RE:Anyway, Mask of Jehadi appeasement has fallen off from CPIM, psuedos face.
by Sam Nath on Jan 31, 2008 09:20 AM Permalink
Hi Tatha, Your vision is great. I am a Prabashi Bengali for last 20 years and I do Salute your contribution.
1. Taslima's book was upheld by Calcutta High Court. CPIM and local fanatic Muslims did NOT approach the Supreme Court agaist that- they started rioting.
MF Hussian has fled the country, and did NOT face the court.
WHAT WOULD CPIM, PSUEDO MEDIA SAID, IF MF HUSSIAN WERE CLEARED BY INDIAN COURT?
2. Taslima condemns regresive traditions of ALL religions. She has severely condemned BJP, many Hindu practises. Hindus did NOT start riot.
BUT MULLAHS STARTED RIOTING. AND CPIM SURRENDERED FOR MUSLIM VOTE.
RE:Why Taslima's case is not same as Hussain
by Tathagata Mukherjee on Jan 31, 2008 08:29 AM Permalink
3. Not a single BJP MLA/MP tried to physically assult MF Hussian, or his work. But there are MIM MLAs who tried to physically eliminate Taslima.
And what psuedos have done so far is kept mum, took no action against them.
RE:Why Taslima's case is not same as Hussain
by riten dash on Jan 31, 2008 08:54 AM Permalink
The process which started in proscribing books in Bengal has now been completed by banning of book fair itself.Books causing pollution? I think some section of "secular" bengal are afraid that books may "pollute" minds and we do not need them especially around Parkcircus.
It is not only Buddhadev Bhattacharya another Bengali is there, name Pranab Mukherjee. And recently nominated for PadmaBhusan. And all of them are SECULAR.
RE:It is not Only CPI-M, Congress is also Part of it
by Simhan on Jan 31, 2008 08:56 AM Permalink
right, because isckon distributes ladoos instead of bombs...
There are strong indications that CPIM gets funds from Arab Countries these days.
It may be noted, veteran CPIM leader and architect of Left Front Promod Das Gupta had to go to PAKISTAN CONSULATE IN CALCUTTA N 1960S PRIOR TO LEFT FRONT CAME TO POWER BRIEFLY.
I see some people are comparing it with Hussain. But unlike Taslima, he was never pushed under carpet by any elected Govt of India. Hussain himself wanted not to face any trial in court - which is why he went out of the country. But in Taslima's case there was no case in any court against her - and simply bowing to the demands of some criminal-minded fundamentalist Muslims (who by no chance represent the Muslim community of India/WB) the Govt drove out of her chosen city. The wrong needs to be corrected immediately and the Govt should apologise to her.
If a Writer creats unrest in the society, if a Painter hurts the feelings of many and that too of another religious followers, what the Amnesty International can do. The best thing that they should do is to call such individuals and provide them a separate world for themselves. It is similar to a drop of poison in a pot of milk. Can the speaker educate that we are born individually and salvation is through individual's efforts only and not enmass.That is the Hindu philosophy and therefore freedom is given to individuals to pursue his way of salvation.
RE:RE:Fundamentals
by Rohan Choukkar on Jan 31, 2008 07:54 AM Permalink
Your religion is your own private concern. Not mine. Or anyone else's. No one has the right to impose their code of morals upon anyone else.
RE:Fundamentals
by kumar saha on Jan 31, 2008 08:04 AM Permalink
i agree with u. no body can stop freedom of speech or thinking. These new hindu should learn what is Hinduism. There is no point to encourage Talibanism or Thakre culture.
RE:What noted economist Lord Meghnad Desai said on CPIM
by Golden on Jan 31, 2008 07:53 AM Permalink
this history will be repeated again and again. dont worry about this. go and work on mfhussains issues. you need to shout idiotic slogans on the road and then you need time to support taslima, though you dont know what she has actually written. you only support shaitaan who pleases you. a supporter of shaitaan is shaitaan only.
RE:What noted economist Lord Meghnad Desai said on CPIM
by Vasanth Srinivas on Jan 31, 2008 08:05 AM Permalink
"Golden" - Better go and bark your islamic values out in Bangladesh / Porkistan (Excellent Democratic countries). Dont bark here. No sane person will have a look.
RE:What noted economist Lord Meghnad Desai said on CPIM
by kumar saha on Jan 31, 2008 08:14 AM Permalink
i know what she has written. She has written about some fundamental flaw mentioned in Koran and she also exposed the Muslim society to the world about their cruelty towards women and religious minority [hindus in Bangladesh]
It is matter of shame that a great writer like Taslima is mis treated by politicians just to please muslim votes. If you dont like a artist dont read her book. she is world know writer anyway. but to not let her live in peace is shamefull. One side we are growing fast, making progress on all front and other side out mentality is so backward. we cant respect a woman writer. This kind of attitude will take our nation in backward direction. We must show progressive and liberal mind set if want our nation to grow as world power.
RE:Disrespect to Taslima means our attitude is backward. we have no liberal, progressive attitude.
by Golden on Jan 31, 2008 07:54 AM Permalink
any idea what has happened to hussain? any word on his issue, bihari dehati bhai.
RE:VOTE FOR COMMUNISM
by Cricket Devta on Jan 31, 2008 07:00 AM Permalink
you take communism today, you'll be a communist pet! You differ tomorrow, you'll be beaten to death!
Why compare him with Narendra Modi? There is not a single case of Riot in Gujarat for last Six years. and look at Bengal, Taslima issue, Singur issue, Nandigram issue and powerty, unemployment and party workers autocracy. He is not even NM's jutiya.
RE:He is not even NMs pav ki juti.
by Golden on Jan 31, 2008 07:57 AM Permalink
you are right, Narendra Modi is actually a bigger killer. NM keep denying the fact and keep murdering innocent lives for the satisfaction of his hatred. at least buddha was working for his progress of the state and putting an industry, not for his hatred.
