for vote
