Please read my comment in this ongoing fracas and give me a reply. Iam born and brought up in Mumbai, aged 35, mothertongue is tamil. I have a friend who is a Maharashtrian, aged 27 years. Who is more of a Maharashtrian, my friend who was born Maharashtrian and spend 27 years in Mumbai or me, who was born a Tamilian and has pent 35 years in Mumbai.For people like me Mumbai is all we have, as far as a city of birth or native place is concerned. How do you differentiate as to who represents the Marathi Manoos in this case?
Zindagi zhandwa phir bhi hai ghamandwa!!! Ye UP, Bihari logoko toh bahut udne lage hai. apna samjke ghar(mumbai) me liya; toh udar hi loot machane lage. ye sab bhi thik tha par jab ye log zyada bolne lage ki mumbai marathiyoki nahi wagara toh khun nahi kholega kya? Jai Bhavani, Jai shivaji
RE:Zindagi zhandwa phir bhi hai ghamandwa!!!
by Attatar Yena on Feb 06, 2008 03:45 AM Permalink
Jaga Ho Maardaaa jaga Ho !! Marathi Marda jaga Ho !!! Saglya amarathi-na heploon kaadh
RE:Zindagi zhandwa phir bhi hai ghamandwa!!!
by raj on Feb 05, 2008 12:39 PM Permalink
barabar aur ek gosht changali hai ki hya aayi ghalyani tond ughadale nahitar apalyala kalalech nasate lai majale ahet mhanun!!!hyana hyanchi jaga dakhwa re mavlyano!!!!!! jai bhavani jai shivaji!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RE:Zindagi zhandwa phir bhi hai ghamandwa!!!
by akhilesh sinha on Feb 05, 2008 03:45 PM Permalink
bihari mumbai aa gaye to tum log bahut hulla macha rahe ho. Mumbai wale US, UK, Gulf kya kele chilne jate hain?
RE:Zindagi zhandwa phir bhi hai ghamandwa!!!
by Marathi Manus on Feb 05, 2008 04:45 PM Permalink
Jis din pure North Indians road par aa gaye, us dil sab marathiyon ko Pakistan jana padega. Do not show power in home. Bahar niklo tab pata chalega. North indians raj karte hain sab jagah. Raj abhi bachcha hai. North indian power se takraoge to kahin ke nahin rahoge.
RE:Zindagi zhandwa phir bhi hai ghamandwa!!!
by Harshal Bhosle on Feb 05, 2008 05:44 PM Permalink
what did u say "dont show power in home" that just reflects your mentality. you people will never accept maharashtra as your home. so just shut your mouth .or go away.
RE:Zindagi zhandwa phir bhi hai ghamandwa!!!
by TANGO HAN on Jun 07, 2008 02:13 PM Permalink
jis din saare UP aur Bihar waale road par aa jayenge, tabhi unko pataa chalega ki duniya kitni aage badh gayi hai, Rapes, murders, in sab cheezon se waqt nikaalo aur dekho, Maharashtra kitna progress kiya hain, Education aur Political condition aapke states se Maharashtra mein kaafi achhi hain, security hain, stable life hain, UP Bihar ke leaders kyon progress nahi karte(karte hain, par khud ki) samjha karo, and from next time marathi sentiments ko disturb naa karo to achha hoga JAI MAHARASHTRA!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm a Maharashtrian born and out of Maharashtra (MP to be precise)and our family is there for three generations, never in my life i have faced any kind of discrimination,hatred or violence in my life just coz I'm non-hindi speaking fellow. and guess what my place Indore is largely populated by Maharashtrians (Even the MP representing indore is Maharashtrian). there are few localities where only Marathis can buy or rent a house (hope that will make MNS feel good). Still we are never taken as 'outsiders' or anything like that? I hope MNS knows what hunger, family and words like that means because thats the reason behind this mass migration. MNS should rather be proud that Maharashtra (or mumbai)provides livelihood to many even from out of Maharashtra and this really makes it Mahaan-rashtra. What does MNS want exactly sympathy, votes, attention or is it really a concern. But the likes or Maya, Mulayam and Nitish Kumar are genuinely concerned they should create opportunites in their states to put a stop at this Exodus. I hope that this hatred is not met with hatred and sanity prevails.
RE:Will i need passport to enter Maharashtra now being a non resident marathi???
by swapnil divekar on Feb 05, 2008 04:08 PM Permalink
not a gaddar! but yeah i extend my loyalty to "India" as a whole rather than blindly following somebody. kuey se bahar nikal mendhak!!!
RE:Will i need passport to enter Maharashtra now being a non resident marathi???
by rahul singh on Feb 05, 2008 05:29 PM Permalink
i really salute u 4 ur thoughts
RE:Only Marathis.
by adityakumar pandey on Feb 05, 2008 05:10 PM Permalink
Oh you own a company....are u so much literate...but ur thoughts totally tarnish ur image...is ur company a part of D company that u talk such senseless things?? if u r in trouble then a person living next door(whether N-Ind or S-Ind) will come to ur help and not MNS or any other political party...rise up and flourish..
RE:Only Marathis.
by Kunal Patil on Feb 05, 2008 12:11 PM Permalink
thats the spirit!!! Raj Thackeray Rocks!!! Let me know where to register for MNS in mumbai.
RE:Only Marathis.
by Nayan Panchal on Feb 05, 2008 05:13 PM Permalink
Dear Freind, We are here to earn a livelyhood. Over and above we are educated people whoes dream is to grow India.
I do not agree with you for the difference in Cast. We are INDIAn's first.
People like you and me shall never make difference between Castes.
My majority of freinds are Marathi, none of them has accepted Raj's Action.
RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by sivasubramanian on Feb 05, 2008 01:00 PM Permalink
Monish das, This is a good solution and good for the country. But i don't agree bagalore was developed only by kannadigas. Your staement may be true some extent to other places.
RE:RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by akhilesh sinha on Feb 05, 2008 06:54 PM Permalink
Monish u r absolutely right. Marathis are not gud workers thats why the HR gives us so much of money to come to mumbai. If Marathis are Gud workers then why the HR people will offer us so much salary to leave north and come to Mumbai/Pune.
RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by satish dane on Feb 05, 2008 11:44 AM Permalink
u sucker, where u eat there itself u shit. because of this mentality only u r facing such attacks
RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by Kunal Patil on Feb 05, 2008 12:02 PM Permalink
Monish, it is same like your house is not owned by you. i am sole owner of all ur property. have u ever been to mumbai & faced the reality? just because of few people like u all the north indian are facing problems. Jai Maharashtra!!!
RE:RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by sivasubramanian on Feb 05, 2008 01:07 PM Permalink
Kunal patil, Your example not correct to the situation, Have given the same right and support to your Dalit guys. I know many guys with fanatstic qualification are suffering in slum without job. You guys often attack them. Whether those guys will competate with others to get job or Fight you guys. I belong to a most voilent community, I know how my people's talent are wasted in anger and fighting and indiscipline. So i will ask you guy to adopt yoga like training and concentrate on all marathi developements. Atleast try to hold your Pune.
RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by pacificblue on Feb 05, 2008 12:07 PM Permalink
We want Maharashtra to be a separate country now. No more living with these dirty non-maharashtrians.. Let's burn them until they all get out.. Let's tell them that descendents of Shivaji can still teach these weaklings a lesson.
RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by adityakumar pandey on Feb 05, 2008 05:21 PM Permalink
Sir Shiva ji maharaj is history...u live in 21st century and talk of stone age...and bro if u get a worker(N/S-Indian) for ur company for a lesser rate i dont think u will look for a marathi worker...isnt it true bro????
RE:Mumbai is not for marathis
by on Feb 05, 2008 12:15 PM Permalink
monish das ek bat batao aapko agar maine mumbai chhodane ke liye 5 crore diye to aap chhodenge? agar ha to dal ke le!!tu edhar bas paisa kamane aya hai. mahman hai mahman ki tarah pesh aa!!! jyada uchhal mat aur rahi bat marathi logo ke kam ki aur skill ki to marath people are rocking all the way!!!in every sector every field. bas itana bata "5 crore milane ke baad kya tu khud ki g**d khud nahi dhoyega kya"
ye kya bol raha hai?? kya bol raha hai yaar.. hum against nahin hain lekin hum sirf maharstrians ke saath hain..kya concept hai..ye kaun hai yaar...ye log kabhi school gaye bhi hain ya bahar baith ke paploo khel ke pass huay hain..ye kaun hain yaar..ye sab kya ho raha hai..isse zyada samajh to mere 3 saal ke bhateeje main hai..use ye to malum hai ki coke peene se dakar aatee hai..
does raj thakre care of marathi living in UP and Bihar? What if UP and BIHARIs hitting them? I think, Raj thakre doing this for Marathi Vote in maharastra and not thinking in broader prespective.
RE:future of non maharastrian marathi
by ravinandanprakash agrawal on Feb 05, 2008 11:27 AM Permalink
vikas where did you get this weird idea from? how can you say that?? its completely out of the box..GENIUS..why dont you share your other ideas on politics with us..why do you think PM quotes rajiv gandhi as the greatest leader India ever produced??
I always thought Mumbai is one of the close-knit communities in India where different religions, cultures and languages live together peacefully. I cant believe Indians have started quibbling like this! I saw the videos in CNN-IBN and my god, they were really gruesome. These goons running into the streets, and slapping and kicking north-Indians, just because they look like different. We know what Gujarat riots did to the country, we dont need another one. Why people get swayed away by these cheap political tricks? I dont know what police and government are doing - India has the largest police force in the world and I am sure Mumbai owns a big chunck. What were they doing when this filth is happening? How come such molesters ride freely in the city doing what they wanted to - burning taxis, assaulting by-standers, etc. Until people stop getting tricked by these useless politicians and religious leaders, whose only motivation is divisive politics, there isnt much going to improve.
RE:SHIV SENA / MNS SIDES OF A SAME COIN
by brijendra jaiswar on Feb 05, 2008 11:07 AM Permalink
Only a marathi can use such a language...bcos thats what they are thought... Jai Maharashtara
RE:SHIV SENA / MNS SIDES OF A SAME COIN
by R@jesh Dube on Feb 05, 2008 11:22 AM Permalink
Dear Mr.San abcd, Don't be a coward when you dare say such things in writing. Maharashtra is nothing without the mix of INDIANs .... If you are really so concerned .. go & help your farmers who die due to hunger & small loans. It is not that Maharashtra does not have money ..... but still poverty kills people here. Lastly, Mumbai / Maharashtra is a part of INDIA & pls do not think like JINNAH.... Jinnah also thought the same way .. & result is infront of you. DO YOU WANT TO BUILD A NEW PAKISTAN. GOD BLESS YOU & YOUR THINKING. JIO AUR JINE do yaar... Thand rakho dost ... dont get carried away by these politicians who will enjoy our fight bcoz that will also mint them money & power.
Cool political drama, isn't it? Now MNS is known at national level, and it may represent itself as true saviour of Maratha community. While other side, SP may emerge as North Indian saviours. So, no doubt, it benefited both opponents. But at the same time, it did nothing good for a common man. It won't be any surprise even if Mr. Thackrey says sorry for hurting statements of north indians now, as his goal is achieved. It's same thackrey who was talking about bringing together all communities, when he started his so-called 'sena'. So nothing is unexpected from him. Nowadays it's common to read full hatred messages on rediff with saying like 'leave our place and go to your place'. What is your and my? This is my India, who are you to dictate where should I leave? What culture are you talking about to respect? First we should learn to respect Indian culture. People forget the meaning of metropolitan culture when discussing these things. When we talk about few cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai, Bangalore or Hyderabad, it means that we are talking about the mixed culture. It means that in those cities all cultures can prevail together. And mind it, there is no 'my culture' and 'your culture' type of thing in these cities. And still if someone is doing this kind of cheap stuff, it implies that he/she is not eligible to stay in that place. He should stay in some village instead. I read few messages regarding respecting American culture and comparing it to Mumbai. But bos
RE:'Your and My'
by prasoon chaudhary on Feb 05, 2008 10:38 AM Permalink
I read few messages regarding respecting American culture and comparing it to Mumbai. But boss, one need a visa to get there, so do we want a visa to get in Mumbai and cities like this? If we want to implement so in all states, it won't be one India. Finally, I still firmly believe that these bunch of people (including hatred messagers on rediff) do not represent whole Mumbai, overall they are good and are having the ability to accomodate any culture. Mumbai is not made by itself, it's people who are staying there, and the people who are working for it, made Mumbai.
RE:'Your and My'
by Rakesh on Feb 05, 2008 10:55 AM Permalink
WHY IS IT THAT NO ONE IS LOOKING IN TO THEMATTER WHY ARE PEOPLE FLOCKING TO MUMBAI I THINK MAJORLY IT IS BECASUE THE MINISTERS IN OTHER STATES ARE NOT ABLE TO GET MORE BUSINESS AND HELP THEIR PEOPLE AND IN SEARCH OF JOB AND A BETTER LIVING PEOPLE COME HERE NOW ITS LIKE HOW WE HUMANS ENCROACH THE JUNGLES AND WHEN THE WILD ANIMALS START ATTACKING US HOW WE KILL THEM OR CAPTURE THEM IN ZOOS AND WILD LIFE SANTUARIES LIFE IS GETTING MORE AND MORE COMPLEX FIRS THING GET PEOPLE EDUCATED AND SECOND APPLY THE RULE OF ONLY 1 CHILD IN ENTIRE INDIA.
RE:'Your and My'
by raj on Feb 05, 2008 01:03 PM Permalink
I dint get what do you mean to say? is mumbai a jungle or a wild life sanctuary? plz elaborate more. problem arises because of the wild animals and gets worst when some of them are well educated,have good command on english but still have no clear idea of what they want to say. but i really appreciate ur thoughts those are good but not correct
