we know that dr amit kumar did not "kill" any body. but i want to know how many lives were saved by him through kidney transplantation????
obviously people dont have a kidney transplant just for fun!!! they do it when their lives are in danger!!
so just before calling this man a dr. evil and so on think about all those people who benefited out of him!! if you have a kidney failure and badly need a transplant then people like dr. amit kumar would appear as angel toqm3you!!!
RE:Just one question???
by on Feb 09, 2008 12:10 AM Permalink
People like him pretend to be innocent. But in NOWAY he'll be innocent. Obviously Money and greed is the reson. Even if money is not the reason, he can't kill some innocent poor (who are lured of jobs and stolen their life) Just hang them in public.
RE:Just one question???
by Sajan on Feb 08, 2008 11:11 PM Permalink
Avit... use some part of ur brain!! He didn't do it as a social service.. if he has done for poor people in India, u were right somehow. But he did it for foreigners through which he wanted to earn hard core money. By the way r u also in same profession???
RE:Just one question???
by ritunesh maurya on Feb 08, 2008 11:15 PM Permalink
Mr. Avijit please send your contact number. I know personally one of the human being facing similar problem. He needs your number for the kidney transplant so that his life could be saved. Do you have a courage? please donate your kidney for saving his life and continuing this great work initiated by your brother.
RE:Just one question???
by Nirpinder Singh on Feb 09, 2008 05:51 AM Permalink
Good Point. Our policies regarding organ transplantation are not in tune with the demands of today's society. There are plenty of needy donors and also persons in need of a transplant. So why not have a Government Agency to arrange a deal between the two to avoid such shady activities as done by Amit Kumar?
RE:Just one question???
by ritunesh maurya on Feb 08, 2008 11:08 PM Permalink
Yes but how about if you had been one of the victim, who lost their one kidney at the gunpoint. He didn't do anything for saving the life of any human being. The sole force behind his work was money. So he is a criminal. If he really wished to save the life of anyone, why didn't he use the kidney of him, his wife or his son. Why those belonging to poor class were used for such kind of act.
RE:Just one question???
by godzila on Feb 08, 2008 11:11 PM Permalink
yes. honesty begins at home. u cant take the kidneys away from the poor people without their knowledge. avijit thinks of him as robinhood ???
Yes right,he deserves a press conference. People in India always have flower on their ears. He usually goes to the Indo -Nepal border, to kill the animals and birds there. A close aide of him recently disclosed that kidneys of the poor animals and birds were used by him to transplant on humans. Its worth investigating in his domain of research. He knows the knowhow on how to do that, and in the press conference, he would reveal that. Another budding noble laureate.
RE:Press conference for what ?
by godzila on Feb 08, 2008 10:52 PM Permalink
doctor says he will organise a press conference after his release. but let him not be released from the jail, so he will not be there to give press conference.
RE:Raj Thackeray should protect kidney kingpin
by raj on Feb 08, 2008 10:37 PM Permalink
sure he will, when he can protect molested boys he definately protect this manus
Dr Amit is very poor. If convicted, Kumar will face a maximum sentence of five years or will have to fork out Rs 5 lakh as fine, or both. We all live in developing India. The fine for similar offense in United states is 26.8 million USD and a life sentence.
RE:India- a developing country
by raj on Feb 08, 2008 10:35 PM Permalink
whatever u say ( we all indians) our highest decision making body gives him bail, when mumbai blast people who killed 1000 people get bail and in future they get released, wats wrong with this Dr he has not kept any kidneys with him he has given life to others, people from whom he has taken out kidneys still living, he has not killed any body, tell me now , who is innocent mumbai blast people or This Dr i appeal the govt to release him
RE:India- a developing country
by Nirpinder Singh on Feb 09, 2008 05:55 AM Permalink
He had several lakhs of rupees in cash with him when he was arrested. He even tried to bribe the arresting Police persons. The man owns several Hospitals and expensive cars.
What does one do if a family member requires a kidney to save his/her life. Its high time we legalize transplants from brain dead souls in to the living. Dr(agon)Amit and many others are there in Illegal, Unethical & corrupt Trades in our society only because they complete the demand supply chain. Fast & swift justice is required to get rid of such evils. There are lots of such characters in every town, Its only that we are not vigilant enough to report them to the authorities and demand action and instead wait for 500 cases to happen before we run with a Interpol alert.
RE:He too needs a press conference. ha ha ha.
by Somanna on Feb 09, 2008 03:20 AM Permalink
Hi Roheet I believe there was no law regarding the transplants some 10 years ago. Because lots of poor people were duped into selling the kidneys, a ban on human organ transplant came into force(Its legal between blood relatives).
I am astonished for the fact that for the crime of this stature the maximum punishment is 5 years or 5 lakhs or both. Thats why all the people commit the crime repeatedly. It should be multiplied by the no. of people affected. In this case I surely believe it should be rigorous life imprisonment and attaching all the properties of the criminal ( pay some minimum monthly allowance for his dependents ). So everyone will know that all the crimes are not same and never ever the life will be same even if he is released from jail for good behaviour or any other reason. He has to work hard even for a living after released from the jail. Now even if he is released after paying 5 lakhs he is going to enjoy remaining part of his life with the multi-crores he has earned and money earns respect for him. Any thoughts ?
RE:He too needs a press conference. ha ha ha.
by Nirpinder Singh on Feb 09, 2008 05:59 AM Permalink
Why should there be a ban on human organ transplants between unrelated persons? If it is medically sucessful and necessary why should patients be deprived of this facility? The Government should think of regulations that ensure proper information for both Donor and Recipient and proper care for both.
RE:kidney kingpin
by Soy Adrenal on Feb 08, 2008 10:31 PM Permalink
Yes right, he went to Indo -Nepal border, to kill the animals and birds there. A close aide of him recently disclosed that kidneys of the poor animals and birds were used by him to transplant on humans. Its worth investigating in his domain of research.
RE:1
by Ravishankar on Feb 08, 2008 10:12 PM Permalink
A countdown (or a count UP!) for his release, knowing how well capable the Indian police are? ;-)
