Yesterday was absolutely a sad day for indian democracy and for the Indian politics.The way our so called MP'S conduct them selves over issues concerning to INDIA was shamefull. This deal is for entire nation and not for any particular government or party. No government or party can take credit if we go ahead and sign any deal which surely is going to benefit our country and would be in the interest of nation with out sacrifising its security and development programme. Why the debate wasn't conducted between top nuclear scientists? Need was to setup Technical commission which could analyze and prepare report over the merits & demertits and after that PM should have addressed entire nation. These MP'S just don't value time and keep on blaming eachother over the issues which we all know. Yesterdays discussion was over Nuclear Deal and some MP'S were putting forth some non sense issues which only create communal differences and no way help our contry to progress. Time has come when we need youth to participate and make decisions and as far as Indian politics is concerned then there should be only 5 major parties. Our MP'S don't understand the respect which they should show in parliament and in turn are displaying ugly part to entire country and the world.
RE:numerical win!!!
by Comment on Jul 23, 2008 10:17 AM Permalink
Congratulations to the person who said "Minorities, particularly the Muslims, have first right over the national resources" ... this, along with Amarnath, is a great win for minorities in 'secular' India!
RE:numerical win!!!
by Hind on Jul 23, 2008 07:05 AM Permalink
dear friend i am not a great fan of Advani ... nor karat ... this is confidance motion not no confidance motion ... so Opposition leader has no role, more over this situation was due to EGO of MMS and Karat so no problem .... I wonder why for this gujrat issues is taken ... werent there any Roits earleier ... for your information Gujrat victims were 1000 to 1500 in whole of Gujrat this include both Hindus and Muslims ..... Sikh roits vitims were 2500 in delhi only ..... My only question is why this poison is still spilled , you know this is still leading to seggrigation of hindu muslim ...
All are culprits , did nt people in nadi gram were not killed, if some gundas did not allow tv crew to that place ,,, and govt covered it up .. is it not killing people and roiting ..
My Intention is to not support Advani, or Karat or any of therse people ,,,, only to say that Gujrat is not a seperate or isoloted inceden ,,, it was happening and it will happen because of these congress, bjp, SP,BSP.COMMunists ... Rajiv was euqally culprit for SIKH massacares and is Narendra modi ,,,, Congress is equally guilt and escaped punishements as is Bjp for gujat ... the only difference was the roits tool place in no congress or its allies ruled state ...
RE:numerical win!!!
by Himalay on Jul 23, 2008 11:12 AM Permalink
Sikh riots were spur of the moment reaction of people against the sikhs, bcos of assasination of a great national leader by her sikh bodyguards, it was no doubt an most inhuman act of killing innocent (sikhs) people and one has to condemn it with all his might. But, Gujrat riots was a manufactured riot it was carefully planned & executed by political parties like BJP, VHP & Bajrang Dal against the muslims. Such riots should never occur again.
RE:RE:numerical win!!!
by Himalay on Jul 23, 2008 11:17 AM Permalink
One cannot compare both riots, whereas one was spur of the moment reaction by people cutting across party lines (may be mostly congress party workers)...the other was cold blooded murder of innocents by BJP, VHP & Bajrang Dal, planned years in advance and executed in a ruthless manner.
There lies the problem. if someone people think a hero (even Shahrukh Khan) says something, everyone starts believing him without even thinking anything about it. I agree Kalam has good knowledge on some of the things, but he's not a nuclear scientist. Most of the indian scientist (they of course know much more about nuclear technology than Kalam) world over have serious doubts about the viability of this deal. Until unless those concerns are addressed, the deal will create more problems than it will solve.
How much power will be generated through nuclear technology? How much will it cost? Who will provide the technology? What about the environmental effect, how the nuclear waste is going to be handled? What if the US decides to stop supplying raw materials and technology? etc. I think Govt. should have taken the scientists opinions on these issues before even thinking about the deal. There is no point in getting some unsubstantiated data from unknown source to answer these questions. We just need scientists to debate extensively on this. In stead, the Govt. has used unscrupulous means to stay on the power and push the deal. I can say for sure, it is a black day for democracy.
Now that Nuclear Deal will go ahead. Slowly will be disclosed the traps in the deal. The sanctions India will be facing. US beginning to get a good hold in Asia by setting a base in India.
Australia will be benefited to a great extent since they will be the main exporters to India of Nuclear raw material.
Since I live in NZ we always heard Australia wanting to India to go ahead with the Nuclear deal.
I hope Nuclear deal is for the good. My only concern is US MNCs killing Indian culture and consistently introducing Western influence. God help us all.
RE:Good for US and Australia
by Vinay Gupta on Jul 23, 2008 06:43 AM Permalink
Vivek u r 100% correct. Cyber coolies of indian origin are suppoting the deal to prove their loyality to US.
In India there is large number of educated population wh open the umbrella in Delhi if it rains in Washington DC
parties seem to have voted just to prove a point. more personal than the countrys intrest. some voted for money some to pay back to their parties. muslims voted just to be anti bjp. communists lick chinasss and congress lick goris. who the hell cares for india. and anyway y is bjp opposing the nuclear deal afterall it was the one who initiated this long time back.
RE:heck does anyone know wat this deal is about
by SKS on Jul 23, 2008 06:06 AM Permalink
No, Kalam, MMS, Maino, Pranab noone knows much about it. I am sure they have not thought about its serious repercussions on our future generations even in their dreams.
RE:RE:Congratulations to Manmohan Singh
by Comment on Jul 23, 2008 10:18 AM Permalink
Congratulations to the person who said "Minorities, particularly the Muslims, have first right over the national resources" ... this, along with Amarnath, is a great win for minorities in 'secular' India!
RE:RE:Congratulations to Manmohan Singh
by SKS on Jul 23, 2008 06:07 AM Permalink
How much power will be generated through nuclear technology? How much will it cost? Who will provide the technology? What about the environmental effect, how the nuclear waste is going to be handled? What if the US decides to stop supplying raw materials and technology? etc. I think Govt. should have taken the scientists opinions on these issues before even thinking about the deal. There is no point in getting some unsubstantiated data from unknown source to answer these questions. We just need scientists to debate extensively on this. In stead, the Govt. has used unscrupulous means to stay on the power and push the deal. I can say for sure, it is a black day for democracy.
RE:Congratulations to Manmohan Singh
by Hind on Jul 23, 2008 05:35 AM Permalink
Bribe for good cause ???? what are u talking do u have mind of urs .... how do u know its for good cause .... we donot know really if its rellay good or bad the current situation is because egos of2 people MMS and Karat .... LK advani and Maya or later players .. how come u blame these people ... we should pray that the deal is really donot harm the country ....
