After all the noise they made about wanting the draft, the only thing they are doing is showing their hurt in not being privy to the draft- behaving like a child! They have till now offered no comment on the draft itself -which apparently seems to be OK. Even Dr AN Prasad an earlier critic feels the draft is OK.
As far the BJP is concerned, they will object to the present Govt for the sake of opposing. In fact even if the present Govt goes ahead and builds a RAM temple at Ayodhya, they will oppose it! Their spokesman is more a lawyer than a politician and his brief is just to oppose any move of the Govt. In fact the BJP stand a better chance of winning the next election if they supported the N deal!
RE:LEFT- and IAEA draft agreement
by Vinod Kumar on Jul 11, 2008 10:24 AM Permalink
helo sir even the congress will oppose it while it sits in the opposition, this r all political drama, why did'nt Mr.MMS do this before, he has wasted last 10 months in conveying the left with lots meetings, this is the neck time to push the deal. this shows that not to lose the POWER AND FOOLING THE PEOPLE
RE:LEFT- and IAEA draft agreement
by mahabodhi on Jul 11, 2008 11:21 AM Permalink
@deep dar BJP is antinational and anticonstitutional kulak party !Its constitution is Manusmirity !India did its first Ntest in 1974 ! It can be never right for the nation !It is pseudonatioanlaist ! Yes Congress was the surrogate mother of RSs!And RSSand BJP are one and same !RSS had many trojan horses in congress from the very begining !that goes in to milllions !That's onne reason when congress started loosing due to dumping by poors and minorties its RSS members imediately joined BJP !such as Kirti Azad the son of former Bihar CM !Krishan Pant !Even PVR Narsimha Rao was RSS stooges !Ask Atal Behari Vajpyee who calls him his Guru !The Manuwadi has been exposed ! who is against NDeal !Why Brijesh Mishra is for NDeal ! Kulaks and manuwadis such as abuse day in and day out but now these RSS wants to thru third interlocutors trying to have meeting with Left !and trying for startgy in the floor huse and who will propose the Nomotion trust !Who r these nonRSS -as reported by RSS supporting media - !This is also litmus test for left !And one must understand that if this NDeal is cleared then even Pakistan and even Iran may be allowed to such NDeal !this explains whether this NDeal is good or bad for India !BJP vote bank traders /bamias who import chinese products in to India r the biggest threat to India !they go regularly to china on the pretext of trade but what r their real motives !Are they mere traders who want to loot Indains by dumping chinese products or r they also spies
RE:RE:LEFT- and IAEA draft agreement
by mahabodhi on Jul 11, 2008 11:23 AM Permalink
!Are they mere traders who want to loot Indains by dumping chinese products or r they also spies for China!These traders who want to make fast money can do any thing for money !they r traitors and vote bank of RSS!RSS and BJp r same that's why Janta dal the first noncongress got split and BJP came in to exisitence !These r very Manuwadis who denied Jagkivan Ram the PM post as they only wanted his support but never wanted to him as PM !
RE:LEFT- and IAEA draft agreement
by critic on Jul 11, 2008 12:40 PM Permalink
MAHABODHI! You are really very BUDHIMAN! Most intelligent person who is blabbering NON_STOP! What do you want to convey just say in three lines & don't CONFUSE masses of India! Regards!
RE:LEFT- and IAEA draft agreement
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 11, 2008 04:47 PM Permalink
All clauses have faults. The deal made to become FAULTS. It is anti-national. Full of lies around it. LEFT PARTIES ARE PATRIOTS. BJP AND CONGRESS ARE ANTI-NATIONALS.
RE:LEFT- and IAEA draft agreement
by deep dar on Jul 11, 2008 09:42 AM Permalink
i wonder why this article is silent on the aspect of India not conducting further nuclear tests! Is the BJP right after all?
RE:LEFT- and IAEA draft agreement
by soorma on Jul 11, 2008 09:57 AM Permalink
silent means they have no objections... India can pursue its strategic programme.... BJP is lying to nation... They should stop wrong propaganda... Otherwise BJP will lose a major share of middle class votes...
RE:Please explain
by critic on Jul 11, 2008 12:57 PM Permalink
WHY REDIFF? WHY DON'T YOU ASK THE UPA GOVT.? WHY they are hiding the facts & content of Deal?
Very very impressed to see rediff (and NDTV like media) taking a lot of trouble to 'educate' us about how this 'deal' is the most useful thing happened to us Indians till date!
Thank you media for 'feeding' us that this deal is good for us and the madam and others are our gods!
RE:impressed!!!
by critic on Jul 11, 2008 01:00 PM Permalink
YES! MADAME IS Goddess of INDIA! YOU TOO should also BOW to HER as UPA is DOING! You may also strike GOLD like SP Mulayam SINGH! Best of luck!
RE:kick the govt out
by mahabodhi on Jul 11, 2008 12:39 PM Permalink
U r RSSBJP bigot !U can go any length to give away the Indian soverignity also !Ur forefathers were bootlickers of Mughals -that's why they had matrimonoail allinces with Mughal-only marrying their princess to Mughjals -why-so that they can stil rule with Manusmirity even under Mughal patronage !Why only upper castes were give title of Rai Bahadur by British !why !why even the Gandhi was given Kaiser E Hind for serving the Britsh raj ! But even these kulaks party know that they can not survive with out help from poors so even ur favorite RSSBJP- also support this recommendation of Congress and Congress is surrogate mother of RSS!so u who calls thenself arayan from Arctic u r exposed ! Read Chamcha /age by Kanshi Ram for broader political vision !
RE:kick the govt out
by critic on Jul 11, 2008 01:08 PM Permalink
MAHABODHI! Intelligent blabberer please be quite or take your Hypertensive control drugs soon!
The nation knows that the alliance was not working. I am surprised at the conclusion of Mr. Raghavan to the contrary. What seems to be the right conclusion is that Manmohan Singh played well by using the N-deal to expose the damage nation is undergoing (and I mean poor Indians...) by electing these relics of "ancien regime". I hope that Jyoti Basu's fears come true and they lose in W. Bengal and in Kerala in next elections. Buddha Deb is in the wrong company. Moderate socialists have to recognize their real enemy. It is this bunch of comrades. This should help realignment of politics and dum-dums of UNPA should either quit or isolate these rascals.
RE:Alliance was working well?
by Sumanth Singh on Jul 10, 2008 11:32 PM Permalink
Who is this miscreant - Bull Shit Raghavan. The agreement is seriously flawed. Text of Brahma Chellaney's article:
It must be doubly embarrassing for New Delhi to see the Vienna-based International Atomic Energy Agency let the cat out of the bag before Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had returned home from the G-8 summit. By revealing that “at the request of the Government of India” it had circulated the safeguards accord’s text to its board members and begun the process for an extraordinary board meeting, the IAEA belied New Delhi’s assurance to the nation not to approach the Agency before Dr. Singh had won a vote of confidence in Parliament.
Also, in helping to make the text public, the IAEA only mocked New Delhi’s claim that it cannot share the text even in confidence with “third parties”, like the Left, which had been propping up the governing coalition. In fact, after the text had appeared on various international websites since Wednesday night, New Delhi claimed credit on Thursday afternoon for “unveiling” it!
Now we know why the accord was shrouded in such secrecy. A careful reading of its text raises several red flags:
■ Far from it being an India-specific agreement, the accord resembles IAEA agreements with non-nuclear-weapons states. With the exclusion of the first two pages that contain the preamble, the accord starting from Section I, “General Directions,” on Page 3 to the very end, is largely modelled on IAEA safeguards agreements with non-
RE:Alliance was working well?
by critic on Jul 11, 2008 01:13 PM Permalink
Where is rest of your comments Dear! ****" Now we know why the accord was shrouded in such secrecy. A careful reading of its text raises several red flags:
■ Far from it being an India-specific agreement, the accord resembles IAEA agreements with non-nuclear-weapons states. With the exclusion of the first two pages that contain the preamble, the accord starting from Section I, “General Directions,” on Page 3 to the very end, is largely modelled on IAEA safeguards agreements with non-"***** Please post them! Regards!
RE:Alliance was working well?
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 11, 2008 04:47 PM Permalink
All clauses have faults. The deal made to become FAULTS. It is anti-national. Full of lies around it. LEFT PARTIES ARE PATRIOTS. BJP AND CONGRESS ARE ANTI-NATIONALS.
RE:Alliance was working well?
by prabhat mohanty on Jul 11, 2008 09:16 AM Permalink
- What did you see in the stated paragraphs about merits and demerits of the Nuclear agreement?
RE:Alliance was working well?
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 11, 2008 04:50 PM Permalink
RAGHAVAN DOES NOT SAY THE CORRECT THING. I SAY, "MANMOHAN MADE THIS DEAL TO TIE INDIA WITH THE LEG OF GEROGE BUSH."
