It doesnt matter whether this deal is good or bad, what matters is whole government machinery has been paralysed for long for an one point agenda which creates a solgan for Congress.
by RAJ on Jul 11, 2008 11:11 AM Permalink | Hide replies
It doesnt matter whether this deal is good or bad, what matters is, the whole government machinery has been paralysed for long for an one point agenda which creates a solgan for Congress during elections.
RE:Kapil Sibal is a a minister of Speeches only
by debesh kanungo on Jul 11, 2008 11:15 AM Permalink
HEY U INVITE PROBLEMS FOR U N US-SUPPORT DEAL TO HELP IND ECONOMY
Semi literate indian middle class need only slogans and knowing this Congress starting from Nehrivian times ( eg Public sectors are temples of development)this has been continuing to mislead the people and redirect the attention from real issues.
One billion people ( out of which 600 Million lives in less than a $ per day), have been seeing this drama of Nuclear for the last several months as if once this is signed we will become a developed world.
Why do we give so much importance to signing a deal which can maximum bring 8% of our energy needs?
Dont we have other pressing issues which requires attention of the Government?
It doesnt matter whether this deal is good or bad, what matters is whole government machinery has been paralysed for long for an one pint agenda which creates a solgan for Congress.
May be BJP can get the same or even better deal once they are in power. very less chances that India would not get this deal in future given the rising oil demand, world would be happier if India uses lesser oil. And supporting the govt. at this point of time would be political suside for BJP cause definately by this time next year inflation will dip on BASE effect. And BJP will again loose the elections for sure. so no need to go for it to help congress, which anyway is no All saints party.
RE:Why should BJP support the Gvt.
by debesh kanungo on Jul 11, 2008 11:24 AM Permalink
CANT DO THAT COZ CONSERVATIVE MINDS NEVER ALLOW THEM TO COME OUT N HELP INDIA PEOPLE.IF SOMETHING GOES WRONG THEY SHOUT N NOW THEY R SILENT WHY?WANT POWER BUT BJP CANT IF NEVER DO GOOD BY SUPPOERTING A GOOD CAUSE.by debesh kanungo on Jul 11, 2008 10:57 AM MY DEAR HAVE U GONE THRU THE PAGES OF N-DEAL------------------------ NOT ONLY MR KALAM BUT COUNCIL OF SCIENTISTS RELATED TO THIS TOPIC HAVE OPINED FOR THE DEAL------------IF POLITICIANS R FOOL THEN WE MUST SAY WE R UNLUCKY TO BE INDIANS
RE:Why should BJP support the Gvt.
by soorma on Jul 11, 2008 11:09 AM Permalink
No logic...India will be forced to use less oil once oil prices touch $200....
RE:Why should BJP support the Gvt.
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 11, 2008 11:16 AM Permalink
NO NUMBERS. If Left was a good ally, Congress has not much number, then why media and Congress politicians attacked Left and compelled to withdraw.
RE:Why should BJP support the Gvt.
by a a on Jul 11, 2008 11:10 AM Permalink
good said ndia will not allow to do neuk test, india is not able to dump that neuk waiste US will chage for that, india nuek station will be under servaleance of UN and US. not excepted, and india will in position to use that fuel after 10 year from now
that deal is agaist us india will not allow to do neuk test for ever
by a a on Jul 11, 2008 11:07 AM Permalink | Hide replies
india will not allow to do neuk test, india is not able to dump that neuk waiste US will chage for that, india nuek station will be under servaleance of UN and US. not excepted, and india will in position to use that fuel after 10 year from now
RE:that deal is agaist us india will not allow to do neuk test for ever
by BhagatSukhdevRajguru on Jul 11, 2008 11:09 AM Permalink
Thats why India lags Behind all nation inspite of Resources, Timing is important -- 1)Indian polititians never care for the timing.China has already signed one deal with US -work has started -- US & Russia has also signed Deal. 2)Dr.Kalam,Mr.Brajesh Mishra(BJP Advisor),other non-congress etc. are experts & visionary--they know the timing--- by the time India makes next goverment & sign the deal , it will take more 1-2 yrs.(already we took 2 yrs for this negotiation) -- we would lose the crucial time (more thn 3 yrs) -- china and other countries will be far ahead. 3) Any how even by supporting & signing the deal, advani's BJP would get in drivers seat in next year election -- And Mr.Advani could not decrease the inflation as oil prices are not in his control -- we have seen what they did in last government (cylinder prices rose to 300 Rs - Ram Naik was petroleum minister)-- their vision is narrow sighted -- only making political issue for bigger gain - only for himself & Party!!! ----- History will always ask questions?
Dr.Manmohansingh is one of an honest politician in record of indian.He is very genuin finance and developer ,devotee,sicere and intellegent SARDAR with loyality to india.Everybody should honour for DEAL.AKALIS MUST>
I was fully with the congress till yesturday. This morning I woke up to a surprise in Indian Express. Pl read the article and I bet you too will join Karat's party to oppose the N-Deal. It is not a N Deal, it is D-Deal for the country. Do you know one thing these IAEA board is trying to restrict your future options. This is a deal between Bush and MM, so that India's development options are curtailed. Bush has never favoured India in his tenure. His priority was - is - and will be Pakistan. Even today in Kabul Blast, Bush has never condemned Pak & ISI.
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SK2007 on Jul 11, 2008 11:24 AM Permalink
Hi all,
In front page of the Indian Expresee there is an article, which has analysed the deal with experts comments. Pl read and comment. Don't waste time. According to Indian Expresee report, India can't go to any other countries in future and even it can't pull out of the agreement ever in future. This means you are permanently married to these US, France or certain countries whose interest is to sell the N Material to India at their price. This is not acceptable. Thsi is the reason, according to Expresss, which has been hidden by Congress hoitherto.
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by pramodm on Jul 11, 2008 11:09 AM Permalink
Do you think you understand better than Manmohan singh about what country needs and what not? Communists are just playing to china's preference. BJP is desparate for power. So anything cong does is against national interst. We have to learn from communists who sided with enemies during freedom struggle and BJP for sleeping during struggle. Who are these people talking about national interst now? NO body will help you free. business is business, not service.
RE:RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SK2007 on Jul 11, 2008 11:26 AM Permalink
question is not MM or Karat, it is the country top of all. MM shoudl not have hidden this grave secret from the public.
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SI on Jul 11, 2008 11:09 AM Permalink
I saw your post yesterday opposing Congress.How many hours in your day?
RE:RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SK2007 on Jul 11, 2008 11:38 AM Permalink
Yesturday the news has just came out. Today the experts have analysed in full. Pl read : Pl read "ONCE IN, THERE IS NO WAY OUT" and How 'Secret' pact turned public?
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by Shreeom on Jul 11, 2008 11:11 AM Permalink
by reading indian expresses you had changed your mind...pl watch TV india ..you will change lot of thing..
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SK2007 on Jul 11, 2008 11:41 AM Permalink
You too might change your view if you read teh following article :
"ONCE IN, THERE IS NO WAY OUT" and How 'Secret' pact turned public?
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SK2007 on Jul 11, 2008 11:21 AM Permalink
According to Indian Expresee report, India can't go to any other countries in future and even it can't pull out of the agreement ever in future. This means you are permanently married to these US, France or certain countries whose interest is to sell the N Material to India at their price. This is not acceptable. Thsi is the reason, according to Expresss, which has been hidden by Congress hoitherto.
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SK2007 on Jul 11, 2008 11:36 AM Permalink
Pl read "ONCE IN, THERE IS NO WAY OUT" and How 'Secret' pact turned public?
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by All Right on Jul 11, 2008 11:11 AM Permalink
So what article in the Indian Express this morning made you join Karat.
Both the Editorial and Co-Editorial were extremely positive
RE:Oppose the N -Deal in its present format...
by SK2007 on Jul 11, 2008 11:34 AM Permalink
Pl read "ONCE IN, THERE IS NO WAY OUT" and How 'Secret' pact turned public?
Bjp opposing the N-deal,,,and trying to show that it is in the national interest,,, what FACE they will show to the future generations. AN ILLOGICAL AND ANTI-NATIONAL DECISION,, WHY DO NOT THEY ALLOW FREE VOTE, TO THEIR MPs.
RE:BJP OPPOSING NUCLEAR DEAL,- IT WILL BE A SELF - AND SELFISH GOAL
by All Right on Jul 11, 2008 11:04 AM Permalink
:-) Precisely the question one could ask why doesn't SP allow a free vote to their MPs?... :-)
By the way, just because A Nuclear Deal is in national interest, doest not automatically mean that THIS Nuclear Deal is also in national interest....
that's where you are really making an erroneous judgment..
RE:BJP OPPOSING NUCLEAR DEAL,- IT WILL BE A SELF - AND SELFISH GOAL
by SI on Jul 11, 2008 11:11 AM Permalink
Advani will tell which deal is in national interest and which is not.
RE:BJP OPPOSING NUCLEAR DEAL,- IT WILL BE A SELF - AND SELFISH GOAL
by SI on Jul 11, 2008 11:24 AM Permalink
Ever noticed that ministers arew sworn in while allies are not?
RE:BJP OPPOSING NUCLEAR DEAL,- IT WILL BE A SELF - AND SELFISH GOAL
by a a on Jul 11, 2008 11:03 AM Permalink
They will show as cong. is show after looting india from last 100 year and people like u are still with those gadaars