RE:only Modi deserves Bharat Ratna
by Pat Thakur on Jan 09, 2008 10:16 PM Permalink
No. Genocide was the work of experts like Indira & Rajiv & were conferred the Bharat Ratna in recognition...
RE:Why we can't give Atalji Bharat Ratna......but Bharat Ratna for Rajiv
by Secular India on Jan 09, 2008 09:41 PM Permalink
I suppport Modi for Bharat Ratna. True man of action and courage. He is the only one who translated the dreams of Atalji and Advani into reality. Atalji had a family even though not married. For Modi, India is his family. Atal was soft on Pakistan and terror which resulted in Kargill and Parliament attack. Modi would have never committed such blunders. If he shakes Musharraf's hands - he will crush it. He is superman.
RE:Why we can't give Atalji Bharat Ratna......but Bharat Ratna for Rajiv
by Amitabh Das on Jan 09, 2008 09:55 PM Permalink
Atal Jee is great. But even Rajiv was not as bad as you are saying. He had a vision for developed India. He bought the much criticized weapon, Bofors tanks but they proved themselves as the best tank during kargil war. The greatest thing which he did in his life was the decision to destroy sri lankan militants in such a way that they never got the power to fight back. Go to sri lanka and you will see the people who really love Rajiv. Militancy should not be accepted at any cost whether it%u2019s promoted by a Pakistani or an Indian.
I agree that Vajpayee can be considered Bharat Ratna for his contributions. But PV Narasimha Rao should be considered for it ahead of him. So far we have been an ungreatful nation towards him due to political reasons.
RE:PV first
by asdfg on Jan 09, 2008 09:27 PM Permalink
absolutely correct my friend. I am a gujarati but feel, pv was a great leader who wanted the best for the nation. infact scindia and pv are the only two congressi that i would have liked to seen them as PM.
RE:PV first
by Amitabh Das on Jan 09, 2008 09:58 PM Permalink
Very well said!. His economic policy's were great. Though Atal Jee truely deserves the bharat ratna award. But Advani jee is looking for his nomination due to political advantage.
RE:PV first
by Pat Thakur on Jan 09, 2008 10:22 PM Permalink
Aise karo, sab Zone ke jitne bhi Leaders hai, saala sab ko Bharat Ratna baat do; har Zone ka quota poora aur phir Leader bhi taiyyar, naye josh se marne ke liye - logon ki...
Teh old age could lead your mind malfunctiong. This is true what's happening with Advani. he does not know, what he asks for or what he says. He may not have taken his medication? If Vajpayee, has done something for India, he will get reward sooner or later.
There is more political motive in this move. Advani wants to be a initiator and center of a discussion, and we all as to how this will end. Honor is not to be sought or craved. By this act he has only made the life of Atal miserable.
RE:Good way to be talked about
by Ramdas Iyer on Jan 09, 2008 09:57 PM Permalink
From this gentleman's name (Narasimhan) it appears that he hails from Tamil Nadu. And the whole world knows how and why M G Ramachandran got Bharat Ratna. So people from Tamil Nadu better not comment on this story
