When SAD say "We really favor the deal, but will vote for BJP" it in essence is throwing egg on the face of BJP !! BJP should be ashamed of themselves, if they have that feeling left with them still..
Well done SAD... glad to hear your opinion at least...
RE:SAD in SAD position
by JJS Chauhan on Jul 10, 2008 03:13 PM Permalink
what is that you are trying to say. If SAD is for the deal they should stand with UPA. BJP has not pressurised SAD to vote for them or did horse trading like UPA. within few nmonths the rates on which MPs are bought will come to public knowledge. Crores of rupees will be changing hands. DeveGowda and Ajith Singh will take a big chunk. DeveGowda is waiting till the last day to pull maximum advantage. He is also a South Indian.
RE:SAD in SAD position
by VH on Jul 10, 2008 03:40 PM Permalink
I suggest you should learn to analyse the politics. No deal with any country,that too with USA,come as a free lunch. There is some give and take. So obviously India obliged a bit while gaining a bit,although technically India gain a lot in long term. As Moily said today that BJP wants the deal but dont want the credit go to Congress. While that is true, BJP also want to take political advantage from negetive points(the give part) in the deal by saying "Congress geopardised the country security".
With that in mind BJP is watching whether the Congress can muster majority on its own. If yes then its well & good. Otherwise BJP has to give something to get the deal. That is taking some embarassment it will ask (secretly though) SAD to vote for nuke deal. How come SAD got so much of love on nuke deal? Their answer is ready (although they havent given that yet). The answer is: "prime minister is a punjabi and sardarji. so we need to support a pajabi". Remember what reason Shivsena gave when it supported Prathibha Patil and not supporting Shekhavat? That is the precedence SAD (or BJP in a way) is using. Although that situation was much more embarrassing than this one.
Another thing is that BJP doesnt want government to fall now. It wanted govt to linger on because the more it stays there the more number of seats it looses in next election because of price rise & lack of action on terrorism. Unless one is a very smart leader it is hard to sell nuke deal to common man.
RE:RE:SAD in SAD position
by VH on Jul 10, 2008 03:43 PM Permalink
And congress doesnt have any such smart & charismatic leaders like Modi. So rest of the failures haunt them in next election.
RE:SAD in SAD position
by Bhagwat on Jul 10, 2008 03:21 PM Permalink
N-DEAL IS IN FAVOUR OF INDIANS.SAD i knowing and saying also.But very sad to say they will follow still BJP. SARDAR KEE NAK NA KATANA>EK Sardar MANMOHAN Singh DUSRE TUM SABCHUHAA N BAN JANA.SARDAR KA SATH SARDARI SE>
Prakash Singh Bada has said that Akali Dal would support the deal but would not vote for the UPA Govt. It would go with NDA and vote against the Govt. He seems to have gone mad to have spoken in contradiction. He must understand that the vote is not against the Govt but against the deal.If he supports the deal he should vote for the Govt. Why join the NDA which is out to bring down the govt so that they could face the elections early. This is total contradictory on the part of Badal especially when his Party is expected to meet on July 13 to decide the issue. It appears that he has not read the situation properly. If he had, he would definitely supported the Govt move to sign othe deal. PM has risked his Govt to go ahead with the deal only in the interest of the people of this country. This deal he must remember would bring cheers to millions of Indians are energy starving in many states. Ofcourse, it may not be the only source but one of them. The conventional energy from coal and water would not solve the problems. Govt have to explore Wind and Solar sources to meet some of the needs of the areas. Nuclear energy for many, would be supplemental and would be beneficial to the country as its dependence on the crude oil will come down. Iran gas line, if signed would also help India tide over some of the problems in this front. But India must be wary of US designs that it may try to sabotage the deal for its animosity towards Iran. India should gauard against such a move by USA.
RE:SAD with NDA - Badal has gone mad.
by Satya on Jul 10, 2008 03:08 PM Permalink
Follish Terror Jamsheed, We know how you people will act based on the situations.
"The SAD is in favour of the deal, but this does not imply that it will vote in favour of the UPA" Above line States we are in favour of deal but not with Congress -- clearly says even NDA also interested in N-deal.
RE:SAD with NDA - Badal has gone mad.
by sandip anand on Jul 10, 2008 03:26 PM Permalink
Vote of confidence is for the congress led govt and not for the nuclear deal, my dear friend. And being an opposition party, SAD as well as BJP have the right to vote against the vote. The vote has now become necessary not because of the opposition but because of the internal problems of the UPA, which is the "left group" (though they'll now say that they were theoretically never part of the UPA-well, they are the masters of playing with words). I am not a congress supporter but I wish they had some peace of mind to rule; if anyone hasn't allowed them to rule peacefully, it is the Left group and not the opposition.Poor Manmohan, he had to live with a 'noisy wife' and divorce is the only answer for a noisy relationship. Pity that it was so late. Hope the Indian voter will shun the criminals called 'left' !
RE:Hi
by Satya on Jul 10, 2008 03:03 PM Permalink
"The SAD is in favour of the deal, but this does not imply that it will vote in favour of the UPA" Above line States we are in favour of deal but not with Congress -- clearly says even NDA also interested in N-deal.
NDA is the only party looks for the national interest irrespective of religion.
RE:Hi
by JJS Chauhan on Jul 10, 2008 03:17 PM Permalink
How can you be so confident that the deal is good for the country. Did you read the agreement or did Manmoron singh gave you a copy to read. No one except perhaps MMS and Sonia had read the agreement. People are commenting for and aginst the deal even without knowing ki woh hathi hai ki tharbooja.
RE:Hi
by manish tiwary on Jul 10, 2008 03:14 PM Permalink
NDA is an alliance... NDA has not supported the deal so far. They including all parties are on same platform,they work only in their interests...
RE:BJP u have no coomonsense
by Suresh Babu on Jul 10, 2008 03:10 PM Permalink
BJP is a failed one and it is proved by itself that they never do anything for the poor people. This is evidence from six years rule of BJP. They are looting this nation in the name of God which does not exist.
this is sahadevan's Bhoot.....sahadeven is already died.....so rediff users dont mind his comment..........god give him peace of toilet paper in hell so he can not be shit here
