Was the woman raped in the Mumbai bus going to a maharashtrian suburb by the bus conductor and driver also an act of the migrants? Most of the names of the people caught in the JWT incident which are being flashed in the media are those of the marathis..what will uddhav say now..It is habit of shiv sena to to issue statements which are nothing but self aggrandisement while turning the blame to the migrants.. Mumbai was just a fishermen's village till migrants from all parts of India have made it the city. The behaviour of the culprits in question here is abominable whosoever they are but to blame biharis or any other 'migrant' is plane irresponsible.
RE:Crap!!
by amit on Jan 06, 2008 11:39 AM Permalink
ther r marathis, bhaiyas, a convert and a singh, i dont know its hard to say, anyways ppl should think that everyone who lives in a particular state should call themselves by that state, for example all people living in maharashtra should call themselves maharashtrians, all people living in W Bengal should call themselves Bengalis, what a wonderful idea to remove the state biases we indians have?
RE:Crap!!
by nitin on Jan 06, 2008 11:40 AM Permalink
There were 70 people only 14 arrested. The main culprit caught in camera is shukla. Last year the culprits at Gateway of india all were muslims form UP Bihar
As far as I know it is the Bihar and Ganga culture because of them we have got all the achievement in our gloriouse history. During the time magadh rule only india expanded its base.
some person from UP / Bihar is no doubt with criminal mind but you can not blame on every UP/Biharis. Let me tell frenkly I never seen hard working person in india like biharis.
RE:Don't abuse UP / Biharis
by eternal sunshine on Jan 06, 2008 11:33 AM Permalink
Do you have a Bihari working at your home with your wife when you are out pireting Capton? Please be careful. having bihari cook is a thing and having bihari kids is another...
RE:RE:Don't abuse UP / Biharis
by CaptJackSparrow on Jan 06, 2008 11:50 AM Permalink
Any way I don't have any bihari working at home but it seems some bihari did something to you.
RE:Don't abuse UP / Biharis
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 12:05 PM Permalink
All Biharis and Bhaiyyas are hard working,,,only thing is they cant work hard in their own state,,,that is the sad part..Secondly all the rapes, robberis, murders, molestation, illegal slums, shanties have mushroomed in Mumbai because of biharis, Upites and rest low class indians. UP, BIhar, Tamil, Kerela, Andhra, Bengal are great, prosperous state go there and do whatever you need to do.
It is high time that leaders like Thakre keep their mouth close. They are d real culprits for the nation for their dividing policies and practices. Is Mumbai their private property? It is the hard earned money of all citizen of India which makes Mumbai a star city. If his reference is for molestation - then he must realise half of the culprits are of marathi origin. It is a shameless act - must be condemned but not on caste,religious or regional basis.
RE:Migrants defames mumbaie
by nitin on Jan 06, 2008 11:50 AM Permalink
how many times marathi boyz have been caught like this, if the arrested persons are really culprits then they must be punished. But all outsiders should understand it very clearly that living in a city and loving a city is different thing. We know that most of the people who are making mumbai a hell to live are from UP and Bihar.My relative who is a grape producer in Nashik made a deal of 3 lac's for his grape crop. The Bihari trader with whom he had made some deals in past gave him 50 thousand on the promise that he will retun the remaining money on delivery. My relative deliveres truck load of Grapes to the Biharis godown. But Bihari promised that he will pay it next. But next day he fleed to bihar selling all grapes to another bihari. After waiting for 10 days, my relative went bihar with his son to the address he got from another bihari. He reached their only to get threaten on gunpoint. After that incident in people in Niphad taluka in Nashik dist. stop trading with Up and bihar people. Now they just beat every bihari and upwala who come to deal.
RE:RE:Migrants defames mumbaie
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 11:55 AM Permalink
Lets start fumigating these outside insects all over Maharashtra,,,they are pushing our patience.
RE:Migrants defames mumbaie
by eternal sunshine on Jan 06, 2008 11:36 AM Permalink
Dear Varsha, Neither Thakare's not any Maratha's came your dirty UP and Bihar inviting you to work here. If you and other bhaiyya's (including the nautanki Bacchhan-s)have any self respect, go back to your bhaiyya land and try improving that place... PARACITES!!!
RE:Migrants defames mumbaie
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 11:53 AM Permalink
I think Varsha needs a Bihari and Bhaiyya Buffalo treatment in a "Tabela"
RE:Migrants defames mumbaie
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 12:14 PM Permalink
Varsha,,,Mumbai is Marathi's private property, It's in Maharashtra. Tell and close the mouth of your dirtbag leaders in your state, don't try to be macho here,,,will make it very difficult for you,,,Remember we run the govt and we are in charge in this state. So be careful what you wish for. It was Bhiyaa who molested the girl,,,all the Marathi boys were onlookers. They were questioned to find out about other Upites and Bihari goons. They must be hiding or gone back to their villages where they came from. What hard money? People like you who live in slums,near to pipelines,railway tracks, dumping grounds who don't have real homes, what kind of taxes you pay? We the real inhabitants of this state is paying for the upkeep of this city. You know what just wait till the next election,,,we will decide,,,what needs to be done,,,once and for all.
RE:Migrants defames mumbaie
by Abhinay Verma on Jan 06, 2008 12:51 PM Permalink
If all the marathi boys were onlookers, this only proves that u marathis are cowards.... If it hadn't been for North Indians, Mumbai wud hv remained a fisherman's area... And India is ours.... we don't need Thakre's invitation to come to Mumbai because we as Indians own Mumbai.... If Roger Binny here and others of his clan have a problem with that, they can keep getting frustrated here.... North Indians will keep coming to Mumbai.... Nobody can stop us
Thakre are bhramins who ruled maharastra from Peshwa time. They want to rule any how. They hate muslim irespective of their language whether marathi or non-marathi. They hate dalits, especially the followers of ambedkar. They hate bhujbal, they hate ambedkar, they even hate Abdul Kalam. Irrespective of logic and affiliations they supported Shali Tai, a Marathi Manus. Had congress given the ticket of President to a dalit or backward from maharstra they never supported him because he for them they are not even manus These people are most rascist people even more than Australian. So if they hate migrants or tamils or bhaiya what is wrong. They wanna rule and this is politics. We have seen the rise of Mumbai and soon we will see the fall of Mumbai.
RE:hate list of Thakre
by amit on Jan 06, 2008 11:15 AM Permalink
Thackrey's are not brahmins he is a CKP, who are not brahmins. Dont defame someone with wrong information. Although i am not Shiv Sena fan he has united Hindus against ppl like Manu(who use false identity and pretend to be hindus)Bal Thackrey is against deceptive people like you who divides indians
RE:hate list of Thakre
by Manu on Jan 06, 2008 11:26 AM Permalink
No body can devide a home even bond is strong. Against whom Thakary is uniting Hindus. Against 40 carores people from UP, Bihar, Rajasthan or Tamil Hindus or Hindus from South. Are they not Hindu? Is BhairoSingh Shekhawat not a hindu? The dalits of nagpur are not hindus. Talking about Hinduism for your own interest will not serve a perpose. Thogh I am a hindu, but donot need any certificate or protection from Thakare. I am not in maharastra and never want to come also.
RE:hate list of Thakre
by amit on Jan 06, 2008 11:47 AM Permalink
Its ok Manu, i do understand your dilemma, i agree that thackrey did a lot of bad things but all that after mumbai suffered terribly after 93 blasts. If you are struck first you have to take some action, He didnt do it wisely,but he did it to secure peoples feelings that you are not without any support. Look at Iraq, after US was hit, you have to take action against bullies, maharashtra has always been disciplined and a uniting force against religious fundamentals
RE:hate list of Thakre
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 11:52 AM Permalink
If you are not in Maharashtra,,,then shut the f up,,,and go back to your hell hole,,,and rot.
What Uddhav probably forgot is that Bal Thackeray is also an immigrant to Bombay. Bombay, like the Konkan coast, never belonged to Maharashtra, it was a travesty of history and justice that got it included in Maharashtra.
RE:Migrants to Bombay
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 12:17 PM Permalink
Kant,,,How a Marathi can be immigrant in his own state? Is this a new theory or you are just dumb like all your other buffalos?
RE:Migrants to Bombay
by nitin on Jan 06, 2008 11:58 AM Permalink
Dumb Shrkant. Mumbai is always part of Maharashtra. Don't forget the Asthi island were part of historical state of Maharatta(Same asthi now developed in Mumbai). Pathare Prabhus are the natives of Mumbai who speak marathi. East Indian christian are the Kolis converted to Chirstianity. They speak language mixed with marathi, Portuguese and english. The Cristian of Vasai speak Marathi only. The AD of Pope is a marathi speaking christian.
RE:Migrants to Bombay
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 12:19 PM Permalink
Kant,,,,oh I know,,,as per Bhaiyya logic its in UP,,,,Yeah,,,well do you want to move Arabian sea to UP...Then it will yours,,,,do you?
In less than 3 weeks, we are going to celebrate our Republic day and we proudly say that we are a nation of over Biliion of diveristy, yet united. But I don't anymore believe this. Look at the comments in this disscussion, it's all about north, south, mumbaikars, biharis, UPs and so on. Why we are saying this in our pledge as long as we don't respect others - I love my country and I am proud of its rich and varied heritage. I shall always strive to be worthy of it. Jai Hind
RE:Divided India
by saleem ahmed on Jan 06, 2008 11:08 AM Permalink
well said.One hand we call ourself an indian but when some incidance occurrs we blame on others. In all the discussion peoples are blaming biharis and UP peoples for such incidance.They wrote mumbaikar has good respect for women then i asked why the same shiv sainik beat so many couples celebrating valentine day.
RE:Divided India
by saleem ahmed on Jan 06, 2008 12:31 PM Permalink
Are yaar dont be in anger when i said Valentine meraa baap hai.. Main janta hun ye tera baap hai..
RE:Divided India
by vinod suvarna on Jan 06, 2008 11:12 AM Permalink
yes man u r right...we are INDIANS first not maharashtrian,up or bihari... IS THERE ANY OPTION TO BURN TJIS ARTICLE
I am born in mumbai and one basic thing i know that people born in mumbai have this basic inborn abiliuty of dicipline. i have always seen ques at bus stops and railway ticket counters. I would even go to the extent of saying that even the underworld and mafia here are also diciplined though in unethical activities they never harassed commen mumbaikars, it is only the entry of migrants mostly from north we have lost our dicipline the biggest example would be rickshaw drivers and hawkers mostly whom everybody see breaking rules everyday, cause they have a "chalta hai" attitude in their states, i support uddhav thakrey in saying the migrants have bought shame to my mumbai.
RE:safe and diciplined mum.
by nitin on Jan 06, 2008 12:04 PM Permalink
Hat's of to you Bubeayji. Yes there are many of my friends from Up and Bihar who born n brought up in mumbai. They know mumbai very, maharashtra and maharashtrains very well. Even they are disturbed with the late north indian migrants who want to dominate this city on the basis of demography.
RE:safe and diciplined mum.
by anurag khare on Jan 06, 2008 11:11 AM Permalink
Dubeji if someone breaks laws or erect slums or illegal construction it is the duty of the government to control that, that doesn't you will take away the fundamental rights of people
RE:safe and diciplined mum.
by Roger Binny on Jan 06, 2008 12:23 PM Permalink
UPites and Biharai,,insects have no fundamental rights in their own State,,,what are you talking about,,,These two States are the hallmark of apathy,goondaism,mafia states.
RE:safe and diciplined mum.
by manju on Jan 06, 2008 11:21 AM Permalink
You are from Noth, right? simply taking birth in Mumbai doesnt mean that u are a Mumbaikar. Try to analyse why such things occur?shame on u who is cricising.
RE:safe and diciplined mum.
by Aditya Sinha on Jan 06, 2008 11:06 AM Permalink
shame on you! If Mumbaikars are so nice and you are one, you would not have said such a thing. If Mumbaikars are so nice, their would not have been any gangs, any hindu-muslim riots, nor Bal Thakaray or Daud Ibrahim. What is this nonsense you are talikng about discipline in Mumbai's criminal gangs, idiot?
RE:safe and diciplined mum.
by Manu on Jan 06, 2008 11:11 AM Permalink
Hota hain Dubay Bhai Chalta hai. I know a Dubey who converted to christianity. Chalta hai
BHAIYYA AND BIHARIS ARE THE MOLESTOR OF THE WOMEN THEY DON'T HAVE ANY DISCIPLINE . BIHAR AND UTTAR PRADESH SHOULD BE GIVEN TO CHINA IMMEDIATIELY SO BHAIYYA AND BIHARIS DON'T COME HERE
RE:molestor
by manju on Jan 06, 2008 11:24 AM Permalink
Better, try to get a resolution pass in the parliament, and ask people in mumbai to do all the jobs what Bhaiiyas and Biharis are doing. You will also find yourself in china.
RE:molestor
by rachna singh on Jan 06, 2008 11:43 AM Permalink
Some frustu marathi can write this....by the way its the people from other states with who's contribution Mumbai is known in the world today whether its Ambani's ,Tata's or the film industry I cannot see any marathi name???Sooooo,pls Mr.Coward stop blaming the bihari's & others for this shameful act.
RE:molestor
by rakesh shah on Jan 06, 2008 11:04 AM Permalink
if u have TWO children from that if any of them not educate because of circumtances what will you do?Give it to your nieghbor or try to work hard for good future so dont give up try to help the society for better future of our country
RE:molestor
by VARSHA PANDEY on Jan 06, 2008 11:22 AM Permalink
Better to see the names flashed on channel - more than 8 out of 14 are of Marathi surnames. You useless guy- keep on writting anything without checking the correctness. Only 2 in that list seems to be from North part.
