You got that wrong, UP has diversity, the Nepali/Mongol/Bengali tribes in Nort-East of UP, the Jat/Rajputs/gujjar and Ahir/Yadavs tribes. By the way Gujjar are akin to Gujrathi tribes. Not to forget the Moghuls/Turks (Agra, Shahjanput, Aligargh).
RE:Re:Rohit Kanwar
by D S on Feb 12, 2008 07:55 PM Permalink
They would have k*-ill-ed SHivaji if not for the Rajputs deciding that he needs to escape and Jats from Braj(Bharatpur and east Up) partnering with Marathas. Not to forget that lot of Marathis clans are still in north including MP. By the way, before Moghuls time, the rajputana extended all the way to Bihar.
RE:Re:Rohit Kanwar
by D S on Feb 12, 2008 08:04 PM Permalink
The message was in reference to population of UP. The UP is not just one set of people, it is many tribes and thus it appear big
WHy does Hindi take prescendence over other languages in India. MH politicians should take Hindi out of schools like in South India and we should promote Marathi. All signs in the city should only be in Marathi and in English. English only because we want to welcome those Indians who are law-abiding. By having English, we can welcome South Indians and other educated Indians who can't speak Hindi. Hindi should be banished from MH.
Furthermore, English is not indegenous to MH and India. The local languages of Denmark and Iceland survive despite everyone being able to speak English. Similarly, Marathi will survive. The problem is with people from UP and Bihar who think they don't want to integrate wherever they move because their language is "more" official than other languages of India. Why is Hindi our main language, when languages like Tamil and Sanskrit are more older than Hindi. I would rather learn Tamil anyday than Hindi.
I lived in Bangalore and know Kannadiga quite well. Why cant Hindi speakers do the same.
RE:Hindi
by Atul Narayan on Feb 12, 2008 08:14 PM Permalink
If you or your leaders have guts, then why don%u2019t you change the constitution and make Tamil the national language, we all will surely learn it being the national language. But, surely Marathi can not be made the national language (otherwise Indians will be taunted for igade-tigde). Generally also, general IQ level of Maharashtrians is very low compared to other parts of India. If Mumbai is the business capital of India, the credit only goes to Gujaratis. Maharashtrians (Igade-tigde) are only good for sanitary works and local goondas. Shiv Sena is a party of parasites. We had so far worshipped Shivaji Maharaj, but looking at the attitude of Thakreys and Ghatees, it appears that Shivaji was also a parasite.
Now what Central Govt should do??? They should deprive Mumbai all the benefits it had got including shifting of major central government corporations and stock exchange etc. to Gujarat. Maharashtrian farmers are already killing themselves and then local ghatees will also start committing suicides.
RE:RE:Hindi
by ashok sharma on Feb 12, 2008 08:05 PM Permalink
After a long time I have a such a stupid mail. What to do with hindi in these matters? You dont want to learn dont learn but refrain from making non sense comments to justify your stand. First stop you kids and anyone in your family and relation to stop speaking hindi, watching hindi channels movies. Thats the maximum you should do. Your mail is full of hatred and without any logic. Your Marathi guy's (mayor of some north district in karnataka) face was blacked in broadday light in Karnataka when he supported merging few districts in Maharastra from Karnataka. You have not seen how Kanadigas and Tamilians fight like dogs during Cavery water issue. So much for your developed states.No doubt that north Indian states are going through bad phase but this should not allow any tom dick and harry to spit venom against their fellow countrymen.
Can someone suggest what we can do about this. Some states in India are very corrupt and don't develop. Due to the lack of education in these states, the people have lots of children. They then move to other states and become a burden on the infrastructure. Should states like MH just yield to this burden and be okay with MH going down the tube or should MH put in policies to ensure the survival of the city and culture.
RE:Migration
by Atul Narayan on Feb 12, 2008 08:14 PM Permalink
Mr. ShivSena If you or your leaders have guts, then why don%u2019t you change the constitution and make Tamil the national language, we all will surely learn it being the national language. But, surely Marathi can not be made the national language (otherwise Indians will be taunted for igade-tigde). Generally also, general IQ level of Maharashtrians is very low compared to other parts of India. If Mumbai is the business capital of India, the credit only goes to Gujaratis. Maharashtrians (Igade-tigde) are only good for sanitary works and local goondas. Shiv Sena is a party of parasites. We had so far worshipped Shivaji Maharaj, but looking at the attitude of Thakreys and Ghatees, it appears that Shivaji was also a parasite.
Now what Central Govt should do??? They should deprive Mumbai all the benefits it had got including shifting of major central government corporations and stock exchange etc. to Gujarat. Maharashtrian farmers are already killing themselves and then local ghatees will also start committing suicides.
RE:Migration
by ashok sharma on Feb 12, 2008 08:11 PM Permalink
What development you are talking about? Where does MH lies in India on development scale? Is it the fastest growing state? Certainly not. you are talking as if MH is USA and you want to deny third country people. Do you know the truth about Vidharba? Scam of local co-operative banks. But you will say MH still better than UP/Bihar. That will show the level of understanding you have about development. Punjab has been the most developed state in India for so long. Have anyone heard such stupid comments from any Punjabi. Are you Maharastrian or making fun of them
