What about Maharashtrians out of Maharashtra?? Should they be also assualted like the North Indians are being done in Maharashtra...the north Indian population is more than that of Maharashtrians... So Raj and your goons of MNS beware!!
RE:What about Maharashtrians out of Maharashtra??
by vishwas joshi on Feb 12, 2008 03:49 PM Permalink
Maharashtrian outside maharahstra lives peacefully and dont makes rallies and comments abt local people........ do u agree with this my friend?????? and if they do..... I guess every state people will do the same like wht MNS did in mumbai. Tell me if i come to punjab and talk against sikh community - wht will happen??? will they spare me?????? I guess u got ur answer
RE:What about Maharashtrians out of Maharashtra??
by Rahul Kapoor on Feb 12, 2008 03:58 PM Permalink
A fruit vendor is more concerend about his livelihood then making comments about local people...if the Maharastrians have the guts hit well off people in Mumbai who are from North India...why assault poor people, taxiwalas, labourers...this only shows how coward they are...I am sure if this does not stop soon...Maharastrians will be assualted all across India....
HE IS ACTING LIKE A FOOL IN GIVING STATEMENTS WHICH ARE NOT IN THE INETREST OF COMMON PEOPLE. MAHARASTHRA - IS OUT OF INDIA ????? ARE TEH NORTH INDIANS DOING SOMETHING WRONG BY DOING A JOB THERE THEY ARE PUTTING A HAND I NPROGRESS OF TEH STATE ???????????? NORTH RUNS THE COUNTRY HE WANTS TEH NORTH INDIANS TO RUN OFF - IF SUCH THINSG ARE DONE TO THE MARATHIS IN OTHER STATES THENNNNNNNNNNN
RE:RAJ THACKERY - HAS HE SOME BRAINS????
by shailendra karandikar on Feb 12, 2008 04:23 PM Permalink
Yes,U r right, giving such statements are not in the interest of common people.Of course, maharashtra is a part of India and there is nothing wrong if people are migrating to maharashtra for the sake of Job. I also agreed with you on the front that North Indians are running the states in North India. Do you justify the way Bihar and UP is being governed? The states like UP and Bihar are still miled away from terms like industrialization, Globalization and other TIONs. dont you think that the state govts in UP and Bihar should do everything to provide Job and shelter to their Own people.Both the states are corrupt and have no future. Do you think that migration from one state to other will solve the problem of the Nation. If something goes wrong on Mumba( natural calamities),all north indians, South indians will go back to their own states to save their lives, Where the maharashtrians will go. Have you ever think of this? Is this migration going to make us Mumbai Like Shanghai and SIngapore. I will tell you a story: The ex prime minister of Singapoer visited mumbai a month back and he made a statement that If we want to make Mumbai like shanghai, we must control the population and migration.If a prime minister of singapore can think so rationally then Why we cannot? I being maharashtrian is ready and happy to welcome people across the country, But we all must understand the limits of the city. You cannot keep on pumping population into one city and leave it on its faith. Try t
RE:RAJ THACKERY - HAS HE SOME BRAINS????
by vivek majalkar on Feb 12, 2008 03:55 PM Permalink
u need not have to worry dear as there are lots of people to take care by the way make it clear that no north indian is making progress or running the country
RE:be good to others and good will happen to you. and vice versa...
by Ayan Mahapatra on Feb 12, 2008 03:49 PM Permalink
if u call the "terrorists" as freedom fighters and have more love for fellow muslims in Pakistan then u better leave this country. i dont know what islam teaches but can see that in the name of islam u guys r creating a lot of nuisance in this country. so please get lost.
RE:RE:be good to others and good will happen to you. and vice versa...
by Rahul Kapoor on Feb 12, 2008 03:59 PM Permalink
Hey man...I guess u are confused...this debate is about regionalism and not about religion...pls do not give colours of hindu/muslim here...
It is time for all Hindus to unite and fight tooth and nail divisive forces within or else we would be playing into the hands of terrorists and what ever has been achieved by India sofar would be destroyed! It is high time dividing selfish politicians are put to place. Central Govt. should act before it is too late!
RE:All shoulid unite
by Rohit Kanwar on Feb 12, 2008 03:46 PM Permalink
Its too late for Hindu unity. Right now the only person who is willing to defend things like chaath pooja and UP/Bihar people is a muslim named Abu Azmi. He will get my vote anytime.
RE:All shoulid unite
by Kolhapuri on Feb 12, 2008 03:51 PM Permalink
That is how the british ruled us. Divide and rule. That is exactly what Abu azmi is doing to get your vote.
RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by p k on Feb 12, 2008 03:59 PM Permalink
This is one of the most stupid arguements anybody can give. A land is not anybody's property. You have to buy it. It belongs to government. Hope it clears your misconceptions.
RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by Asheesh Sinha on Feb 12, 2008 03:44 PM Permalink
Your house according to constitution is your property. The state you live in isnt your property to govern. Learn the difference
RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by Milind on Feb 12, 2008 03:48 PM Permalink
It is about perspective... you are standing at the narrow end of it and I am at the broader end that is the difference...!
RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by devdass on Feb 12, 2008 03:49 PM Permalink
Don't think you have put in a clever argument! Take note thuosands of immigrant Indians cheerinf Indian Cricket team in England and Australia! If my house has been built by you neighbors and now you want him to get out. What about Indians living in US,Malasia,Singapore and Srilanka? You want them to be called back. You think twice before indulging in parochial thoughts!
RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by recalcitrant on Feb 12, 2008 03:51 PM Permalink
Milind - are you talking about Mumbai. Your logic seems to be apt for an older and more serious "Israel - Palestine" problem. I wonder why people can think of such issues only when their house is at stake.
Anycase, every person in this country has equal right to work & live anywhere he/she wishes. The very assumption that you consider Mumbai as your "exclusive" home is contentious. I can't believe few poor hawkers from other states as the cause of these problems.
As India is more urbanized, people have to invent themselves to survive. Scapegoating someone for your problems is not a healthy sign.
RE:RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by Milind on Feb 12, 2008 03:51 PM Permalink
If you think that putting burden on some body else is not wrong then you will not find any logic in what I have written...!
RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by AMIT DIXIT on Feb 12, 2008 03:48 PM Permalink
once house is once private property and mumbai and maharastra or any place in india is a national property.so two situation are totally different. why they are beating up taxi driver and froot shop owner who has stoped them of driving a taxi or starting a froot vending shop.
RE:RE:Why Should we take the burden?
by AMIT DIXIT on Feb 12, 2008 03:51 PM Permalink
like sharukh khan in chuk de humain states ke naam sunai nahin dene chaiye sirf ek naam sunai dena chaiye IN DI A
Dear Indian brothers and sisters : Don't consider the actions of MNS as representing Maharashtrians! I am a Maharashtrian, and proud of it, but much more than that I am an Indian!! I can vouch for a majority of Maharashtrians that we do not share the regionalist perspective of the MNS!
This country belongs to all Indians, and they are free to travel/work/settle anywhere they choose.
Look at the example of pakistan, they released the genie of partition out of it's bottle, and their country has already been split one further time. Now there is a distinct possibility of Balochistan/Sindh/NWFP separating.
If you want to focus on differences, you can find millions. This is a slippery slope to ruin!!
MNSwalas : aslya karyanne tumhi deshacha dusra partition ghadvaal. Mag Vidharbha, Marathvada, Konkan che loka regionalist zhale tar tyanna kaay mhanoon thambval??? Vichaar kara!
RE:MNS is not a representative of Maharashtrians!!!
by arunkumar singh on Feb 12, 2008 03:50 PM Permalink
hi...saurabh I too agree with you..but these people r slowly creating friction in society...its time for educated people to rise against foolish politicians..be it Raj or any one else
RE:MNS is not a representative of Maharashtrians!!!
by mike b on Feb 12, 2008 04:18 PM Permalink
although the message of oneness u give is true but the point u say of islam being the only propogator of peace and others preaching hatred is completely out of line.Just the way you muslims claim to love another muslim similiarly all hindus irrespective of languages do have their religion in common and unite as one when Hinduism or India is at stake.Also inspite of it's message of peace Islam does not unite the Pakistanis-(Baluchis vs sindhis vs waziristanis vs punjabis) or the Iranians who fought a long bloody war with the iraqis and still are at each others throats and there are many such examples of beautiful brotherly love in your muslim world!!It is good we are not having such goodness nor do we need to learn it from you muslim zealots...history is proof that muslims have fought each other,betrayed each other and killed in the name of Allah..may he forgive you guyz although it will be difficult for him to do so as he taught you love but all you gave the world is hatred and what not!And about other religions it is the prophetic religions which claim only themselves to be true and others a farce..all eastern religions have always taught love and peace and universal brotherhood and history is proof of this...So please don't preach to us what we know already instead go put some of your love to use in the Islamic world!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RE:MNS is not a representative of Maharashtrians!!!
by Rahul Kapoor on Feb 12, 2008 03:48 PM Permalink
Great thoughts brother...hope the MNS people will understand like you and not be led by the vote bank politics of Raj...othewise I am sure all Maharashtrians all across India will need to run back to Maharashtra....
RE:MNS is not a representative of Maharashtrians!!!
by deepak sinha on Feb 12, 2008 03:54 PM Permalink
plz don't put any ear to MNS and raj .we are unnessary giving him a publicity.if a billianoir throw a party then in that party u can see both amar singh and raj and they will eat same food without any differance .it's politicia's nature.so don't fight for these dirty politician.
RE:MNS is not a representative of Maharashtrians!!!
by mailme alladin on Feb 12, 2008 03:49 PM Permalink
Your view seems to be quite nobel here, but it doesn't matter. What matters most is Maharastra govt. steps to ensure - it's a paradise for every Indian. Govt. stand so far has been very callous like most other state govts. in India.
Probably this is the problem in democracy - a govt cannot be firm even against these divisive hooligans.
RE:MNS is not a representative of Maharashtrians!!!
by sks on Feb 12, 2008 03:49 PM Permalink
Great..thats the spirit. I liked it. People like you must have contributed for Maharashtra and India (at least by showing that you are good Indian)..Great
Most of the UP/Bihar Labour Workforce people have fled Nasik and there is an acute shortage of labour at present..... If all the labour community people from UP/Bihar goes out of Maharashtra then there will be an acute shortage of labours in the entire State... Even if all the Marathi people of Maharashtra comes together they will not be able to replace this labour community... And hence the industries and economic situation of Maharashtra will go down... Think about that before you do anything....
RE:Current Situation of Nasik to be felt in entire Maharashtra soon... If this goes on...
by Yuppie Indian on Feb 12, 2008 03:47 PM Permalink
This is true.. It will hurt us only.
