It is the prerogative and also of duty of Leader of Opposition to say to rulling party which have lost suport of another party to bring confidence votion in parliamnet, if goverment fail to do so than is is the firm duty of opposition party to bring non confidence motion in parliament. at present situation it look that goverment has lost the support of majority ,so for smooth running of parlimentry democracy govremnet should immediately seek confience motion
RE:Prerogative of Leader of Opposition
by arp on Jul 05, 2008 01:38 PM Permalink
Well said dear Shiv Thakur.If lefts is saying that they will withdraw the support how a minority govt can take decision.So MMS sud get majority in the house if left withdraw support.
RE:Prerogative of Leader of Opposition
by RAVINDRA MANJREKAR on Jul 05, 2008 01:42 PM Permalink
That can be done only when the parliament session is conveyed in the month of August 2008.Otherwise the Govt/President of India has to arrange for its earlier coveyance,to seek vote of confidence by the UPA.
RE:Prerogative of Leader of Opposition
by Shiv Thakur on Jul 05, 2008 01:52 PM Permalink
it is the consitutional duty of Honable president to instuct rulling party any time when goverment has lost support of majority by arrangeing special session. becasue goverment going to sign a prminent agreement. this is my question that when majority of any goverment is doubt than how PM is auhtorized to sign on this deal. PM is responsible to house it means he also to responsibe to public of union of India.
RE:Are politician Much educated than Dr. KALAM
by Onlooker on Jul 05, 2008 01:39 PM Permalink
We still haven't got rid of the herd mentality. Should it matter if it is Kalam or abc? Shouldn't we be discussing the pro's and con's of the issue? Kalam must definitely have to be a politician to a smaller extent to rise to that level if he is not from a privileged section of India society.
In 6 years Advani & Co made policies for America; INDIA SHINED. sit in the closed room of CIA. What confidence motion? People lost confidence on him. The only way left to kill whole leadership in AKG Bhawan.
RE:In 6 years Advani & Co made policies for America; INDIA SHINED. sit in the closed room of CIA. What confidence motion? People lost confidence on him. The only way left to kill whole leadership in AKG Bhawan.
by jj on Jul 05, 2008 01:31 PM Permalink
Sick again
RE:In 6 years Advani & Co made policies for America; INDIA SHINED. sit in the closed room of CIA. What confidence motion? People lost confidence on him. The only way left to kill whole leadership in AKG Bhawan.
by arp on Jul 05, 2008 01:33 PM Permalink
Barking dogs party never belives in democracy,only blives in killings like done in Singur,Cooch Bihar,Nandi Gram.Compare interest rates for common indian ppl in NDA govt and now in UPA govt supporting by barking dogs party.
RE:In 6 years Advani & Co made policies for America; INDIA SHINED. sit in the closed room of CIA. What confidence motion? People lost confidence on him. The only way left to kill whole leadership in AKG Bhawan.
by jacob tiger dawa on Jul 05, 2008 01:55 PM Permalink
Dear ARP, y dnt you sit n compare the rate @which crude is quoting tday n when NDA was in power...crude has gone up more then 100%..have some sense n try living a real life...You wont benifit by being blind to the Current situation...
Why you want to renegotiate the deal? why can't you just support it as it is, after the most eminent scientist and ex-President have said that the interest of the nation should be kept above party politics. Will Advani heed to the advise of Shree APJ Abdul Kalam or they will show the same short sighted view they have been taking till now?
RE:You support the deal Mr. Advani, Listen to ex-PRESIDENT Kalam.
by Rocky Balboa(xyz) on Jul 05, 2008 01:45 PM Permalink
The same deal is opposed by eminent nuclear scientists. The question is why the givt want to hide the details. The govt should comeout openly on this issue as this deal is in national importance. The future generation should not suffer because of this deal
RE:You support the deal Mr. Advani, Listen to ex-PRESIDENT Kalam.
by DAWA JACOB on Jul 05, 2008 02:03 PM Permalink
the govt is going to come out n discuss the deal with the members OF the house after it gets all the required approvals ....the govt is in hurry cause ,after we approve it here it will be discussed in the US congress...so the time in hand is very limited...we jst want to have the freedom to conduct nuclear explosion ...that is jst to fool the common public that we are a nuclear state...
Remember the period from 1999 to 2005 1. Nuclear test done by India. 2. Delhi Metro project started 3. Conditions of National Highways improved. 4. Plan to connect all rivers initiated 5. This would have avoided floods & droughts ... ... ... ... The list is endless And all this happen when NDA was into power & India was shinning
And now see where these bloody lefts & congress has taken India to, India has lost all its shine.
RE:This government shud fall
by Stalin Selvamoni on Jul 05, 2008 01:32 PM Permalink
those projects and achievements were started when Congress was in power. BJP is bad for Indian image both nationally and internationally because they are religious fundamantelists worse than the communists!
RE:This government shud fall
by Shiv Thakur on Jul 05, 2008 01:42 PM Permalink
Stalin I would like explain some thing about the above mentioned project. 1. although it is fact the we are ready Nuclear blast for pokhran II since 1979. but any prime minister shown power to make blast, neither Indira nor Rajiv, nor Narshimha Rao. IK ,DEVe. that is AB Vajpayee who taken difficult decesion to mke blast becase in 1966 when china ahd made blast than ABV had told in Rajshabha . Parmanoo bomb ka jawab parmanoo bamb se denge. 2. Delhi Metro is the creation of Madan lal Khurana. 3.National highway projectt was a deam AB vajpayye. 4. Plann to likllin the all reavers it was lying under dust since 1953.
RE:RE:This government shud fall
by DAWA JACOB on Jul 05, 2008 02:09 PM Permalink
shiv thats a bullshit explanition..... the nuclear explosion was jst to fool the indian people...China is a monster...even the US fears...it was a faild govt trying to fool people by creating false pride...i think we jsut want to compete with pakistan...even a premitive afganistan has guts to challange pakistan...so lets not harp much about Pokhran...
RE:Manu Bhai
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 05, 2008 01:58 PM Permalink
BJP cries foul that it is a party with difference. It changes its policy in a daily basis. One day they make alliance with Maya; then no alliance. Always criticised Left on Bandh. Now Kill on bandh and it became a BANDH JUNK PARTY.
RE:BJP should support the deal and congress party
by arp on Jul 05, 2008 01:22 PM Permalink
Go thru BJP statement.BJP never oppose nuke deal.BJP wants to delete HYDE ACT from this nuke deal 123.
RE:BJP should support the deal and congress party
by Onlooker on Jul 05, 2008 01:28 PM Permalink
This is typical of BJP. BJP would not even have bargained this far. This communal party is very dangerous to the country.
RE:BJP should support the deal and congress party
by jj on Jul 05, 2008 01:29 PM Permalink
Mr. Tarun do u know Chinese have similar agreement with US? I would suggest u go through that agreement then u will find where the problem is? I am not advocating in favor of Communist nor BJP but why there is descrimination with India? Why there is no Hyde act for them? etc. etc.
RE:BJP should support the deal and congress party
by DAWA JACOB on Jul 05, 2008 02:12 PM Permalink
123 agreement is an international agreement...it will not be affected by Hyde act...in that case we can also pass a ACT n counter it..we are getting a better bargain then China...thats the reason China dsn wants it 2 happen...
RE:BJP should support the deal and congress party
by ramji on Jul 05, 2008 01:26 PM Permalink
not just pulling their legs, they are necking them out either do it or get out,deal is not acute emergency.BJP will surely think,bargain some more and then ink
RE:BJP should support the deal and congress party
by RAJEEV GUPTA on Jul 05, 2008 01:27 PM Permalink
BJP is the only party which does not require a "Nationalist Party" certificate from anybody.All other parties indulging in the anti-national activities definitely require it.
is as good or bad as their fast friend communists.Congress should not got trapped and declare the General Elections to save its image[whatever is left]
