In my view the larger disparity of income in the society is the main reason for such a hanious crime. In India it is the wrong policies of the Government of India which has enlarged the gap of poor and rich. Though we claim that ours is a socilistic society and the policies are of socialistic society, but it is not true. As per the statistics available the number of below poverty line peaple in India has grown faster, More and more people are getting rich where as number of poor is also increasing heavily. Summarily the governmet policy has supported the rich and enhanced the woos of poor. It is poverty which induces the poor to sell their organs to save the lives of their near and dear one and the people like Dr. Amit takes advantage of the situation. For such a crime if any one is to be blamed it is the Government and the people behind it and not the individuals. If any thing is to be believed considering the past Dr. Amit shall come free after investigation since all are corrupt who also benifits due to this type of disclosure and take advantage of the situation. G.P.Sureka
RE:RE:RE:Northy Docs
by Lobo on Feb 04, 2008 07:09 PM Permalink
he could not do it maharashtra. Such thing is possible in the north india only which chor north indian do and hence it is possble there only.Samje sharmaji..
RE:RE:RE:RE:Northy Docs
by Param Sites on Feb 04, 2008 09:11 PM Permalink
ha!ha!ha!ha!ha!ha!ha! do all south Indian people sound so uneducated like you? You are one funny uneducated man!! and you are most certainly controled by NORTHERN people coz' they can make you mad.
RE:Northy Docs
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 11:41 AM Permalink
may be because only northy doctors can do the transplant thing. these morons southis dont have any caliber or talent to do this. they can only treat fever...LOL...
RE:Northy Docs
by vox populi on Feb 04, 2008 11:54 AM Permalink
golden--check your brain--maybe you need a transplant but pls do not go anywhere near a "northy" doctor--might end up with something else
RE:Northy Docs
by Krishnier Natarajan on Feb 04, 2008 11:46 AM Permalink
I had a good laugh! Yes; the Northy Docs are smart in transplanting: Your kidneys!
RE:Northy Docs
by Koduvayur on Feb 04, 2008 11:50 AM Permalink
Perhaps this is the reason why major heart and other organ transplant surgeries are done in Bangalore, Trivandrum, Vellore, Chennai (to name a few) All these places are in north LOL
RE:RE:Northy Docs
by binu thomas on Feb 04, 2008 07:03 PM Permalink
Northy means stupid, North Indians who still think Ramjanmma Bhumi is the top priority for India They are blind religious fanatics, ignorant idiots in Bihar, UP, MP etc. No one take care to improve their standards. Even politicians came forward to defend serial killer who killed numerous childeren for organ business recently. The land of Mulayam, Lallu , Mayawati etc. Big shame on the face of mordern India. Killing anf frying humans in Tandori, Killing and eating people Looters in the train. Shitters on public places Cow dung eaters Cow worshippers Hates non Veg people, worshippers of monkey, rat, elephant Gods Stupid ,arogant , North Indian rascals . Now I think you understood who's northy....
RE:RE:RE:Northy Docs
by Param Sites on Feb 04, 2008 09:07 PM Permalink
Cool down Thomas, you don't sound very educated yourself either...now do you? I am from North and North is much more than what you have explained here. Get your facts straight and stop spitting here with half-baked truths. I have been to Chennai and seen people shitting on railway tracks, taking showers on the railway tracks, killing cow and goat fetus and eating it...what do you say about that? Are you telling me that in SOUTH people are not violent? Who are you kidding? Don't judge people by the news you read. Experience things first hand and then criticize. Have you ever been to any Northern state? I bet not.
RE:RE:RE:Northy Docs
by on Feb 05, 2008 02:15 AM Permalink
Dude..talking about north..where is LTTE from..u r most fanatic people who even do not know the national language.
RE:why are you scared....?
by VENURAJA Bowenpalle on Feb 04, 2008 11:46 AM Permalink
The kidney rockets are there in every country including most of the europian countries. In a developed country a kedney was stolen from a tourist right in his hotel room . He was found unconscious in his bath tub. The surgeons were experts according to the police, so they could extract the kedney right in the bath room and did not kill the victim ( left with one kedney) So you can not blame one perticular community. or one perticular country. The whole world become very commercial.
RE:RE:why are you scared....?
by Yaqoot Mir on Feb 04, 2008 07:24 PM Permalink
Nothing wrong with Pakistan my freind,,,,its better than this SHIT you called india for sure!
RE:RE:why are you scared....?
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 11:39 AM Permalink
i shall be happy to life any where. our lives are meant struggle and fight for the truth and help the opperessed and save the innocents. it may be in india or in pakistan. it doesnt matter to us. we live for the truth and shall die for the truth. we dont worship idols and then shout about greatness of vedas while vedas too condemn idol worship. it is height of blasphemy and hypocracy.... we are not hypocrite. we believe in purity from outside as well as from inside.
RE:why are you scared....?
by Hi on Feb 04, 2008 11:45 AM Permalink
Whom do u refer to We? People kill the same community, woman and children of their own RACE? So u are one of them? what do u meant by We? Don't sit in a cushion chair reading something and have a good life? why don't u rush for the cause of them who really suffer by violence? r u happy to see such thing? Do u feel proud of this?
RE:RE:why are you scared....?
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 12:02 PM Permalink
community is not important, it is the truth which is important. thinking community is actually a racial feeling in disguise which you people transplant in your heart in your childhood. any one who becomes enemy of truth and humanity, must be put to death. we are not like you who will support the killer modi and praise advani for spreading hatred. bad is bad and wrong is wrong always no matter what. but hindus are so selfish, if any one does something wrong in their favour they will appreciate it and if goes against them they just start burning, that's what we call hypocracy. as far as fighting the same community is concenred, what happend in the case of mahabharata, brothers against brothers, why? do you condemn or did your krishna condemn it. what he told, karam kiye ja phal ki ichchha mat kar ai insaan....... why not condemn the fighting of mahabharata although who was right and who was wrong was still ambiguous. we condemn molesting and insulting a lady in public and call them adharmy but the one who drinks wine (one mistake) then gambles (second mistake) and then puts his wife in bet (the most heinous crime one can do) is called DharmaRaj Yudhisthir....shame on you. your hypocracy only compells people to embrace islam which never favours any race, region of land. truth is truth only and it stands out of any kind of corruption.
RE:reason for the crime...
by varghese on Feb 04, 2008 12:02 PM Permalink
ALMOST ALL TERRORISTS IN THE WHOLE WORLD R MUSLIMS FOR THE SIMPLE SAKE OF FIGHTING AGAINST NON-MUSLIMS AND FOR THE CREATION OF AN ISLAMIC PARADISE SAME LIKE AFGANISTHAN,SUDAN ET AL..MOST MUSLIMS INDULGE IN ALL ANTI-NATIONAL,ANTI-DEMOCRATIC AND ANTI-SECULAR INSTITUTIONS IN ONE WAY OR OTHER AND BLAME OTHERS FOR THEIR SAD PLIGHT WHICH HAS BEEN INFACT BROUGHT UPON BY THEIR RELIGION,KORAN AND THEIR PROPHET...
ISLAM IS THE SOLE CAUSE OF MUSLIM DEPRESSION,FRUSTRATION AND LAWLESSNESS..STOP BALMING THE WHOLE WORLD AND BEGIN LOOKING INTO THE REAL CAUSE OF UR HORRID STATE
RE:RE:reason for the crime...
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 12:09 PM Permalink
first time the word fundamentalist was used for protestents christians who revolted against the churches. now they use this word to demonise islam but the problem is more they try hard more people read islam and revert to the right path of islam. i cant help from laughing on the helplessness of enemies of islam. for long CIA has adapted the policy of terrorism to scare its enemies and others ideologues. CIA confirms this on his official websites too. now these moron christians who dont know their own bible more than 2 page think what is totally absurd. yes, terrorism starts from christianity and spreads but muslims when fight for their rights, these idiots think that muslims are terrorist.
RE:reason for the crime...
by peter pan on Feb 04, 2008 01:06 PM Permalink
A crime done for money, is something that can be taken care of and can be controlled. But doing ugly things in the name of religion or some ideology doesn't really have an easy cure is like a disease with no easy cure. We have all seen what the Nazis did in Germany and it wasn't about money. Greed is a disease that can be cured but not so sure about terrorism or religious fundamentalism, Mr wise guy.
RE:reason for the crime...
by Prem Prakash on Feb 04, 2008 12:00 PM Permalink
shut up you gandagi. once you took your portion in 1947, you don't have write to say any thing. understand you fool. It is hindus kindness that you are still enjoying every thing.
RE:RE:reason for the crime...
by Yaqoot Mir on Feb 04, 2008 07:25 PM Permalink
Some kindness...before you are kind to Pakistani try and be kind to your own caste ridden society first...you Hindu meat lover
RE:reason for the crime...
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 12:05 PM Permalink
hindus are not only butchers, they also support lies and crimes if only it is against the people they hate. what can be taken the bigger example of a dirty mentality than this.
RE:who is responsible at the end of the day....
by Hi on Feb 04, 2008 11:34 AM Permalink
very funny. hope u'll be happy to have a life in Pakistan. All the best my friend...
RE:RE:who is responsible at the end of the day....
by Prem Prakash on Feb 04, 2008 11:49 AM Permalink
shut up you gandagi. once you took your portion in 1947, you don't have write to say any thing. understand you fool. It is hindus kindness that you are still enjoying every thing.
RE:RE:RE:who is responsible at the end of the day....
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 12:04 PM Permalink
hindus are not only butchers, they also support lies and crimes if only it is against the people they hate. what can be taken the bigger example of a dirty mentality than this.
RE:RE:RE:RE:who is responsible at the end of the day....
by jay kumar on Feb 04, 2008 02:23 PM Permalink
Ask an american/ britisher/ Indian/ Russian/ German about you and ya religion and he will let you know what you guys are into. Your claims are ridiculous. You are what the whole world sees you as. Clean your ownbackyard before you speak about ya neighboturs. You dont have the guts to attack from the front but send suicide terrorists everywhere cos you know that you cant win any war. You might wanna just shut up because you are trying to make a fool out of yourself and your religion
RE:RE:who is responsible at the end of the day....
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 11:37 AM Permalink
i shall be happy to life any where. our lives are meant struggle and fight for the truth and help the opperessed and save the innocents. it may be in india or in pakistan. it doesnt matter to us. we live for the truth and shall die for the truth. we dont worship idols and then shout about greatness of vedas while vedas too condemn idol worship. it is height of blasphemy and hypocracy.... we are not hypocrite. we believe in purity from outside as well as from inside.
Let the INDIAN GOVT. take the Initiation to seizes his properties and hand over the money to the INNOCENT PEOPLE whose kidneys were removed from selling house of Canada $610,000.,$65,000 rental Lexus SUV 350, and he all his properties immediately and to be paid along with compensation.
He should be punished by removing his kidneys and profession should be beggar(Let all the innocent Indian's give him Kick everyday, throughout his life till he survives. and he need to work as domestic servant in all the 500 Houses)
Request to Indian GOVT and Judicial Department: His punishments should be decided by all these 600 innocent victims.
Interpol: please co-operate with we innocent Indians. Lets have a public opinion about his punishment Govt on INDIA.
RE:Let all the public of India decide.
by Sunrise Consultants on Feb 04, 2008 11:31 AM Permalink
abey Lala pagal ho gaya hai kya? itna paisa milega to govt. khud nahi rakh legi logo mein kyu baantegi.
The Doctor and the all person behind him must be hanged.Goverment should not show any mercy on them.If these things go abroad its bad name for Indians Only.
RE:Doctor towards a Hannibal Carrier.
by Sincere Citizen on Feb 04, 2008 11:28 AM Permalink
Question needs to be asked is how come such grave "crime" go unnoticed for so long. I mean kidney transplants are not easy things to do are they ?
RE:Doctor towards a Hannibal Carrier.
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 11:45 AM Permalink
you are talking about islamic rule. indirectely you are approving islamic sharia in the indian panel code. yes, islam is natural way of life. if any body is left free to think, he will think islam not the idol worship and dirty things. implement islam and see the result. a crime free world. as far as fight for the justice, equality and human rights are concerned, this fight will go every where, where true islamic rules are not implemented. islam claims equal rights for every one so breach this right and face the lovers of islam, call it terrorism or what, but fight for the right will continue.
RE:Doctor towards a Hannibal Carrier.
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 12:18 PM Permalink
if you really want to know then read the islamic history by un-biased historians. they will tell you. even today the least crime state is saudi arabia, no female harassment, no money laundring, no murder, no rape, no riot, no killing, what else do you want? education is a must there for every body. it is not like shouting slogan for education and then simply sitting at home and enjoying the TV. any one who doesnt send his child for education will be jailed. that's what islam is. not only give ideas, enforce it too so that the benefit can reach to most common people too.
RE:Doctor towards a Hannibal Carrier.
by varghese on Feb 04, 2008 12:04 PM Permalink
LOTS OF PEOPLE WHO BUY SUCH KIDNESY ARE MUSLIMS FROM ISLAMIC NATIONS LIKE SAUDI...HEHEHEHE SO MUCH FOR UR FAILED ISLAMIC NATIONS..THEY SPORT HINDU KIDNEYS..HENCE WILL SURELY GET TO HELL..KORAN
RE:Doctor towards a Hannibal Carrier.
by Golden on Feb 04, 2008 12:13 PM Permalink
so this is your new information. may i know the source of this info. yes you cant provide. i just request others to look how easily an enemy of islam be it christian or hindu go lying. they dont even blink their eyes before uttering it. this vargi has just now invented one news so that he can demonise islam and muslims. please fellow brothers, dont give ears to these kind of liars who follow only the lies. please see the truth, read your scriptures and quran and hadeeth and compare and then accept the best you find.
RE:RE:Doctor towards a Hannibal Carrier.
by Prashanth R on Feb 04, 2008 07:12 PM Permalink
ok ppl, it's gone a bit too much. golden, it'd help to keep ur views to urself.others, it'd be better for us to jus leave this guy alone. one day he'll realize violence and fear solves NOTHING in the longrun.
RE:Doctor towards a Hannibal Carrier.
by Shalet on Feb 04, 2008 11:59 AM Permalink
AS far as I know, Muslims religion does not encourage the terror. You must be one among them & want to support the people who are actually doing the wrong things & getting bad names for muslims & the community. In the name of the religion, looking for their own benefit
Police and Politicans corruption is exposed in Dr Horror case. India is most horrable corrupt nation in entire world. These criminal Police and Politicians are supposed to safeguard citizens of this country but involved cutting humans to sell organs to foreign countries. These b*turd Indian Police allowed Dr Horror to dig out kidneys of innocent peoples. The Police, Politicians enjoyed Sex with Young ladies and Hefty Bribery ( in crores) supplied by Dr.Horror over the 8 years of his service to the nation. Now, its turn for Judiciary to enjoy Sex and Money which will be extracted out from Dr.Horror further to set him free of all troubles
He was only helping to save lives. Agreed he was helping rich clients but he was not killing anyone.
Think about this.
Is Dr Horror worse than Jagdish Tytler , Narender Modi , Sajjan Kumar who are responsible for the deaths of thousands of Indians in riots ?
Is he worse than ths politicians who organize riots , mass murders or who loot the country ?
Is he worse that police that does fake encounters and kills innocents ?
I think the real porblem here is the corruption and rot in the indian legal system , police and political system which sets the WRONG example to the common man.
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by RM Dayanand on Feb 04, 2008 11:45 AM Permalink
If he had removed one of the kidneys of yours or your close ones unknowingly, would you still defend them? These are the people who rock the civilization and must be put behind the bars till they die; lest them do another crime of similar magnitude.
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by varghese on Feb 04, 2008 11:45 AM Permalink
THIS IS THE PROBLEMS WITH INDIANS..HERE WE R AN HIGHLY FOOLISH EMOTIONAL PEOPLE..A RACE DEVOID OF USING WISDOM AND INTELIGENCE..
IF U ASK ME WHAT IS NEEDED HERE IS ' JUSTICE ' NOT COMPARISON,APPEASEMENT,POLITICS... HE DID MURDER HENCE HE SHOULD BE HANGED AND HIS MONEY SHOULD BE CONFISTICATED LAWS SHOULD BE AMENDED AND DEATH PENALTY SHOULD BE THE PENALTY FOR ALL THOSE WHO INDULGE IN SUCH HENIOUS CRIMES..ALSO THOSE WHO HELPED HIM IN THESE AND THOSE WHO WERE CAUGHT NAPPING SHOULD BE GIVEN VERY VERY SEVEARE PUNISHMENT AND BE TERMINATED FROM THEIR JOBS AND THEIR ILLGOTTEN WEALTH BE PUT BACK TO NATIONAL ISSUES ALL THE ADVOCATES AND JUDGES WHO HELP THESE PEOPLE SHOULD BE INDETIFIED AND CHAGES OF TREASON SHOULD BE LEVIED UPON THEM
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by Subramanian Manimaran on Feb 04, 2008 11:31 AM Permalink
Pls Donot justify by comparing these kind of cheats with politicians. Both are equaly dangerous viruses to the country. Both need to be erradicated from the world. The problem here is we all discuss for a while, after some point of time we all(including media) forget these people. Then another Horror/Modi will come up, or may be same Horror/Modi will do the similar kind.
Do any one remember/know what happened to the culprit of Noida murder case...b'se we all forget on the way of our personal life...and the media don%u2019t have anything great to sell it after.
There should be a follow up to any news otherwise there will be lot of Horror,Modi and several others
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by Darshan Trivedi on Feb 04, 2008 12:04 PM Permalink
For your Kind information Mr. V S, this guy wasn't a doctor at all. How he can help other people by giving kidneys. The operations which he did were out of his expertise and might have costed the life of victims. Anonymous
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by ashish sharma on Feb 04, 2008 12:05 PM Permalink
Dear V S
I have just one Q to ask in return to your Q.
Does a bigger crime negate the negetivity of a comparatively smaller crime?
Yes..... Nothing compares to the trauma suffered by families of riot victimes. But does that mean that we should ignore other crimes? And you say he was only SAVING lives. In a recent news item, it was reported that 3 turks died while being operated on by your SAVIOUR.
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by peter pan on Feb 04, 2008 01:14 PM Permalink
Perhaps you need to get your head examined VS. Supporting one criminal for another. Man you sure are setting a great example over here.
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by Prem Prakash on Feb 04, 2008 11:44 AM Permalink
apart from Jagdish Tytler, Sajjan Kumar you must add new edition Raj Thakrey.
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by V S on Feb 04, 2008 11:46 AM Permalink
yes basically these politicians are manipulating the poor masses and winning votes.
We need to rid India of the politicians that are eating the woodwork of the country like deemak...!!
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by Sincere Citizen on Feb 04, 2008 11:27 AM Permalink
Although your message sounds negative I tend to agree with it albeit it feels me with great sadness.
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by Dipti on Feb 04, 2008 11:24 AM Permalink
I'll ask you one question. What if you or anybody from your family had been his victim?
RE:Is Dr Horror really that bad ?
by V S on Feb 04, 2008 11:32 AM Permalink
And I'll ask you this ..what if you or anyone in your family was victim of riots or killed in fake encounter ?
which is worse ? The Dr. who saved lives (although illegally removing ONE kidney of people) or the politicians or police who brutalize the ordinary person.
He should be caught and kidneys to be removed lively (no anesthesia)that too publicly the operation to be carried out and left to die. Also should be telecasted worldwide. And the donee (rich patients buyer) who holds kidney should held responsible for poor donors life by giving employments
