now this is very clear that somnath view about bjp.bjp is nationalist party & main opposition of india. as speaker well known his view about b.j.p. now he hate this party he think bjp enemy not opposition he has no right for work as speaker. indian constitution allowed such people as speaker whose vEiw anti ndian. dear somnath please check image of a comrades in indian people not mOre than a gonda elements. we never think any differ in anti indian, comrades, jehadi, naxal. very serious for indian A RED TERROIST CHALLANGE OPENLY TO INDIAN. & FRRELY MOVING IN DELHI SHAME FOR INDIAN.
Nuclear deal will be harmful to India,no doubt in it,BJP is only against congress and they are not against nuclear deal.NOW IT IS PROVED THAT BJP AND CONGRESS ARE ANTI NATIONALS.Once I misunderstood the communists,but now I understood they love the nation and communists are great and intelligent people.RED SALUTE TO COMMUNISTS.
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by Sandeep R on Jul 17, 2008 10:30 AM Permalink
Kerala is still under developed only because of people like you. They all make big hue and cry against all countries except communist countries and some gulf countries. But when they want to send their kids or close relatives for education or for jobs, they will send them only to US, UK, Australia or Europe. They work only for MNC companies based out of these countries. I wonder where this guy (Suresh Menon) works? Must be working for some US company either directly or as a client. Man, if you are so interested in commnunism go and settle in China, North Korea or Cuba. Please let us live in peace in India.
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by galilio on Jul 17, 2008 10:42 AM Permalink
bjp is against the nuclear deal in the present form with the clauses of HYDE act which the local american act .this could be altered at any time by USA and hence bjp wants to put an indian act also in the deal to pull the string. in short bjp does not want india to surrender to bush.congress also does not want nuclear deal but due to the inflation,this nuclear deal comes to the rescue to save congress face and convince people like you.moreover this is the deal to get rid of communists before the election and make quick money by buying nuclear plants from american cos like general electric. after the elections are over,both congress and communists join in common goal to keep bjp out of power. in short hindus like us are being fooled by this anti hindu forces whose aim is to engage minority appeasement and conversion agenda and fool the people of india mainly hindus.
RE:RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by galilio on Jul 17, 2008 10:50 AM Permalink
karat is correct to say congress is sinking ship becouse they lost 9 states ruled by them before to bjp and karat was proud that all three states ruled by communists are not allowing bjp to grow in their communists ruled states.true but communists are more or less not touching the sensitive issues of hinduva in kerala,bengal and tripura.if they touch such sensitive issues against hindus,communists would be routed out in kerala first,west bengal second and tripura third.already bjp is having now good hold in kerala where communists are trying to intervine in temple affairs and work against hindus.so this time bjp would increase its voting percentage from 8% last to 12-15% in next election to eleminate communist but will help congress to come to power.
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by Navratan Sethia on Jul 17, 2008 09:26 AM Permalink
red salute to red terrorist& anti indian only possible in india.in other country anti national hanged at public place or shoot at site.
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by ram kumar on Jul 17, 2008 01:05 PM Permalink
mr menon, they have said subhash chandra bose-tojo's dog. they have oppose india's independence. they have voted against war order to china. they always criticised only majority. so hence proved that they are anti antional and kameenest.
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by Chouhan Chouhan on Jul 17, 2008 09:26 AM Permalink
go to china, read evrything about DEAl, you will come to know what is DEAL all about.
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by suresh menon on Jul 17, 2008 09:39 AM Permalink
chouhan,are you a chineese agent,do you like chineese communism do you like such system in India
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by C.V.RAMAN IYER on Jul 17, 2008 09:38 AM Permalink
Menon saare (sir), you are able to express your views just because you are living in a democratic nation, mind that. Communists are slightly worse that Jihadis (terrorists of all hues).
RE:RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by Sudharsan R on Jul 17, 2008 09:46 AM Permalink
Communists don't make the poor richer but makes the rich poorer. Equals, ain't that? The communist votes comes only from poor uneducated mass.
RE:NUCLEAR DEAL
by Sabu Abraham on Jul 17, 2008 09:35 AM Permalink
Thanks for understanding the communists,come let us give power to that wonderful party CPI(M).
this speaker's refusal to quit and holding on to a flimsy excuse only shows that anybody whether great or small, young or old will not leave their chair of position.ethics are thrown out of the window. my admiration for mr catterjee is lost forever. it is impossible to dislodge him now till he sees the govt win
he speaker categorically says that he is above party. if so, why has he stated that he will not vote with the bjp? what justice can the bjp get from the speaker chair. i wonder also that it could be a joint strategy between the govt, the speaker and the left by raising the bogey of the bjp stand. this only reveals that the trust vote is only a sham.the govt will not lose.why should the left worry about what the bjp is going to do when it hates the party so much? if left is convinced that the nuclear deal is bad for the country, why should it worry about what te bjp stand is . they are trying to get out of a situation which they do not want to pursue.
RE:SPEAKER
by Sandeep R on Jul 17, 2008 10:35 AM Permalink
Already you guys screwed up entire Kerala and WB. Keralites are forced to go outside and search for jobs only because of these communists. And BTW, how is the development in WB where you guys are ruling for the last 30 years or so? WB was one of the most developed state in India before communist came to power and see it's state now.
RE:SPEAKER
by Sabu Abraham on Jul 17, 2008 09:04 AM Permalink
If the Speaker is a C.I.A. agent he should be kicked out of India along with the congress people.
RE:SPEAKER
by Suresh Babu on Jul 17, 2008 10:30 AM Permalink
No, he may not be a CIA agent, but he wants to enjoy the facilities, which are getting from the MM Singh Govt. till May 2009. After that he will not contest any election and he will retire from the politics also. This is in his mind and hence he is reluctant to resign from the post of speaker.
The most corrupt and biased partial speaker ever in modern history was kulak Kesri nath tripathji of RSSBJP in UP vidhan sabha !
by mahabodhi on Jul 17, 2008 08:56 AM Permalink | Hide replies
The most biased partial and corrupt speaker in the modern history was Kesri Nath Tripthi of UP vidhan sabha of RSSBJP member ! Kesri NaTH tRIPTHI WAS THE ONE WHOI ILLEGALLY SPLIT the BSP and benefitted the BJP and also SP !Such speaker should have been given examplary punushment !And these corrupt and bigot RSSBJP Ps leaders who r condemning the great parliamnatriarin Somnath Chatterjee forget that they took oath of Janta Dal MPs in Parliament but still owe its alleghiance to RSS the so called udal mebership in 1980 !all corrupt leaders like Atal Vajpayee Advani Joshi etc. were and always playing dual dirty politics games thru out their life !They split the Janta Dal on the dual membership !they lied to the nation and constitution !They r antinational and traitors !They hv no right to say anything against somnath Chaterrjee !The prakash Karat has to learn more from Somntah Chaterjee and Jyoti Basu !
RE:The most corrupt and biased partial speaker ever in modern history was kulak Kesri nath tripathji of RSSBJP in UP vidhan sabha !
by srikant on Jul 17, 2008 09:10 AM Permalink
After that only congress reduced 20 to MLA`s. and Mayawati and Sp both have come to power.
People know who is what BJP has a tough time ,BSP a good time ,SP a tough time and congress needs some time to get vanished.
RE:The most corrupt and biased partial speaker ever in modern history was kulak Kesri nath tripathji of RSSBJP in UP vidhan sabha !
by srikant on Jul 17, 2008 09:14 AM Permalink
Chinese citizens are not allowed here.
Abe Mahabodhi!!! Just go to bejing and
stoop there , will be kicked. All commies
are dropped in india through Bangladesh
and they join communist party.
The water of BAY OF BENGAL is rising to take you.GOOD BYE Commies
RE:The most corrupt and biased partial speaker ever in modern history was kulak Kesri nath tripathji of RSSBJP in UP vidhan sabha !
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 17, 2008 11:07 AM Permalink
Both Congress and BJP are sinking boats. Read my blog : Chidambaram Now Fears People of India, go to google and search "Sahadevan's blogs".
History will never forgive BJP & Left for Anti India Stand !!! 1)Left is with china & BJP is with Pakistan thats why china & pakistan are happy today.. Advani like last time(Jinna episode) will tell Pakistan is Secular country as PM of India on his next visit!!! 2)Nuclear deal is supported by all great visionaries & Intellectuals like Dr.Kalam,Mr.Brajesh Mishra(BJP Advisor),Dr.Manmohan singh(Architect of New India),Anil Kakodkar(Great Nuclear Scientist),Mr.Iyer(Nuclear Scientist),Sri Sri Ravishankar (Spiritual Guru) etc..... 3) where is RSS -- they should give again dose to Advani for his Anti India stand just like they gave in Jinnah Episode--- History will never Forgive Advani's BJP !!!
RE:History will never forgive BJP !!!
by Govindan on Jul 17, 2008 09:55 AM Permalink
You have not read the 123 agreement & Hyde Act properly.If you are interested to know more you may contact my e-mail Id given below. E-mail Id. knn_1981@yahoo.com Intellectual like Dr.Kalam has not studied the deal in detail. He has not replied to my technical enquries on the Nuclear deal
The speaker's post is supposed to be one of impartiality. But Com. Chaterjee by his utterance, has exposed his innerself. From hence forth whatever his rulings will be in the Lok Sabha, can always be considered as partial.
Manmohan should have answered all questions regarding deal, instead he kept on avoiding the debate. The most agonizing question that pricks my conscience is that . If nuclear deal is so good why none of the developed countries went for this option for last 40 years instead the opted for other means to produce electricity ? and this include countries like Australia too
RE:Nuclear Deal needs debate
by Sabu Abraham on Jul 17, 2008 09:33 AM Permalink
Thanks for your intelligent question manoo kaushal,according to our PM India need to produce 40000 mega watt electricity,the cost to produce one mega watt neuclear electricity costs 12 crore rupees,to produceone mega watt thermal power is Rs.4 crore and to produce one megga watt power from dams is Rs.3 crore.There are lot of things to say,but I am stopping,LISTEN TO COMMUNISTS MAINLY CPI(M),YOU WILL GET MORE AWARENESS REGARDING THIS.
