somnath daa has been expelled by a general seceratry who has never won a panchayat election in his life nor will fight one, has expelled a parliamentrian who has been a mp for nearly 4decades
RE:RE:EXPELLED BY WHOOM??
by aslil chhabi on Jul 23, 2008 11:26 PM Permalink
nice point, still i dont understand why the communists are in india... all of them shud be sent to china.Mr somnath has also did his part to sell india to china and now mr karat is doing the same .... what a joke
He is a man of double standards, and is at his best in telling lies. His behavior as speaker has been shamelessly unfair. His constituency has been declared reserved on recently, so he was looking to Congress for greener pastures. He is in Congress already, that is what made him to publicly say that he is not going to vote with BJP contradicting his own statement that the post of speaker is above party politics. If speaker's post is above party politics-- how could he publicly be against BJP, though having voted by their side in the past, he simply is a master lair and opportunist having an eye on the coming elections. There is no difference between him and the "for sale" MPs.
RE:Somnath Chatterjee
by aslil chhabi on Jul 23, 2008 11:28 PM Permalink
there bis nice point which was told in tv. if the MPs are getting sold, why not question their leader? why this political parties are giving ticket to the people who are these easily sellable? don't we have any honest people left in india?
India is a democracy but communism does not believe in it. Communist parties around the world are products of Marxian or Leninist doctrines which do not accept democracy as a mode of governance. Democracy is anathema in communism and people around the world are still fighting to end the dictatorial rules of the communist parties. Indian communists are not democrats by choice. The party organization is run in India just like communist parties run governments the world over. The ultimate aim of communist manifestos is not democracy. It is an irony. While democracy allows communism, communists by their faith do not believe in democracy. In their way of governance, not only governments but also democracy are subservient to the party. It is unrealistic to expect communists to have any respect for democratic institutions. They just want to use Indian democracy as ploy for achieving their ultimate objective of communist dictatorship in the country. Expulsion of the Speaker of the Indian from CPM is only an example of what these communists ultimately want to do with Indian Democracy
The only sign of honesty and transparency in the entire episode was Mr. Chaterjee standing up for the values of the chair. The CPI (M) must be complimented to remove the silver lining from the cloud... Mr. Chaterjee, if you read this, I read somewhere that you not planning to contest elections again. I can only say that the end to your innings has been the best any politician who cares for democracy, for this country can have.. For this , you must thank your politburo (is this what it is called?) Hats off to you.....
RE:The only honest thing punished..
by hariss hariss on Jul 23, 2008 11:18 PM Permalink
what transparency did u see?
"Chatterjee had voiced his displeasure over the CPI-M voting against the United Progressive Alliance alongside the Bharatiya Janata Party.". if mr chatterjee was HONEST and TRANSPARENT, as a speaker, why should he VOICE HIS DISPLEASURE OVER CPI(M) VOTING AGAINST UPA....?
RE:The only honest thing punished..
by hariss hariss on Jul 23, 2008 11:22 PM Permalink
expelling him from the party was not for beingg in the chair as speaker during the trust vote. it was because he was not available with the party when he was required to be.. he was expelled only after the trust vote, isnt it?
RE:NON PARTISAN-DHAA.
by aslil chhabi on Jul 23, 2008 11:12 PM Permalink
nishu, do u know how to write english?what garbage u r writing?i thought u were foolish, but it seems u r mad
RE:NON PARTISAN-DHAA.
by nishu kutty on Jul 23, 2008 11:15 PM Permalink
CHOBBI, AFTER A LONG TIME, YOU ARE AT LAST FOUND FROM HIBERNATION. TRY TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS AND DONT QUESTION THE LITREARY/ARTISTIC PRAISE ABOUT OUR BELOVED CHOM DHAA.
RE:NON PARTISAN-DHAA.
by nishu kutty on Jul 23, 2008 11:23 PM Permalink
YOU SHOULD DEFINITELY BE IGNORING ME BECAUSE YOU DO NOT HAVE VALID,CLEAR ANSWERS. YOU ARE ONE AMONG THE LOT WHO ALWAYS TRY TO BEAT AROUND THE BUSH AND CANNOT ANSWER DIRECTLY,HONESTLY.
While everybody is praising Somnath as an honest person, i have different opinion and he is adopting double standards and tell lies. The speaker post is above parties and the speaker should treat all parties without any differentiation. But, look what he told when he refused to resign. He said, that, he does not want to vote with BJP and thus, he has shown that he hates BJP and all those talks of his bipartisan attitude and neutral person is all fake and a pack of lies. See, how much he hates BJP and if he is a true bipartisan and netural speaker he should not have such opinion. So, he is a fake and cheating peoples.
RE:Somnath Chatterjee's expulsion
by aslil chhabi on Jul 23, 2008 11:15 PM Permalink
It is a nice point. Actually all the politicians are corrupt but none like the communists.Indian politicians sell themselves but this communists try to sell the country in the name of china and russia.they always maintain double standard.kick prakash karat and party out of india.
RE:Somnath Chatterjee's expulsion
by nishu kutty on Jul 23, 2008 11:19 PM Permalink
CHOBBI, DO NOT BEAT AROUND THE BUSH. ANSWER DIRECTLY ABOUT CHOM DHAA AND NOT ABOUT KARAT.
While everybody is praising Somnath as an honest person, i have different opinion and he is adopting double standards and tell lies. The speaker post is above parties and the speaker should treat all parties without any differentiation. But, look what he told when he refused to resign. He said, that, he does not want to vote with BJP and thus, he has shown that he hates BJP and all those talks of his bipartisan attitude and neutral person is all fake and a pack of lies. See, how much he hates BJP and if he is a true bipartisan and netural speaker he should not have such opinion. So, he is a fake and cheating peoples.
RE:40 years of curse
by aslil chhabi on Jul 23, 2008 11:21 PM Permalink
those rules seems to be more important than indian constitution.why dont we kick this communists out of india? i really doubt the intelelct of the bongs, how they are allowing this traitors for more than 30 years? wake up my bong friends, stop being foolish and kick out communists.
RE:40 years of curse
by hariss hariss on Jul 23, 2008 11:44 PM Permalink
but isnt that good to have some strong guidelines within the party for their members...
do you know about anyother party having such a system?
no other party has such a system... that is the reason why corruption among CPI(M) leaders is at much lower levels than others...
to check if the corruption level is less, you can check out how many such charges are there agaainst leaders of other parties and compare that with of CPI(M).
CPM should look back. Did they perform well in the discussions in parliament? There are many vital points in the whole deal which the congress could not answer. Did they read the various debates in the media. OH, I forgot. They have a 202 page booklet -well researched!!! What is the use if it is not presented in the appropriate forum in the right time? CPM utterly failed in this matter. Do not try to fool the people.
Party discipline-wise there is no question as to why Somnath should continue as speaker.Morally speaking,he should have resigned as speaker to enable himself step into the shoe of a disciplined soldier of the party to carry out its orders.O.K. His intentions may be different-That he might have been thinking of casting his prerogative vote as speaker in favour of the govt in case of tie or he must have been feeling obliged,in the heart of heart,to Congress party which had no objection for his candidature for presidentship.Whatever it be,when his party issues a whip he should have obeyed it.CPM has correctly followed its text book procedure.Among the political parties it is known for its discipline.We should wonder if it had not expelled Somnath.Even so,it appears to have waited patiently for Somnath himself to react and resign at least after the voting.Since,it could find no semblance of any such thing & instead heard the irking news of his intention of continuing till the Common wealth Parliamentary Association meet to be held i.e.almost for another three weeks,it hastened its disciplinary action.This is what any party does should it be in CPI-M's place.No party tolerates some one enjoying the benefits of a position accorded by virtue of ones entry in to the house sheerly due to his having been elected on the symbol of their party.Chatterjis outward slogan of his not willing to share negative voting with BJP is not convincing.His exact intentions are still a mystery.
RE:Somnath should have resigned at least after voting
by hariss hariss on Jul 23, 2008 11:07 PM Permalink
i doubt any other party in the country has the stuff to take such a step, if one of their senior members did so...
