RE:Honour Vajpayee with the Bharat Ratna: Advani tells PM
by sudipta basu on Jan 09, 2008 09:29 PM Permalink
in a secular state, one ledaer of communal party seeking Bharat ratna for his collegue - realy surprising. Differences between Advani and vajpayee is very welknow, actualy it is nothing but Advani's tactics to take the confidence of vajpayee for the next general election where BJP want to promote Advani for PMcandidate.
Undoubtedly, one of the greatest politicians (yes politician, but with a difference) of his generation, Atalji is not just respected and honored within his party, but also in the opposition! Not just within the country, but also all over the world! (I can recall how one of my American friends praised him detailing- how US opposition had for the first time demanded for a joint session for hearing the 'best orator'! I am not looking for some foreign 'approvers', just quoting the fact!)
A son of the school teacher, Mr Vajpayee for over 60 years of his public life, has never been accused personally! An achievement- very few in the world can boast of! His honesty and integrity is remarkable, unparallel, and widely-accepted!
A poetic heart at helm, he is more-or-less responsible for steering the country onto path of rapid developments and economic progress, in spite of having a factored mandate. (Golden Quadrilateral, Pokhran-2, Kargil Victory, Intelluctual scientist- APJ A. Kalam as President... and more importantly a sence of 'hope' he bestowed in young India- to name a few of his achievements as PM)
Atalji has a number of times represented the country into various international forums (UN) and have successfully defended and conveyed the country's message over important issues including disputes with Pak!
An unparallel orator, and man who gave his life for selfless service for the country, based upon principles really deserves the country's highest civilian award.
RE:If not Atalji, then who?
by Poopa on Jan 09, 2008 09:27 PM Permalink
If there is a person who is really worthy of the Bharat Ratna, it is our pretty pari, the queen of grace and beauty Shilpa Shetty..
She has revolutionalized the world by her beauty and brains and created awareness about racism.(much more than Nelson Mandela).
In fact, she should get the Nobel peace prize in addition to the Bharat Ratna.
Please join me in offering salaams to this jewel on earth...SHILPA SHETTY..SHETTY..SHETTY...
By bestowing just "Bharat Ratna" to Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee, it'll equate his contributions to likes of Indra Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi. I think, it'll be utterly unfair. Bestowing will be just first step in right direction.
Remember, it's was under Shri Vajpayee's leadership, India could think of becoming something in economic arena FIRST time in our history. He gave hope to billions of people who're seen like poor and weak thanks to communist policies of Nehru family followed over six decades.
First time in India's history, it was proven that coalition can provide economic and political stability adding much-needed concept to Indian democracy. Nehru family's contribution is just their whims to political process in this country.
We only have to think if "Bharat Ratna" is enough recognition to his contributions.
RE:Shri Vajpayee deserves more.
by Ramesh Kapoor on Jan 09, 2008 08:50 PM Permalink
Sonia Gandhi deserves it more than Vajpayeeji. Why even raise the point, Mr. Advaniji, you cannot ask a beggar to give alms.
RE:Shri Vajpayee deserves more.
by Solid Man on Jan 09, 2008 08:54 PM Permalink
It was during his time, that mushrraf came to india and made a mock of our diplomacy. It was during his time that Kargil happened. It was during his prime-ministership, his beloved pramodji became a billionaire. It was during his time Unit Trust of India (UTI) saw one of the biggest financial sector scams and the net asset of the company has been reduced by Rs 25,000 crore, hitting the company's flagship saving scheme of US-64 in which legion of small savers, retired people, widows and pensioners had put their life-time earnings It was during his time that one of his minister was caught on tape accepting bribe (remember judeo tape). It was during his time that the CAG has exposed that the former NDA regime had spent an unauthorised sum of Rs. 62.3 crore on its %u2018India Shining%u2019 media blitz just on the eve of last year%u2019s general elections. There are numerous scams which cannot be mentioned here but I must say that this guys must get a Bharat Ratna. This guy when in opposition between 1991 and 1996, opposed PVN Rao and Manmohan Singh and said that the foreign company would come again and capture india. I remember lots of Bharat band in the name of swadeshi. This same guy when he came in power after PVN Rao, he followed the same economic policy and then he's all there to take credit for good work started by MMS. This guy (Atal) should definitely get a Bharat Ratna. He's been accused personally but cries foul when someone does it but prefers to keep mum if
RE:RE:Shri Vajpayee deserves more.
by asdfg on Jan 09, 2008 09:31 PM Permalink
just a quick note about musharraf's visit. his guard of honor was with all the soldiers taller than him, thus he was looked down upon. realize that fighting with Pakistan will not help India. We need a peaceful nation to strive economically.
RE:Shri Vajpayee deserves more.
by BigDesi on Jan 09, 2008 09:03 PM Permalink
I agree Kargil was a failure.
How he can be made responsible for personal acts of other individuals? That's not very smart. Corruption is amongst all of us, no matter who we're? Look at his personal record. Is there who can come close to him even a mile?
Let's not bring personal political affiliations while deciding who deserves top national award.
Moreover, Indra and Rajiv can get the award, I've no hesitation supporting Shri Vajpayee's name.
Moreover, if we start looking at failures, Nehru, Gandhi and Indra are top names. We have to look at total impact.
RE:Shri Vajpayee deserves more.
by Solid Man on Jan 09, 2008 09:13 PM Permalink
sonia gandhi should be voted as bharath ratna being an italian she is doing soo much for this coutry..she is a lady of sacrifice
RE:RE:Shri Vajpayee deserves more.
by Tamil Arasan on Jan 09, 2008 09:25 PM Permalink
How can you say Kargil was a failure, you must see the government action after that incident, he gave order immediately to our army to take action against the intruders, in the history of Kasmir war first time Indian air force used, now kargil is a golden chapter in Indian history where our mighty army defeated the Islamic terrorist.
RE:Shri Vajpayee deserves more.
by BigDesi on Jan 09, 2008 09:38 PM Permalink
Good point! We can't attribute Kargil as Shri Vajpayee's failure. If we can, who we should attribute losing territories in Kashmir and North-east to?
When software industry was tottering during economic recession period in 1998 , he created a task force and stopped the impact and implemented the task force recommendation.
Advani is making a fopol of himself and revered Vajpayee...These things are not that noteworthy..that Bharat Ratna needs to be conferred.... Just becos he said.."yes " lets fight Pak in 71 and Yes to coalation..since he was power hungry..Yes to economic reforms(congress initative)...BHarat Ratna neednt be conferred....for that Matter every Indian did welcome all the decisions that weere mentioned above..then why single out Vajpayee..Every Indian should be conferred thenm
