People when argue against BJP, they just talk about "Secularism", "minority".. nothing else.
When one of BJP MP became a minister in Karnataka, he immediately resigned as MP but look at congress. Even after becoming the CM of a state then MP giridhar gomango didn't resign and hence the Vajpayee govt fell by 1 vote. Their high command asked him not to resign from parliament.
when some MP belong to BJP caught on camera(trapped) for taking money to ask questions in parliament are suspended, then how come MPs who are in jail for being convicted for murder, links with ISI, rape blah blah are allowed to vote and still they are MPs ? This Somnath Chaterjee will go into the history as the most biased speaker.
RE:what is this
by Common Admi on Jul 21, 2008 06:24 PM Permalink
Suspention is different. A suspended MP is not allowed to take part in the parliamentry proceedings, but they have a right to vote for or against a motion in the parliament. All the MPs who are currently under suspention, is going to come back. All those are in the jail or out in bail, because a person remains a MP till the re election in his constituency. So all of them technically can take part in voting, now making arrangements to get them out to vote, that is correct or not is a seperate issue.
If the Speaker is above all political parties, he had no reason for saying that he did not want to vote on the same side of the BJP. This is a dead give away of his thinking. No one is asking him to support either way, but as an impartial person, he should not comment in this fashion about a Political Party that had been in power earlier.
RE:Speaker episode: Tip of CPI-M iceberg
by satyarthi on Jul 21, 2008 02:21 PM Permalink
After all he is a RED, master in 'double speak'. In the same paragraph, he talks of his neutrality and his opposition to BJP.
By alienating intellectual & experienced persons like Somnath Chatterji, Jyoti Basu ,Subhas Chakraborty etc. Karat & Bardhan are pushing the communist movement in the hands of some hot headed bigots where prudence , knowledge and experience take back seat .
By stating in a letter to Karat Samnath Chatterji has stated that he doesn't want to vote with BJP. Is this doesn't clearly reflects his dislike for the party and with these known facts how he can be considered as impartial & a suitable person for the post of speaker.
Imagine How far the Karat and Bardhan can go to stop the deal. they do not have respect for nation/Pm/Parliament/ Institution/Individual/Friend/Collegue.All commrades should see if this can happen with Somnath it can happen with any body. Is Karat a leader or Psycho. Party should get rid of this bander. Bander ke haath main Ustra lahu luhan kar dega. Kaun marega bhagwan jane.Is it the way to give farewell to man Like Somnath.
RE:Karat/Bardhan are psycho
by Hebbar R on Jul 21, 2008 02:17 PM Permalink
Imagine how far the PM can go. If he can decieve his own supporters, how can he be trusted? If he can keep the Draft a secrete from his own supporters, how can he be fair with the Country?? If he can encourage defections and purchase of MPs, how can he be trutsted about the Country?
We must think what is right & what is wrong and the country comes first. It seem that in politics, country has the last preference and any good person is treated like a criminal. We must thank god that we have good PM today as many in the past. We must not let the holigans take this chair. We must support the opportunity in front of us and all like minded people would so. The PM has sacrifed the chair which no one would be ready to do so. We must satule him.
